- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 05/02/2010
- Florence Cassez - Mexico - Nicolas Sarkozy - organised crime
The thorny case of Florence Cassez
Faced with mounting public anger, French President Nicolas Sarkozy and his Mexican counterpart Felipe Calderon have decided to appoint an opaque "Bi-national Commission" to handle the case of Florence Cassez.
"Que se quede!" Splashed across the front page of Mexican newspaper La Prensa, the bold red headline sums up the general sentiment in Mexico surrounding the case of Florence Cassez. No matter what French President Nicolas Sarkozy said during his official visit to the country, the Mexican daily says, the kidnapping-gang-member-turned-martyr-of-the-French deserves to rot in a Mexican jail.
The 34-year-old French native and ex-girlfriend of Mexican criminal gang leader Israel Vallarta was convicted by a Mexican court of participating in at least three kidnappings, and sentenced to 60 years in jail. She has requested to be transferred to a French prison, something she is legally entitled to under the 1983 Strasburg Convention, signed by both France and Mexico.
Plagued by more than 8,000 abductions each year, however, Mexicans are not enclined to show those linked to kidnapping circles any tolerance. "She committed crimes here (in Mexico ), so she should pay for them here," argued the PRD party's senate leader Carlos Navarrete, voicing what he sees as a "consensus" in Mexican opinion.
Indeed, when sifting through the countless blogs or reader reactions discussing Cassez that have sprouted up on the Mexican Web, one is at pains to find any that agree with Sarkozy's call for Cassez to serve her prison sentence in France. "It's all right for governments to defend their citizens, but for a president to make an official state visit to plead the cause of a convicted delinquent is just nonsense," posted one reader of La Jornada's website.
His reaction is among the more polite ones: most Mexican Web users, fuelled by the emotional accusations of kidnapping victims who claim to recognise Cassez as one of their captors, can't seem to find words hard enough to condemn both Cassez and Sarkozy's initiative. If Mexican President Felipe Calderon is perceived as bowing too easily before French demands, he will doubtless face the wrath of his electorate.
In France, on the other hand, many have come to view Cassez as a victim of a corrupt Mexican justice system, due to the numerous irregularities which flawed her arrest and trial. An editorial in the Mexican broadsheet La Jornada admits that "the investigation's blunders gave ammunition to Cassez's defence lawyers". However, it stresses that "Calderon must not cede to French pressures," because it would send a "bad message" to Mexican citizens, who live in constant fear for their safety, knowing that criminals often get away easily.
Under these circumstances, both Sarkozy and Calderon were understandibly keen to pass on the hot potato to somebody else. Which they did, in a way, by naming an obscure "Bi-national Commission" charged with reaching an agreement on Florence Cassez's fate within three weeks.
The commission -- which includes France's foreign affairs minister, Bernard Kouchner, and his Mexican counterpart, Patricia Espinosa, as well as representatives of both countries' justice systems -- was given the near impossible mission of "finding a solution that preserves the interests of the Mexican justice system, the interests of the French justice system, the interests of kidnapping victims and the right for each person to be transferred to a prison in his country of origin, even when found guilty", as President Sarkozy put it during a joint press conference after talks with Calderon.
But conflicting declarations concerning the commission's agenda and domain of competence have made it clear that getting rid of the prickly case of Florence Cassez won't be that easy. Contacted by FRANCE 24, officials of both the French embassy in Mexico and the Mexican foreign affairs ministry refused to comment.



























Comments (7)
for Gabriel
Gabriel do you really believe she is not guilty? after victims made a perfect recognition of her. I agree we are probably the most corruptious country. But i dont think this witnesses are lying. With what purpose they will incriminate some inocent girl. There is one of the most horrible crimes i dont think 60 years of her in jail would compensate the pain these people live during cautivery.
She is Guilty
She is Guilty. The witnesses recognize her participation on those kidnaps. There is not more to discuss. She is Guilty.
cassez case
bien, le president de la mexique dit il que elle faites un crime dans le pays du mexique, elle etais seule meme
une femme mais y apres il y a des millions qui fais des crime unumerables dans les etats unis et dehors de la mexique, elle a le droit d'y allez au son propre pays en le meme raison qui les autorites ditent qu'elle le fait.
Calderón inept at geopolitics
Despite the possible corruption, witnesses say that frenchwoman held them hostage. Evil creature.I say keep her locked up. Do not bow down to Sarko. Calderón should have let lower-level officials deal with this matter, as Porfirio Muñoz Ledo commented recently. Wary are we of the gringos, but just as wary of the do-goody EU (when it is convenient, they are so self-righteous).
Florence Case
Seeing this case in another angle, in my point of oview, this case was not fairly judge. Firstly because it was base on a montage orchestrated by the director of the Federal Agency of Investigation (the Mexican FBI), Genaro García Luna, today chief of the Federal Police. Secondly, there has been a lot of contradiction in the testimonies of the victims, as well as omissions. Thirdly knowing the background of Genaro García Luna, which he has been pointed to have links and give protection to the organized crime. I think there is a possibility that she could be innocent.
Gabriel
Degree in Broadcasting Communications and journalism
http://www.equisy.blogspot.com
Florence Case
I agree with you, although it seems that there is a part of the convention where it states that if the laws differ with the state that sentenced, this may refuse and not be obligated to extradite. There is also another problem, Mexico is in mid term election process so the discourse of all the politicians is against her extradition. Unfortunately this case has politicized because of this. If the french government would have ask Mexico the extradition last year or after the elections, I am quite sure that Mexico wouldn't deny at all.
Florence Cassez
Mexico is a signatory of the Strasbourg Convention and must therefore accept that this woman, no matter what offences she has committed, is entitled to be remove to France to serve her term of imprisonment. The Mexican government must ugnore the hysterical outbursts of its citizens and respect the Convention.