View our special report on The French presidency of the European Union.
Just hours into the French EU presidency, the blame game for the myriad problems plaguing the 27-member bloc ratcheted dramatically with EU trade chief Peter Mandelson accusing French President Nicolas Sarkozy of “undermining” him.
“Yes, I am being undermined and Europe's negotiating position in the world trade talks is being weakened,” said Mandelson in an interview with the BBC Tuesday, referring to the growing rift between the French president and the EU trade commissioner’s positions on farm tariffs in the lead-up to the July 21 Doha round of trade talks.
Responding to Sarkozy’s Monday night accusation that Mandelson was ready to sacrifice European farmers on the “altar of global liberalism,” the former British minister said he regretted that, “Mr. Sarkozy’s intervention last night will make it harder for me.”
It was the latest salvo in a mudslinging match that has been doing the rounds for some time now.
Earlier, Sarkozy accused Mandelson of playing a role in the June 12 Irish rejection of the Lisbon Treaty. It was a blow delivered in the acrimonious aftermath of the Irish referendum, and for his part, Mandelson wasn’t pulling his punches, when he snapped that he was “mystified” by that remark.
Barroso under fire too
As France took on the six-month EU rotating presidency, the dossier of tricky issues confronting the bloc looks particularly heavy. And, seemingly with each issue, the much-touted unity of the 27-member bloc has been suffering the strain.
The Irish rejection of the Lisbon Treaty, by far the biggest challenge to the EU, has sparked a round of divisive behind-the-scenes talk even as European leaders publicly issued statements about respecting Irish opinion.
European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso has also stepped into the firing line, according to several British news reports, with French officials pointedly noting that under Barroso’s watch, three European referendums – in France, the Netherlands and Ireland - have swung no.
French and Dutch voters rejected the EU constitution – the previous avatar of the Lisbon Treaty – in 2005.
Barroso is widely seen as not having done enough to sway undecided Irish citizens to vote ‘Yes’.
‘A kid dies of starvation every 30 seconds’
But by all accounts, the rift between Mandelson and Sarkozy, reflecting the differing positions within the EU on agriculture and trade, has been particularly acerbic.
France has long opposed proposals for farm import tariff cuts in return for better access for European manufacturing exports in emerging markets such as India and Brazil. It’s a position that Mandelson has been forcefully advocating.
In a Monday night interview with French TV shortly before France took on the French presidency of the EU, Sarkozy linked the trade position to the global food crisis. “A kid dies of starvation every 30 seconds and the [European] commission wanted to reduce European agriculture production by 21% during World Trade Organization talks,” Sarkozy said. “This was really counterproductive.”
Counterproductive, interestingly, was Mandelson’s charge in response to critique. “Of course it makes my job more difficult,” said the EU trade commissioner Tuesday, before quickly adding, “but not impossible.”
























Comments (6)
Liberalising trade ends famine
As crops often fail across regions covering many countries due to weather, without established trade and the resulting capacity to respond quickly, food shortages are the result that only get addressed by aid when they become acute. Protectionism kills children not free trade. Free trade makes people better off.
Oh, and there has never been a famine in a democracy either. Another "unfashionable" view. So crude, dont you think?
I see Total is in Iraq, France is last in meeting its G8 Gleneagles development aid commitments, and the "new" troops for Afghanistan are in fact the same old ones shuffled around a bit.
Is this rupture? From here it looks like plus ca change
French defence
Probably France is defending farmers. But, dont delude yourselves: they are at best defending french farmers.
And using EU as a scapegoat to that end.
Sarkozy is a hero
Sarkozy defends French and European farmers in this deal. He is a great man to act so. He doesn't let down the EU farmers!
Sarkozy and the democracy
Sarkozy and Barroso don't respect the will of the Irish people. They want them to vote again for a dead Treaty.
Mandelson is not able to defend the EU position. What a good team with these 3 men!
Lisbon Treaty
Sarkozy and Cowen don't respect the rules of democracy. Barroso is a member of this anti-democratic campaign. They want to present them with the Treaty again.
Sarkozy - Barroso: the same man
Sarkozy and Barroso don't accept the Irish vote about the Lisbon Treaty. They want to make the Irish vote again for this treaty. Is it democratic?