Afghanistan - Taliban
France stands by Afghanistan commitment
Tuesday 26 August 2008
French PM Nicolas Sarkozy paid tribute to the ten soldiers killed in Afghanistan while French Defence Minister Herve Morin and French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner face questions from a parliamentary committee about the Afghan war.
Tuesday 26 August 2008
By France 24 with wires (text) / N.Germain (video)French President Nicolas Sarkozy addressed the regiment that suffered the heaviest losses in last week’s attack in Afghanistan in the southwestern French town of Castres on Tuesday, while in Paris, his defense and foreign ministers faced a grilling by French lawmakers.
“You are not responsible for the death of your comrades,” said Sarkozy, standing before soldiers from the Eighth Marine Infantry Paratroopers in Castres. “Death is not a fatality for soldiers. A soldier’s fate is to go home.”
Sarkozy confirmed that relatives of the ten soldiers who died in last week’s ambush in the Kabul province would travel to Afghanistan next month to see the place where the victims were last stationed.
But he repeated that France’s commitment in Afghanistan was not an option but a necessity. “This is a fair fight that we can’t afford to lose because what’s at stake isn’t only the future of a country tormented by an obscurantist regime but the future of everything we believe in.”
The French president confirmed that 30 soldiers from the Eighth Marine Infantry Paratroopers would leave for Afghanistan to replace their fallen colleagues and continue their mission along with the 2,600 other French soldiers based there.
“Nothing would have allowed us to foretell what happened”
At the National Assembly, French Defense Minister Hervé Morin and Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner defended the government’s decision to have French troops serve in the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF), a UN-mandated force that currently numbers around 53,000 troops from 40 countries.
“Nothing would have allowed us to foretell what happened,” Morin said.
“The opposition didn’t ask for a troop withdrawal,” Roselyne Febvre, who covers French politics for France 24, noted. “But many wonder what exactly France’s interest in Afghanistan is.”
Morin presented the preliminary conclusions of the attack’s reconstitution. He called it an “extremely concerted operation” where insurgents simultaneously attacked the column of French and Afghan soldiers.
He also debunked rumours that the French soldiers were hit by friendly fire.
In an interview published by French daily Le Parisien before the hearing on Tuesday, Morin said France was examining the possibility of sending Special Forces commandos back to Afghanistan to improve the army’s ability to gather intelligence ahead of ground missions. France withdrew its special forces from Afghanistan in January 2007.
In his testimony, Kouchner warned lawmakers that France would likely face new losses even as it tried to minimise risks.
"The situation in Afghanistan remains worrying despite undeniable progress,” Kouchner said. “As the sad tragedy of August 18 reminds us, it is far from being stable.”
French troops have been serving in Afghanistan since the late 2001. In April, Sarkozy announced additional French troops would be sent to Afghanistan. On Sept. 22, the National Assembly is expected to vote on the measure.
-
ANALYSIS
"Things have changed with the death of these ten soldiers in Afghanistan last week" - FRANCE 24's David Crossan, 26/08/08
Vidéo
Pour aller plus loin
Pour aller plus loin


28/08/2008 01:11:16 Alert a moderator
French soldiers mistaken - n'est-ce pas?
By Anonyme - USA Washington
So the wounded French soldiers reported in le Monde were mistaken? They were only pinned down for a mere 20 minutes before help arrived, and not 4 hours as they suggested. They claim they were hit by small arms, machine guns, & IED's - they didnt mention anything about mortars - they must have missed that bit. They only had rifles to defend themselves & soon ran out of ammunition (in 20 minutes NOT 4 hours?) And they were only 30 miles from Kabul in a supposedly safe area yet over 100 Taliban managed to assemble & ambush them? And yet there were US A-10 Warthogs only minutes away at the base in Surobi? Something stinks here! Either some were killed & injured by NATO planes by accident or these young soldiers were hung out to dry by an incompetent officer corps at the beck & call of the political class which supports the US Empire building activities. Either way the French public need some explanations
27/08/2008 00:11:23 Alert a moderator
mortars not bombs?
By Anonyme - USA Washington
So you are saying that the French soldiers who told Le Monde that they were accidentally bombed by NATO planes were in fact mistaken, and it just happened that the mortars landed on them at precisely same time as the NATO jets flew over the area? Why havent we heard this version from the soldiers themselves?
27/08/2008 17:04:57 Alert a moderator
Either mortal.
By Musashy - France/Paris
The explosion which killed french troops were heavy mortal shots, the use of those weapon makes us think that we have been sold by a spy in the Afghan Nationnal Army.
27/08/2008 02:19:21 Alert a moderator
Deaths of 10 French soldiers in Afghanistan
By Anonyme - Washington,USA
So let me get this correct - the story in Le Monde newspaper which interviewed French soldiers who claimed they were bombed accidentally by NATO planes was either
a) A pack of lies - the newspaper & the soldier interviewed deliberately told an untruth - a very serious offence and worthy of a public inquiry
or b) a simple mistake was made - the soldier couldnt tell if his comrades had been killed by small arms fire rather than high explosive bombs?
Either way something doesnt quite add up here
26/08/2008 18:51:58 Alert a moderator
No french soldier died because of friendly fire
By Musashy - France/Paris
Don t worry, you never bombed our troops.
The distance between french and taliban soldiers where very low and the air strike which aimed to allow french to escape were canceled. The 10 french heroes were killed by enemy's fire only. No mistakes were comited by NATO's forces.
I hope our dead brothers will rest in peace, and all the others all over the world too.
26/08/2008 12:08:45 Alert a moderator
French soldiers killed in Afghanistan
By Anonyme - Washington, USA
Has France 24 checked out the valitity of stories on the internet that some of the 10 soldiers recently killed in Afghanistan were the victims of 'friendly fire' when they were accidentally bombed by NATO planes?