- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 03/06/2009
- AF 447 crash - Air France - aviation
Mystery surrounds Air France flight disaster
The cause of the probable crash of Air France flight AF 447 is completely unknown. Experts are sure that a lightning bolt could not be the sole cause, but are clueless as to the other factors that may have led to the tragedy.
A complete mystery surrounds the cause of the probable crash of Air France flight 447.
The first hint of what could have caused the crash came from Air France officials, who spoke of a “lightning strike”. According to Air France's chief executive, Pierre-Henry Gourgeon, the aircraft had sent "a succession of a dozen technical messages" saying that "several electrical systems had broken down", causing electrical and pressurization failures.
But lightning strikes are “commonplace” in today’s airline flights, said aviation expert Pierre Condon, a former editor of French aviation magazine Air & Cosmos.
Modern aluminium- or composite-bodied airplanes are designed to conduct lightning around the body of the plane, leaving the internal systems — and passengers — completely untouched.
At worst, Condon said, lightning can cause the plane to temporarily lose its way because of loss of certain navigational systems. “But that’s all,” he said.
There are other factors. The area in which the Airbus A330-200 disappeared is known meteorologically as the “Intertropical Convergence Zone”. The ITCZ is a moving region near the equator where winds from the northern and southern hemispheres clash violently in storms.
This weather phenomenon is also hindering the search for the missing plane.
A French crewman searching for the AF 447 said the area has “weather patterns that are dangerous for flying”.
“That means we've only been able to do a very basic search,” he continued.
Search operations are usually conducted very rigorously in mapped-out grid patterns.
Modern aircraft such as the Airbus A330-200 are designed with numerous fail-safes and complete, redundant back-up systems.
Condon explains that “there are complete back-up systems”, including a small ram-air propeller that descends and “runs a little generator giving a minimal current to control the plane and communicate”.
“There are also back up batteries and other systems”. The only way the plane could have crashed, he says, is if none of this worked. He speculates that a combination of events could have caused explosive decompression in the cabin, leading to serious “mechanical failure”.
Black box recovery
The only way to know what really happened to the plane is to find the aircraft’s so-called “black box”, which would contain critical data from the flight. The box, as Jean Louis Borloo, France's environment and transport minister says, “emits signals for thirty days”.
And the Atlantic Ocean has an average depth of 3600m – far deeper than most divers and submersibles can explore. Borloo continues to say that “the ocean bottom reaches three to six thousand metres with strong currents.”
US satellite technology might be needed to help recover the boxes, if it is at all possible. This morning, US President Barack Obama agreed to make all means available to help in the search.
Still, Condon doubts that the boxes will be recovered. “Unimportant debris will be found”. But the boxes might now be at the bottom of the ocean.



























Comments (11)
Nightmare
I had a night mare about an island called fernando norna or something like that
black box
isnt there a way to include black boxes in buoyant material so they can be recovered after crashes ? what's their use if they now sink to 6km seabeds ?
condolence continued
Let just pray to GOD Absolute, if we have seen/percieved him (or just pray to the GOD in human form - A TRUE MASTER/Living Saint...Present on this earth looking after everyone) that wherever you have kept those 228 souls...grant them Peace...Solace..allyour Love, Grace & Protection. One more thing which we have to be aware of is that ......IN TRUE ESSENCE we are all one and the same......DROP OF CONSCIOUSNESS OF THE SAME OCEAN....when somebody dies....we feel the pain and that pain is all because that we all are INTERCONNECTED from INSIDE....there is something within us which DIES every moment and we become more conscious....conscious of our real self..which is soul.....The physical world is just temporary..we are only here for a small amount of time...ultimately we have to go back to our true source..which is ETERNAL ...
Condolence
There are some instances in life which shows us how helpless we are? There are some things which can not be concluded with the human mind, we need to seek help from beyond to get the answers. Like in this instance we want to know what really happned? Where are those 228 people? are they dead? have they been kidnapped? what their fate? we think nobody knows? but the answer to every question of this world lies beyond..we just have to invert within and then we will see everything what happened like a movie playback..? what was the cause of it? the cause and effect can be percieved by the conciousness not the Mind....we are conscious beings been given the faculty of mind to use in the worl
Shut up !!
Guys grow up its not about US or some other state its about the lives of ill fated on AF 447, we need to pray and thats all we can at the moment.All are speculating for some survivours - lets also.
HOPE
Lets hope everyone who travelled in AF447 are safe .still if we get a news which we dont like to..we shall accept and pray for their soul..
"We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope". -- Martin Luther King, Jr.
Poor one
It is the USA inside you, this sick image your carry in your mind, that has a hand in most accidents.
So, it is you that is responsible for that.
Tragedies like this touch us all
Some fool said that the US is involved here?
Wow, what a disgraceful individual.
At at time that we all should be praying for these souls, someone had to spew venom on the
wound.
We are humans and sometimes nature shows us how finite and small we are.
Let's hope for a cause so we can prevent a similar catastrophe.
May God bless these souls.
Safety
The US govt offers its support in these circumstances because determining the root cause of the incident will save lives in the future. Its in the world's best interest to prevent another tragedy from occuring in the future -- and the US has significant expertise in salvage and crash investigation. If memory serves me correctly, the NTSB played a large role in the Swissair investigation in Halifax, Canada. Denmark contributed significantly to that mission by providing deep-sea salvage equipment to "vacuum up" aircraft debris from the ocean floor. I would be very suprised if this support is politically motivated.
You are an idiot
If you have some proof that the US military was involved in this, then show proof or SHUT UP. Also, where do you get the idea that the US military or the USA is involved in "most world disasters"? Again, where's your proof?
The US offered its help in the search and rescue because it's the USA that has the best and highest technology available to perform this kind of search. You must be one of those people that complain when the USA offers help, yet criticizes the USA when we don't offer help either. What a loser.
Mystery maybe not??
We ask why it is the US military so helpful and willing to do the things to help in search, yes? What is this for? I makes me suspicious. It is like when a husband has affair with other womens and then brings his wife flowers. Is the US covering something up?? The US probably has hand in disaster because it has hand in almost all world disasters.