India - Mumbai attacks - Pakistan
India says Pakistani 'elements' were behind attacks
Monday 01 December 2008
India has formally accused "elements from Pakistan" of being responsible for a spate of deadly attacks in Mumbai after Indian officials said investigations had shown that the attackers were Pakistani nationals.
Special Report Terror in MumbaiMonday 01 December 2008
By FRANCE 24 (with wires) (text) / Christophe BAUER - Lise BARCELLINI (video)
Watch our Face Off debate: 'Mumbai: A Pakistani connection?'
India on Monday formally accused "elements" in Pakistan of being behind the devastating Islamic militant attacks in Mumbai and demanded that Islamabad take "strong action".
The move came after Indian officials said investigations had shown that all the attackers involved in the 60-hour-long assault, which left at least 172 dead and close to 300 wounded, were Pakistani nationals.
The attacks were also described as a "major setback" for the peace process between the nuclear-armed neighbours.
"The High Commissioner of Pakistan was called to the Ministry of External Affairs this evening. He was informed that the recent terrorist attack on Mumbai was carried out by elements from Pakistan," a statement said.
In New Delhi's first formal complaint to Islamabad, India said it "expects that strong action would be taken against those elements, whosoever they may be, responsible for this outrage".
A Jewish centre was among the targets and eyewitnesses said some attackers singled out Britons and Americans in two luxury hotels. Civilians were also gunned down in a railway station, hospital and a cafe.
"What has happened is a grave setback to the process of normalisation of relations and the confidence-building measures," Minister of State for External Affairs Anand Sharma told AFP.
Officials said they are convinced the Pakistan-based militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba, possible with assistance from sections within Pakistan's powerful spy service, staged the operation.
But Pakistan's government has denied it was in any way linked to the operation by the well-trained and well-financed attackers. Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari has urged India not to "over-react".
India and Pakistan have fought three wars and were on the brink of a fourth over a 2001 militant assault on the Indian parliament.
India's ruling Congress party said any response would be "carefully considered" but made it clear that a line had been crossed.
"We have been confronted by a rising tide of terrorism for some time but the attack in Mumbai was qualitatively different and calls for immediate and stern action," Congress party spokeswoman Jayanti Natarajan told reporters.
US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who is due to visit India on Wednesday, said it was crucial that Pakistan exhibit "complete, absolute, total transparency and cooperation" with the Indian investigation into the attacks.
"What we are emphasising to the Pakistani government is the need to follow the evidence wherever it leads and to do so in the most committed and firmest possible way," she told reporters accompanying her on a trip to Europe.
White House spokeswoman Dana Perino also said she had "heard nothing that says that the Pakistani government was involved," adding that US President George W. Bush was briefed in the White House situation room on the Mumbai attacks.
Asked whether Washington trusted Islamabad to help investigate the attacks, Perino replied: "We have no reason not to right now. Everything that they have said in their public statements and in their private statements to us has been encouraging."
Asked about tensions between the nuclear rivals, Perino compared their often difficult relations to a bone-dry forest in which one spark might be enough to touch off a blaze.
"In some ways that whole region is like a forest that hasn't had rain in many months and one spark could cause a big, roaring fire. That's what we're trying to avoid," she said.
"Obviously we want to help reduce tensions wherever possible. The good news is that the Pakistanis and the Indians have an open line of communication. This is something they didn't have just even a few years ago," she said.
"We have encouraged them to open that line of communication, and the Indians have gotten some responses from the Pakistanis that they are committed to following through on this investigation. That's a good and positive step. We need to continue to make sure that that helps," said Perino.
Pakistan has repeatedly underlined that it is fighting its own battle against Islamist insurgents, who have taken their bloody campaign to the heart of the Pakistan capital and stressed the two nations have a common enemy.
Lashkar, which has been battling Indian troops in Kashmir, was banned by Pakistan in 2002.
Public outrage in India was fuelled Monday by fresh reports that clear warnings of a coming assault were ignored.
The Hindustan Times said a captured Lashkar operative had told his Indian interrogators back in February that the militant group was planning an attack on Mumbai's five-star hotels.
Tension between India and Pakistan date to the post-independence partition of India in 1947 that created the Islamic state of Pakistan and led to horrific bloodletting between Muslims and Hindus.
India has also had its share of homegrown unrest, from Muslims to Maoists to Hindu extremists, and Indian officials have repeatedly declined to blame Pakistan directly for the Mumbai attacks.
-
IN THE FIELD
"The attackers followed a 1-year training program in Pakistan"
France 24 correspondent Sebastien Dagueressar, Mumbai, 01/12 -
REPORT
The resentment of the Muslim community in India
France 24 report by L.Thomas-Richard, T.Ellis, S.Dagueressar and N.Rushworth, 01/12 -
VIEWPOINT
Mumbai Mirror photographer Sebastien D'Souza took a photo of an attacker in action, who was later arrested
France 3 report, 1/12/08
Vidéo
Pour aller plus loin
Pour aller plus loin
Pour aller plus loin


04/12/2008 16:14:19 Alert a moderator
Forgetting
By Concerned - Norway
Balwinder, it is indeed unfortunate that you have been treated with such inconsideration, however I feel the attacks in Europe has been largely "forgotten" as well by the world. It is certainly not spoken of often. And that is a dangerous thing, I think. I would also like to offer you MY condolences, as I noticed that this attack has been treated as "low-key" as well by a numbed media and people when its repercussions assuredly are grave. Had I known any Indian people I would have done the same to them, and I don't even see myself as especially compassionate. It is clear that India is subject to much of the same terrors as Europe and The USA, and it is my belief that we'd do well to stand together in the face of this threat. I hope this illustrates that there are Europeans who are understanding of what has happened, and I am ashamed of those who disregard it. I hope you get whoever is behind this.
04/12/2008 05:12:26 Alert a moderator
Terror and SoLLUTION
By M Ariely - Israel
Terror and solution
A:Terrorism serves some Muslim regimes aspiration
B;Double language:Talking softly to west
Encouraging extremism inside against infidels
C:Acting against extremists only when their regimes are in danger
Shielding extremists from their victims justes
D;What is needed?
CHANGE OF BASICS
Close madras's teaching extremism
Forbid@act against hate preachers in Mosks&Media
Accepting multicultural rights&enforce the law
Update DAR EL ISLAM-DAR EL HARB to
LOVE ALL HUMAN
03/12/2008 14:19:41 Alert a moderator
Mumbai attack
By Balwinder - Paris/New Delhi
I was on a tour of France with my Americans when this attack took place in Mumbai. The reaction of one of my guests was" why is CNN only covering this? Only 200 people died". I was shocked and told her it was like 9/11 and she said "oh! but 3,000 Americans were kikked!" I was too shocked to comment on this as in fact it reflects the opion of many Americans and Europeans too! not one of my colleagues who all know I am Indian even offered condolences. So now another attack in India is going to be forgotton if not already done by the International community. We in India have been suffering such attacks constantly in India and Kasmir and except for the Soviets no country even looked onto the Kashmir issue! we are under attack since 1947 by terrorists! will more people have to die before action is taken?
03/12/2008 08:54:00 Alert a moderator
I am Shoked when i think
By Rashmi - Bhubaneswar
I don't understand why people do this.Are they getting more money?and how only few people can capture three big buildings?It is really a shoking thing.If any one of my family would be there then what?All should think in this way....
02/12/2008 22:36:17 Alert a moderator
clarification
By yuvraj korpe - mumbai
i had held the banner reading "All the HARDLINER political parties"; here the stress was on d religion-based parties n not on all d political parties. as these hardliners had severely criticised our martyr 'hemant karkare' for malegaon blast investigation n he had to lay down his life to prove his integrity towads his job n countrymen. let there b no political interference into the work of r forces n investigating agencies atleast in matters of national security. however at the same time i also appriciate the hardwork put in by reporters like leela jacento into the hour of crisis by patiently listening to the aggitated people around. we indian pray for relatives who lost their dear ones including d relatives of the young terrorists killed;who unfortunately failed to incorporate the supremacy of love n peace into the hearts of these young lads. god bless their souls.let the world come together by solving problems with alms n not with arms.-yuvraj korpe.
01/12/2008 10:32:11 Alert a moderator
Razza you are right
By Anonyme - RDC/Goma
Dear friend, i am sorry to what has happened to India and every body is sorry for it but you need to regognize the responsibility of your country in this issue because no one can understand how this could happened since India is highly protected. In stead of thinking on the improvement of the security in India, now every body is focusing on Pakistan. How to protect innocents should be the main focus. I am sorry because if India react like USA in Afganistan, innocents will die more and more. All people have the same right. The point of Kazza is not stupide. Kazza is right at 100%. Thanks
30/11/2008 22:15:54 Alert a moderator
God bless the Indian commandos and police
By Anonyme - USA
I have been to the taj hotel it is a very large hotel with many openings and exits. It would be extremely difficult to clear out hostages and take out terrorists.
The Mumbai police and commandos are true Heroes!
29/11/2008 17:51:48 Alert a moderator
How stupid point
By Parvesh kumar - india
Your point is so stupid because without getting into the facts you are giving this kindof point, just for the final investigation and then decide wht is right and what is wrong.
29/11/2008 16:00:15 Alert a moderator
What are the Pakistanis talking about?
By Anonyme John herbert - England
There have been lots of terrorst attacks 9/11,Jaipur, Bomabay etc and now 26/11 one of the worst happennongs in the whole history of Mumbai and India.
We know quite well that Muslims have been heavily involved, brainwashed , propulsed by International Muslim groups to perpetrate such actions all over the place to create havoc , destruction and demoralisation to peace loving people and citizens whereevr they may be and this in the beloved name of Allah! !
Now the militants who have been killed and one who has been captured alive, has confessed he has links with Pakistan and no doubt that the well planned movement from the trainers and their involvement had been prepared well in advance . The number of heavy geared weapons and guns , artillery cannot come from a small group of rascals , miscreants who just wanted to have some fun. They are Muslims and have emanated from Pakistan who now is on the forefront to try and say they are not aware and involved in whatever way .
These militants being brainwashed were claiming to be from Deccan Muhajedeen or what , a pure invention from the Authorities who guided them through to mislead the world .
No stone to be left unturned and those involved severely dealt with once demythtified. Innocent lives again lost at the detriment of God!!! The authorities in India also have been lax with the invasion of Mubai by what 10-20-40 terrorists?? They should be more concerned and India as a whole should work together to avoid such things happening.
29/11/2008 12:18:17 Alert a moderator
Thank you India
By Patrick Warner - USA/NYC
All these terrorists have accomplished is proving to the world that they consider life meaningless and that are just outright savages. They even shot into the crowd outside. What they have achieved for themselves is a status below zero. They are uncivilized. The Indian commandos removed them the face of the earth so they would be unable to do iit again. Civilization must close its ranks and purge and remove such savages ffrom the face of the earth. Thank you India and its soldiers for doing what needed to be done..
29/11/2008 12:05:48 Alert a moderator
religion
By Anonymejohn connolly-bond - uk
please print my comments you are printing others why not mine do you not belive in freedom of the press are freedom of speach i personal went to a war for this FREEDOM OF MOVEMENT / FREEDOM OF SPEECH ALL OF THESE RELIGIOS ARE ALLOW TO STAD ON THEIR SOAP BOXES AND SAY JUST WHAT THEY WISH I PERSONAL HAVE NO RELIGION IT CAUSES TO MUCH TROUBLE IN THIS WORLD LOOK AROUND YOUR SELF I DONT KNOW WERE I CAME FORM I DONT KNOW WERE I AM GOING
29/11/2008 10:19:18 Alert a moderator
mumbai atacks a CONSPIRACY!
By raza - usa
I am a student of journalism and I’ve raising this point since I have caout up wth news about mubai attacks I did post this comment earlier on YouTube but they removed it, which I think clearly proves my point! The indians think made it all up! IT’S A CONSPIRACY, even If a Pakistani kid/child accidently enters the indian border, they kill him/her and how is it that the hostage takers came to india on a boat, and the indian navy never noticed, how stupid is this and the indinas keep on bluffing about their the power of their navy? Hahahah…Moreover the indians just want to blame Pakistanis for no reason, they weren’t sure from the beginning and till now aren’t sure how many hostage taker were there in the hotel ,but they were sure that they were Pakistanis, again how idiotic…This clearly show that it’s a conspiracy! So I need to know how many of us agree to my point?
28/11/2008 22:03:53 Alert a moderator
I visited a site and liked a comment, it say:
By Simon Mohammed - USA
This is time that the muslim need to change all the way of their thinking:
I read other comment and article, and i felt the need to write a comment and share it with you in this site, I hope it is not arrogante:
---
And i mean it, Every one.
First i am sending my sincer condoleances to all humanity.
second: why we all need to change the way of thinking it is because 143 killed, arround 400 or more injured and the start of this masacre are:
1- islamist group, not proved yet likely will be
2- 2 Giant countries if they don't use wisdome can clash and it will be a new disaster
3- The importantes people who been killed arround 17 (UK, USA, French, Israeli Etc
and the rest who are human maybe most of them are Indian arab, muslim do not count.
and that is why i think every one need to change the way of thinking.
We the human are all under attack and we do not know for sure who is behind it, we speculate.
again my sincers condoleances to the humanity.
Best regard
28/11/2008 14:43:58 Alert a moderator
How can Muslims be one sided and not caring for other communitie
By Anonyme/Humanity - England
" Many who blames muslims thing. The growing feeling of insecurity and lose of trust of the majority of
indian moslems in their home land.India is the home land of Indian moslems too.Accept that"
signatory Indian Moslem.He is saying that India is the homeland of Indian Moslems too. Who is saying that it is not?But does he try to mean and say that India is not the homeland for Bharat Hindus and other communities?The very fact that Muslim terrorists are conducting these attacks and have been targeting Mumbai holding the city in siege are they Indian Moslems or are they backed by external forces most probably Muslims themselves who are well known world over to conduct such businesses for such a long time?To this Indian moslem who posted this view and to all others who have elected to live in Bharat India: Have they not thrived on this soil and succeded as any other Hindu.Millions of those Indian moslems have been given the opportunity to live successfully without any prohibition.or distress.Does he mean that Hindus or other communities,peace loving citizens need to suffer at their detriment?Our Hindu community too have the right to live in this India which Muslims are desecrating. To kill.To mortify. They should be ashamed to call themselves humans.There must be other forces behind these horrific attacks. They pretend to target the British,etc. So why choose Mumbai to carry out these attacks? They have created chaos to the most beautiful hotels in the world and it's not American,Britishor Jewish. It's bloody Indian lest he forget! If you have a grudge against them go there, NOT here in MUMBAI.
And adding further:Do educated Muslims understand the fact that they should live and work decently where they are rooted ? This is the saddest part of it too.You seem to forget that Hindus and others' homeland is India. Accept that ! Work together as Indians , as you seem to approve?Do you.?
27/11/2008 21:16:39 Alert a moderator
Mumbai Innocent Victims
By Anonyme Jean - Paris
On Thursday, one of the gunmen holed up in the Trident-Oberoi hotel told the India TV channel by phone that they wanted an end to the persecution of Indian Muslims and the release of all fellow Islamic militants detained in India.
This is a quote from the news on Thursday --- The terrorists are saying that there is a persecution(!) of Indian Muslims and wanted a release of all fellow Islamic militants detained in India.
These militants, as they say, are their fellow men. Therefore all of the same feather: terrorists.
Why in the first place were they being detained ? Are they being persecuted or guilty of terror attacks or simply connected with just to blow up India? These present terror attacks have been well planned and have tried to disseminate their attacks in the whole city targeting prominent places such as the Taj , Oberoi, VT station etc. They wanted to blow the airport too. This means that this orchestrated movement has been propulsed from fertile minds to kill innocent lives and who are those who have supplied these grenades, explosive weapons, guns, and what other arsenal intended to create chaos and havoc.
Whosoever are behind this must be laughing seeing their sick motives being actioned. These youths do not value human life as they themselves have been killed in the encounter. This means that if they do not respect their own lives how can they respect others'.
Whatever terrorist is left and caught should be dealt with severely and all those connected with such crimes should have the utmost sentence without any pity shown to them
27/11/2008 20:29:22 Alert a moderator
Death Toll
By Alexander Dale - New York City
As the death toll in this Al Qaeda attack climbs rapidly past the hundred mark think back to what it was like for New Yorkers to have 2,783 people murdered where we live.
And to how sucessful the 'Unilateral Cowboy Diplomacy' the hand wringers of the world have never stopped whining about has been in keeping it from happining here again.
Time for Prime Minister Singh to saddle up ...
27/11/2008 19:21:14 Alert a moderator
Bombay under attack! Why?
By Krapotkin - USA
Beside the Kashmir conflict, India has been under a perennial religious,tribal and economical bloody conflicts, seldom relayed in the western media. We had a massive attacks on Muslims,Christian and poor farmers, from Indou extremist and mercenaries paid by industrial interests needeing cheap lands for industrialisation, almost on daily basis.
I opine, that there is no need to blame oustsiders for the Bombay tragedy, too many peoples within India, are pushed daily to the limits of acceptable conditions, that generates a bloody reactions, such as the world is witnessing today!!!
Houston,TX
27/11/2008 18:25:59 Alert a moderator
Terrorists
By Anonyme - Bound Brook NJ USA
It is zealots and extremists of any religion or "ism" which are the problem for humankind, not Islam per se. Insanity seems to be fairly evenly distributed across the human race - it is up to civilized people to cooperate and contain the crazy ones! I am not Muslim, yet my own religion has had its share of lunatics. Pray as if it its all up to whatever God you believe in, work as if it is is all up to us, co-operate with like-minded people.
27/11/2008 15:52:49 Alert a moderator
Mumbai
By M.LeClerc - Aquitaine, La France
Several world leaders you report have condemed these attacks by this group of murderous criminals.
Why haven't we seen reports of condemnation by muslim leaders? Surely they should be outraged that these gangsters are carrying out acts of murder[a crime in any religion] in the name of their religion.
27/11/2008 14:14:46 Alert a moderator
bombay (Mumbai)
By Anonyme.joseph walker - sherborbe dorset uk
The only ones confused are CNN and the english broadcast news media,The indians will soon sort out the situation,these broadcast media are to ignorant ,thier news panders to the uneducatd and ignorant people in thier respective countries.ps these media should remember thier own terrorist carnage in new york.i suppose nobody paniciked travelling to america..get educated .Alqueda is more intelligent than the news media ,they know thier strategey of misinformation will pander to thier ignorance
27/11/2008 13:19:26 Alert a moderator
Tragidy
By Bek Dam - Imo State Nigeria
Mumabi is now a dead trap for foreigners, I am in Mumbai now and has been a nightmare to the inhabitants of this surbord, I suggest that the global village should aid the Indian forces to control this situation as many foreigners are still traped in some of the attacked hotels.
27/11/2008 10:58:46 Alert a moderator
Mumbai Attacks
By Anonyme -
We are given to understand that the terrorists have gained access to Mumbai city by Alfa vessel and disembarked using inflatable boats to firm land. However I find it difficult to comprehend how they did enter the Taj or Oberoi with weapons, grenades and a series of arsenal without being noticed by any member of the staff or anyone.
I have not seen this being scrutinized yet, unless I am wrong in saying so. These terrorists have gained the hotel premises on the 15th floor or the 5th floor of the hotels targeted without being disturbed as it looks. How ?
Also all the other targeted locations .
And the loss of innocent lives is again emphasized here where punishments by law are very often too generous towards crimes to society.