- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 06/12/2008
- France - justice - murder
Judge reopens case of four-year-old Gregory, murdered in 1984
A French judge decided Wednesday to reopen one of France's darkest murder mysteries in the hope that DNA tests can help find the killer of Gregory Villemin, who was found drowned in 1984 when he was four years old.
AFP - A French judge decided Wednesday to reopen one of France's darkest murder mysteries, in the hope DNA tests can help find the killer of a four-year-old boy, 24 years ago, lawyers said.
Gregory Villemin was found tied up and drowned in the Vologne river in a bleak area of the Vosges mountains in eastern France in October 1984.
A day later, a poison-pen letter arrived at the home of the child's parents -- who had been receiving anonymous hate mail since 1981 -- claiming responsibility for the murder, and calling it "revenge."
The killing sparked a 17-year legal saga that was wrapped up in 2001, after failing to identity either the killer or the sender of the mysterious letters.
Christine and Jean-Marie Villemin, who have both served time in prison in connection with their son's killing, sought to have the case reopened to allow for DNA testing of the rope used to tie up their son.
Their lawyer, Marie-Christine Chastant-Morand, said the appeal court in eastern Dijon had agreed to allow investigators to search for traces of DNA on evidence seized during the probe.
The case of "Little Gregory," as it is known, became one of France's most notorious post-war criminal mysteries, as police sought to untangle a web of family hatreds and local jealousies.
A second cousin of the child, Bernard Laroche, was charged with the killing, based on evidence given by a sister-in-law, but was released from custody after she withdrew her claims -- only to be shot dead by the boy's father in 1985.
Jean-Marie Villemin spent two and half years in prison for the crime.
Later that year, his wife Christine was charged with her son's murder. She was finally cleared eight years later and all charges against her dropped.
The inquiry was reopened briefly in 2000 to allow for DNA testing of a stamp on a hate letter sent to the Villemins months before the murder, but the probe yielded no new clues to the killer's identity.
Read more
‘Darth Vader’ demands free land from Ukrainian government
Browse all editions
React to the article
(2) Reactions
'Affaire Gregory', DNA tests
The DNA analysis won't be performed on the ropes which were used to tie up the little boy but on the enveloppes that were used to send hate mails to the Villemin family. At that time, people had to lick the flat of enveloppes to make them stick. So hopefully they will give a clue, even a quarter of a century later.
It still remains that had the forensic surgeon done his/her job properly, the contents of the boy's lungs would have been analysed and the suspicion of his mother accidentally let him drown in his bath would have been either confirmed or infirmed.
A sad screw up.
Grégory
If the report is correct that the intended DNA extraction is from the rope which bound the childs hands, then it is 24 years too late. This rope was in water, the deposition of DNA would have been of the 'cellular type' that is through sweat, easily washed off. Also if the likely suspect remains the mother then as I recall the rope originated from the family home, any highly unlikely DNA profile of a family source generated by the process would be useless.What the investigative process requires is an impartial review of any forensic opportunities not recognised or pursued by the current investigative team. Latvia, I would suggest is more advanced in DNA processing than France. Unfortunately France would appear to be forensically naeive in believing it can achieve what the rest of the world cannot.