17 June 2009 - 12H29
- Benedict XVI - Catholic Church - Vatican

Vatican declares ordination of breakaway priests 'illegitimate'
The Vatican said on Wednesday that the ordination of priests belonging to the Lefebvrist schism, scheduled for the end of June, would be "illegitimate".

AFP -  The Vatican Wednesday declared "illegitimate" the ordination of priests planned for later this month by a hardline breakaway movement from the Roman Catholic Church.
   
"The ordinations are ... still to be considered illegitimate," the Vatican said in a communique, despite its controversial decision to lift the excommunication of four bishops from the Society of St Pius X including Holocaust denier Richard Williamson.
   
Members of the fraternity "do not exercise legitimate ministries in the (Roman Catholic) Church," the communique said.
   
The Vatican will maintain this position "as long as issues concerning doctrine are not clarified," it said, adding that the Switzerland-based group had "no canonical status in the Church."
   
The pope's decision in January to lift Williamson's excommunication infuriated the Jewish community and many Catholics.
   
Benedict's predecessor Pope John Paul II excommunicated Williamson and three other bishops after traditionalist leader Marcel Lefebvre ordained them as bishops of his separatist church in 1988.
   
Their fraternity rejected reforms passed by Second Vatican Council in the early 1960s, notably including a declaration, Nostra Aetate, which ended a Church doctrine by which the Jews were held responsible for killing Jesus Christ.
   
Williamson, who claims that no Jews were killed in Nazi gas chambers, has apologised to anyone offended by his remarks but has refused to retract his assertions, saying only that he would reexamine the historical evidence.
   
The pope said in March that while the bishops had been "invited" back into the fold, they "do not (yet) legitimately exercise any ministry in the Church."
   
Benedict said that the four must recognise "the authority of the pope and the Second Vatican Council" in order to "complete the last steps necessary to achieve full communion with the Church."
   
Lefebvre ordained the four, in defiance of John Paul II, as bishops to create a heirarchy for the breakway group.
   
 

Comments

@ "Hypocrites" by Anonymous 18/06/2009

These guys were cut off for continuing to officially blame Jewish people for the death of some guy named Jesus and one of the guys is someone who adamantly denies that the Holocaust ever happened.

I guess that to those who believe such things, they might see it as having radical opinions that the church just can't handle. But when I think of people criticizing the Church for shutting people down, I usually don't think of them crying foul when the church shuts out purveyors of hate-speech.

However, if you're defending them on principle of freedom of speech/speaking your mind, I understand, but I'm thinking it's more likely that you saw the words "Church", "cut-off" and "different ideas" and blew a big load of "the Pope's a Nazi who can't handle free-thought!!" all over the screen.

Hypocrites.

Typical. The church says "You're not one of us, you show a glimmer of independant thought.. so you're illigitimate."

How closed minded and ignorant.
THIS is why we don't need religion anymore, it closes peoples eyes to the beliefs and views of others.
How can I respect the church if they don't respect me?

Religion is a plague upon this planet. Do away with it, immediately!

Why These Guys?

Apparently you need to be in good standing with Nazis and Skinheads in order to rejoin the Church. Wake up people, when organized religion shows such flagrant disregard for all that is good, just, and beautiful in this world, maybe its time we asked ourselves what God wants us to do instead of listening to the severely flawed men that, current and past, have led this religion.

Related Content

Close