Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

MEDIAWATCH

No strategy and a beige suit

Read more

THE WORLD THIS WEEK

The World This Week - 29 August 2014 (part 2)

Read more

THE WORLD THIS WEEK

The World This Week - 29 August 2014

Read more

ENCORE!

Alain Choquette: A Hilarious Magician in Paris

Read more

FOCUS

France welcomes Iraqi Christian refugees

Read more

FRANCE IN FOCUS

Emmanuel Macron: A new economy minister with a pro-business agenda

Read more

THE OBSERVERS

More of this year's best Observers stories

Read more

#TECH 24

Changing the world, one video game at a time

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

Socialist Party summer conference kicks off in explosive atmosphere

Read more

  • Besieged UN peacekeepers battle Islamists in Golan Heights

    Read more

  • Ukrainian plane with seven on board crashes in Algeria

    Read more

  • Kerry calls for 'coalition of nations' to battle IS militants

    Read more

  • EU leaders meet in Brussels to seek a response to Russia

    Read more

  • Exclusive: Fabius warns Russia of more sanctions

    Read more

  • Lesotho army seizes police HQ, jams radio stations

    Read more

  • IMF backs Lagarde amid French corruption probe

    Read more

  • Ebola drug ‘ZMapp’ heals all monkeys in study

    Read more

  • British killer escapes from French psychiatric hospital

    Read more

  • Police hunt for British boy with brain tumour taken to France

    Read more

  • Ukraine to relaunch NATO membership bid

    Read more

  • Suriname leader’s son pleads guilty to courting Hezbollah

    Read more

  • Mapping Ukraine: Canada and Russia in ‘tweet for tat’ row

    Read more

  • France shines in IMF list of world’s promising economists

    Read more

  • Chelsea’s Torres set for AC Milan switch

    Read more

  • First case of Ebola confirmed in Senegal

    Read more

  • Obama has 'no strategy yet' against IS militants in Syria

    Read more

  • Netflix to woo French with ‘House of Cards’ set in Marseille

    Read more

  • French businesses ‘hoping for a new Thatcher’

    Read more

  • The deleted tweets of Manuel Valls

    Read more

  • Libyan PM resigns as Islamists set up rival administration

    Read more

France

French judge faces disciplinary panel in wrongful imprisonment case

Latest update : 2009-02-02

Fabrice Burgaud, an examining magistrate from 1999 to 2002, faces a disciplinary panel for his role in the wrongful imprisonment of 13 suspects in a paedophilia scandal that has turned into a political issue for French President Nicolas Sarkozy.

REUTERS - A French magistrate faced a disciplinary panel on Monday over his role in the wrongful imprisonment of 13 suspects in a paedophilia scandal that has turned into a political issue for President Nicolas Sarkozy.

The disciplinary procedure against Fabrice Burgaud, 37, will be closely watched by Sarkozy, who announced last month he would scrap the position of examining magistrate which Burgaud held at the time of the child abuse investigation in 1999-2002.

Burgaud is accused of having suspects incarcerated based on unsubstantiated allegations that a group of neighbours were abusing children in the northern town of Outreau. The allegations turned out to be wildly exaggerated.

Four people were eventually convicted, but 13 others were cleared after spending up to 39 months in jail.  The case is considered one of the worst miscarriages of justice in recent French history and Burgaud's record is one of the strongest arguments in favour of Sarkozy's decision to scrap the powerful position of examining magistrate.

But examining magistrates have spearheaded efforts in the past 20 years to investigate corruption in politics and many in the justice system say that getting rid of them would make it easier for politicians to hide their wrongdoing.

Burgaud and his defenders say that he is a scapegoat and that the disciplinary action against him is designed to bolster the argument in favour of Sarkozy's controversial reform.

"This is not about judging a magistrate but about enacting a political strategy. Mr Burgaud is a pawn in a game where the stakes go far beyond him," said Jean-Yves Montfort, a magistrate who is assisting Burgaud with his defence.

The disciplinary panel is made up of magistrates and they could decide to ban Burgaud from working in the justice system.

Under a legal system that dates back to Napoleon, examining magistrates are supposed to consider all elements of a case, whether they strengthen or weaken the case against the suspects. Burgaud is accused of ignoring evidence that showed many of the Outreau suspects were being wrongly accused.

Under Sarkozy's proposed reform, state prosecutors would be tasked with building up the case against suspects, while lawyers would focus on the case for the defence.

Critics of the plan say that it undermines judicial independence because prosecutors answer to the justice ministry, as opposed to examining magistrates who are independent. The critics say the government would be able to stop or manipulate inconvenient investigations through the prosecutors.

Date created : 2009-02-02

COMMENT(S)