Latest update: 11/11/2008 

- France


World marks anniversary of end of WWI
On the 90th anniversary of the end of World War I, French President Nicolas Sarkozy paid tribute to more than 600 French soldiers who were executed by their own side for disobeying orders as ceremonies were held across the world.
By REUTERS (text)
Shirli SITBON (video)

Watch our Face-Off programme: 'History: a selective memory?' 

 

French President Nicolas Sarkozy paid tribute on Tuesday to hundreds of World War One soldiers shot for disobeying orders, in a change of tone on the first Armistice Day without a living French veteran.

 

More than 600 French soldiers were executed by their own side during World War One, many for refusing to obey orders to continue to fight after a bloody and failed series of offensives in northeastern France in 1917. "France will never forget its children who died for it," Sarkozy said in a speech paying tribute to the French and allied war dead that explicitly included those shot for cowardice or acts of mutiny.

 

"I think of these men of whom too much was asked, who were too exposed, who were sometimes sent to be massacred through mistakes by their commanders, of those men who, one day, no longer had the strength to fight," he said.

 

The 1917 mutinies, in which many regiments refused to move from their own lines, raised fears among French leaders that the army could collapse and led to harsh reprisals against soldiers who disobeyed orders to fight.

 

World War One, fought out in large part on French soil between 1914and 1918, cost some 1.4 million French lives and remains firmly anchored in French memories but there has been growing debate about the best way to mark the event.

 

This year's Armistice Day was the first without a French veteran after the death earlier this year of Lazare Ponticelli, an Italian-born immigrant who joined the Foreign Legion as a 16- year-old and who was the last French survivor of the war.

 

In his speech, delivered on the site of the Battle of Verdun rather than at the traditional site before the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, Sarkozy said the time had come to recognise that many of those executed had been pushed beyond endurance.

 

"That total war ruled out any indulgence, any weakness but 90 years after the end of the war, I wish to say in the name of our nation that many of those who were executed at the time did not dishonour themselves, were not cowards but went to the extreme limits of their strength."

 

The speech made no mention of a possible posthumous pardon but the minister in charge of veterans affairs said earlier this year that France would consider clearing the names of many of those shot for refusing to obey orders.

 

In 2006, Britain posthumously pardoned 306 men shot for desertion or cowardice during World War One, many of whom were believed to be suffering from psychological trauma.

 

There have been several previous attempts in France to rehabilitate soldiers shot as an example and dozens were cleared during the 1930s, but the most recent serious bid was rejected by former President Jacques Chirac in 1998.

React to the article
Comment this article typing your message in the above text zone. Please note that this is limited to 1500 characters or less.
(3) Reactions

Rembrance Day should not be celebrated any longer

It's time that the world moved on to better things. If we are to only remember the armed forces on this day, then we seem to forgotten the defenceless citizens who were not armed and therefore at the mercy of the enemy. Why are these the civilian victims for the !st World War forgotten?

With a UNITED EUROPE, let us not dig up the past but work together to bring an aura of PEACE to all peoples. By removing Armistice Day we will bring together the people of the European Union as brothers and sisters not as enemies of the past, but a family of nations that wants a better furure for all people.

I think there are two mistakes in this article

I think there are two mistakes in this article, first world war one was between the Triple-Entente and the Triple-Alliance, Germany is in the Triple-Alliance ,so it is not correct to say "Germany signed the armistice with the allies powers". Second, it is not correct to say "The commission recommends retaining Armistice Day, the May 8 celebration to mark the defeat of Nazi Germany",cause at that time Nazi is not appeared in Germany.

the necessity of remembering

the question of commemorating the two World Wars doesn't have anything to do with the European Union. We are no longer celebrating the defeat of Germany and its allies, we celebrate the bravery of the soldiers who fought in the tranchées and who didn't step back though they were going to an extremely painful death. Those were on both sides.

I'm only 25 but I've always been to Memorial to the Death on that day, with school or with my parents. On that day, we also remember the unity of France and the "valeurs", ideals of the Republic so many spit on today, afraid to be related to anyone. It might be a myth as the country wasn't living in perfect harmony at that time but they put aside the internal problems and unite to defend their country, our country.
It's no surprize to me that the first World War and the post second World War are such a part of the "imaginaire commun", that memory we share. We idealized those times but it is what a nation needs to feel like a nation and not a sum of selfish individuals.

As for the commemoration days recently created, I would agree that there are too many and I especially do not like the idea of repentance. I do not feel ashamed of our history and I do not want to apologize for slavery or for the colonization. It doesn't mean anything to anyone today. Yes, those times were unfair and yes indeed people have been tortured. But, though it's no excuse, France hasn't been the only violent colonizator.
and if we are to apologize for the past, I'd rather restore the memory of Napoleonian soldiers who have been disowned and treated like parias under the Restauration when they fought for their country and to defend our territory.

What I mean to say is that history is here to teach us lessons. Let's remember heroes, acknowledge there had been victims but let's stop being hypocrite or "polite" to the point of repenting for generations-old acts just to satisfy communities unable to move on.

Read more
Close