Don't miss




Fighting unemployment: Millions of Indians face layoffs amid shrinking job market

Read more


Deneuve vs. #MeToo: Exploring feminism 'à la française'

Read more


Meryl Streep on gender equality: 'Something has cracked wide open'

Read more


Trump's presidency, one year in: 365 days of outrageous tweets and blunders

Read more


War in Syria: UN refugee agency denounces rape of men and boys

Read more


Poland protests for right to abort

Read more


Ethiopian opposition leader Merera Gudina released from jail

Read more


Apple to pay $38 billion in US taxes by moving cash home

Read more


'And the winner is'... Trump awards Fake News to CNN, New York Times

Read more

Socialist Left factions in dire straits in Paris

Video by Benjamin DODMAN , Thibault LIEURADE

Text by Benjamin DODMAN , Thibault LIEURADE

Latest update : 2008-11-09

In the 11th district of Paris, supporters of competing motions cross swords in the last days before the Socialist Party’s (PS) Congress. Despite the financial crisis, the sitting mayor's stronghold backs its leader, the moderate Bertrand Delanoë.

View our special report: 'French Socialists looking for some fizz'


Two weeks before the congress is held in the city of Reims, the various motions competing for party members’ approval are campaigning flat out. In the 11th district of Paris, on the east side of the city, the local Socialist branch – the French capital's largest has organised a debate so that each side may defend its proposals.


Socialist militants will vote on the different motions during the Reims Congress on November 14-16, changing their leadership and fixing the party’s new programme.


Daniel Assouline defends former French presidential candidate Segolene Royal’s motion. As the party bigwigs scramble for the top, Assouline underlines the importance of grassroots discussions. “The Socialist Party should really work on proposals in close collaboration with society, […] with trade union members, association activists, experts and not only through an process of internal debate and leader-worshipping.”


Yet, this Segolene supporter is hardly in friendly territory. Paris’ young and trendy 11th district is a stronghold of Paris mayor Bertrand Delanoë: more than three-quarters of the audience at the debate back him.


Laurent Cheno is one of them. However, he acknowledges that several motions look quite the same. “Two of the six motions are more or less the same. Delanoë’s and Royal’s motions are very similar in their support for the European Union. Benoît Hamon’s motion ‘C’ is more protectionist and therefore does not correspond to our European vision.”


Anything but Hamon in the 11th district


This European vision, shared by the representatives at the branch, is how the social-democrats stake out their difference from the farther left of the party – led by Benoît Hamon – whose popularity rocketed after the financial crisis.


Hamon’s motion is the most critical of capitalism, calling for a “radical” change of direction. Hamon also proposes an immediate reevaluation of the SMIC, the French minimum wage, at 1,500 euros a month and the relocation of production.


Socialist MP Danièle Hoffman-Rispal, who signed Delanoë’s motion, maintains that Hamon’s group is incapable of bringing the right solutions. “It’s easy, it’s demagogical, it looks left-wing… And then when they’re in power, they don’t do what they say. Hamon has never been a minister, but a number of his friends have and in government they didn’t do what was written in his motion. So that type of attitude really gets on my nerves.”


Patrick Bloche, mayor of the 11th district and a close friend of Delanoë, shares this point of view. “I find their proposals worrying, especially in terms of free trade. They are trying to reintroduce outdated protectionist measures and countries of the southern hemisphere will be the first to suffer.”


Utopia, an anti-globalisation group, underlines its differences


Even the anti-globalisation minority faction Utopia, though very close to Hamon, has underlined its differences.


“It’s true that the present crisis might make motion C more popular. Unfortunately, we reproach them for their lack of ecology analysis,” says Benjamin Grebot, who supports the Utopia motion.


The left of the left is unlikely to storm this social-democrat stronghold on November 6. However, for those here who think that the Socialist Party has drifted too far to the right, far-left leader Olivier Besancenot’s activists are organising another meeting just across the hall.

Date created : 2008-10-26