Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

AFRICA NEWS

Kenya : Police arrest 8 over Mombasa rampage

Read more

FOCUS

Overfishing and the global appetite for bluefin tuna: can Tokyo turn the tide?

Read more

MEDIAWATCH

Too many graphic images from Gaza ?

Read more

FASHION

Who's next in Paris, an event with international ready-to-wear and fashion accessories collections

Read more

ENCORE!

Tunisia's Carthage International Festival turns 50

Read more

THE OBSERVERS

Muslims and Christians clean up Bangui, and violence spirals out of control in Algeria's Gardaia

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

Is there such thing as 'telegenic' victims of war?

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

2014-07-22 07:21 IN THE FRENCH PRESS

Read more

THE INTERVIEW

Michel Sidibé, UNAIDS Executive Director

Read more

  • US, European airlines suspend flights to Tel Aviv over Israel-Gaza conflict

    Read more

  • France gives go-ahead to pro-Palestinian Paris rally

    Read more

  • Video: Lebanon fears fallout from regional turmoil

    Read more

  • Australian veteran Rogers claims 16th stage of Tour de France

    Read more

  • French Jews mourn French-Israeli soldier killed in Gaza

    Read more

  • Colombia's Rodriguez signs '€80m' contract with Real Madrid

    Read more

  • A call for harmony in riot-hit ‘Little Jerusalem’ Paris suburb

    Read more

  • Five children among seven killed in minibus crash in eastern France

    Read more

  • Hollande says French warship delivery will ‘depend on Russia’s attitude’

    Read more

  • Widodo wins Indonesian presidential election

    Read more

  • Ukraine rebels release bodies, black boxes from flight MH17

    Read more

  • Notorious ‘VIP’ prison in Paris closed for renovations

    Read more

  • An ‘explosion of violence’: French press reacts to Gaza protests

    Read more

  • Christians in Iraq's Mosul face execution or exodus

    Read more

  • Scores killed as Libyan militias fight over airport

    Read more

  • Ukraine football players refuse to return home after friendly in France

    Read more

Europe

Parliamentary expenses scandal: a media 'blood fest'?

Text by Tony TODD

Latest update : 2009-05-23

For two weeks Britain's The Daily Telegraph has been drip-feeding the British public with details of outrageous and bizarre expense claims made by the country's lawmakers. The press are having a field day and parliament is feeling the strain.

"This blood fest has got to stop," said since-suspended UK Justice Minister Shahid Malik after details of his parliamentary expenses were revealed in The Daily Telegraph.

 

And a blood fest it most certainly is. The British media is in full frenzy.

 

The biggest scalp - to date - was that of Michael Martin, Speaker of the House of Commons, who resigned due to criticism of the way he had handled the scandal.

 

The Speaker is responsible for members’ conduct in the House of Commons - and Martin is the first to be ousted in more than 300 years.

 

Since the Telegraph began drip-feeding the outrageous and often bizarre expense claims made by law-makers, parliament, the "oldest gentleman's club in Britain", has been brought to a grinding halt.

 

Three-quarters of the right-leaning Telegraph's international edition on Thursday May 21 was devoted to the issue. Details included phantom mortgage repayments, insurance mysteries and the announcement that Sir Peter Viggers, a senior Conservative, will step down at the next election after it was revealed he had claimed £1,634 for a floating duck house.

 

So far, the newspaper has published lurid allegations of misconduct by 19 Labour MPs – including the Prime Minister, 19 Conservatives, six Liberal Democrats and two Sinn Fein MPs. 

 
Self-regulated
 

It has been known for a long time that the self-regulated parliamentary expenses system was open to abuse.

 

After a High Court ruling last year based on the Freedom of Information Act 2000, the House of Commons said it would publish MPs' expenses in July 2009, with certain "intrusive" details held back. 

 

But an unnamed "businessman" sold disks containing all the grizzly details to the Telegraph - and since May 8 the paper has been publishing a daily dose of parliamentary outrages.

 
Newspaper sales
 

There is nothing like a red-faced politician to stir righteous indignation and make that breakfast cup of tea taste better while you flick through the morning's paper.

Britons like their newspapers and have a voracious appetite for scandal. And newspapers like to feed this appetite. After all, it drives up sales.

 

On May 20, 11 days into the scandal, The Guardian reported that the Telegraph's sales had surged by 60,000 a day.

 

Public interest in the debate was such that the BBC's flagship Question Time on May 14 enjoyed its highest viewing figures in 30 years - 3.8 million tuned in for the debate on expenses.

 

Even bankers can take comfort from the fact that the spotlight has been taken off them and their own much-reported appetite for huge bonuses at a time of grave economic crisis, for the time being at least.

 
Parliamentary reform
 

But The Economist makes the point that an accountable parliamentary system with clear moral authority is essential if the bigger issues are to be tackled correctly, calling for a measured move towards constitutional reform, rather than a snap election, in response. 

 

"Better to save that great accounting for a time when voters care about something bigger than the dodgy expenses of some errant MPs," the leading article said.

 

The Guardian ran a four-page pull-out titled "A New Politics: Towards a blueprint for reforming government".

 

The pull-out’s leading article says that simply fixing the expenses system is not enough to clean up parliament and that broad and far-reaching constitutional reform is required. 

 

"It took the Founding Fathers of the United States four months to agree their constitution," it reads. "Mr Brown has longer than that. He has a year in which to cement his place in history as a great reformer or as a great political failure."

 

The left-leaning broadsheet's columnists go on to suggest ways in which this reform might take shape.

 

Gary Younge calls for the final abolition of the Monarchy and Jonathan Freedland says parliament needs a fully elected House of Lords (rather than a house full of party favourites).

 

Martin Kettle  says MPs need to be given more power and be a bigger check on the executive, citing the decision to go to war in Iraq, adding: "MPs should stop being sheep and start being watchdogs."

Date created : 2009-05-22

COMMENT(S)