- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 10/07/2009
- China - genocide - Tayyip Erdogan - Turkey
Turkish PM Erdogan likens Xinjiang violence to 'genocide'
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has compared the plight of the Uighurs - a Turkic-speaking Muslim minority in Xinjiang - to genocide, a move that could potentially damage Turkey's relations with China, a key trading partner.
AFP - Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan compared Friday the plight of Muslim Uighurs in Xinjiang to genocide, risking the ire of China, a key trading partner.
Erdogan sharply elevated his government's criticism of Beijing as anti-Chinese demonstrations were held across Turkey in solidarity with the Uighurs, a Turkic-speaking Muslim minority.
Erdogan, who heads Turkey's Islamist-rooted government, did not specifically blame China -- a key trading partner -- for deaths in Xinjiang but strongly criticised Beijing's inaction.
"The event taking place in China is a kind of genocide," Erdogan said, adding that "we have difficulty understanding how China's leadership... can remain a spectator in the face of these events."
At least 184 people have been killed in unrest in Xinjiang over the past week, according to official figures. Meanwhile anger has built in the Islamic world over the treatment of the Uighurs, who have long complained about repression under Chinese rule.
Up until Friday Turkey, wary of the growing importance of its ties with China, had been reluctant to forcefully rebuke Beijing over its handling of the crisis.
"Turkey is caught in a dilemma," said the International Crisis Group's Hugh Pope, who has written a book on relations between Turkey and Uighurs.
"One one hand, it has real, strong interests with China. On the other hand, the government does feel a sense of sympathy and responsibility, and media and public opinion is very emotional about the story."
Erdogan earlier said Turkey would ask the UN Security Council to discuss ways of ending the violence. The call was rejected by China, one of five permanent members of the council who can veto its actions.
"This is completely China's internal affair," Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Qin Gang said in Beijing.
Turkey often cites "internal affairs" to deflect international criticism of its handling of a 25-year Kurdish insurgency in the southeast.
"Just like China with the Uighurs, Turkey is wary of foreign powers meddling with ethnic disputes like the Kurds, so can't bang the drum about any need for international supervision too hard," Pope said.
The foreign ministry in Ankara has been careful with the wording of its statements, urging China to "act in accordance with international human rights norms and principles" in handling the unrest.
"The Turkish people feel very close to the Uighur people and share their suffering," said a ministry statement, underlining that Uighurs form a "strong bridge of friendship" between Turkey and China.
Trade and Industry Minister Nihat Ergun called for a boycott of Chinese goods, while hastening to add that this was a personal gesture with no government approval.
Prior to Erdogan's genocide comments, the media had criticised the Ankara government's stance as too soft.
"The Turkic Uighurs should at least get the same sympathy shown to the Palestinians of Gaza," said an editorial in the Sabah daily, referring to Erdogan's angry slanging match with Israeli President Shimon Peres at the Davos forum this year over the Gaza war.
The unrest in Xinjiang comes at a bad time for Turkey.
President Abdullah Gul visited China in June, accompanied by 120 businessmen, in a bid to strengthen trade links.
The two sides discussed telecoms, electronics and auto sector projects. Gul also visited Urumqi, capital of Xinjiang and donned a qlapan, a traditional Uighur costume.
"China is a great power that Turkey needs a good relationship with for a wide variety of reasons," Pope said.
"Big Turkish companies are producing goods in China, and importing significant quantities of goods from China. The Turkish armed forces are very interested in Chinese military technology," he added.
Trade between Turkey and China has grown over the years to about 17 billion dollars in 2008 -- heavily in China's favour with 15.6 billion dollar's worth of exports to Turkey.




























React to the article
(9) Reactions
Uighurs are not aboriginal peoples of XinJiang
Firstly, XinJiang(Western Region) is part of China during Han, Tang, Yuan, Qing Dynasty. Because the Zunghars(a branch of Mogols) living in XinJiang rebeled Munchus ruling time after time. The Qing Emperor Qianlong ordered to exterminate the Zunghar race, thus create a vacuum for the Uighurs to fill in. The Manchus accept them because they've no place to go and willing to become the subjects of China. Western media always accuse China of Han colonialism without studying the history first, drawing conclusion from their colonization of the New World and Australia is unacceptable.
will Turkey be a terrorist home?
The Turkish PM regarding the recent violence by Uighurs mobs in Xinjiang are completely bullshits.
All are about how the Chinese government crack down the Uighurs ethin minority without mentioning how many favorable policies they enjoyed for decades which Han Chinese majorities could not. They can have many more babies whereas Han is not allowed by the law and these stupid backward and lazy could get extra grades for college extrance which Han Chinese never dream of but to work hard silently without complaint.Many more favorable policies by the Chinese government have backfired, which spoiled these Uighurs separatists ,terrorists and extremists as becoming one privileged class on the other hand.
Now the spoiled minorities become a monester of stomping and hurling to death month-old Han babies and 60- and 70-year olds demonstrated in the violence.
Get a grip, Erdogan.
This inane outburst from Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, is an excellent demonstration as to why the EU is very reluctant to pursue the accession of Turkey, to the EU. It is highly unlikely that the Chinese authorities are conducting a pogrom against the Uighurs, who also happen to be Muslims. Furthermore, when Tayyip Erdogan even thinks of less than 200 deaths as something akin to a genocide, he is ether speaking from the perspective of a clouded judgement, or playing to gallery back in Turkey, as a way to underpin his efforts to promote something akin to an Islamic hegemony, at home and abroad. Whichever, he demeans the whole concept of a genocide and its catastrophic nature.
Truth?
Both China and the pro independence movements distort the truth. China has represed these people and taken over thier land for half a century, and people are shocked this is happening? Why? Everyone understands Israel/Palestine conflict, this is not much different only it started instead of with war, with the heavy handed Chinese taking over and imposing their government and taking their land.
Geocide
hmmm.... I think Australians should look at themselves!!!! The Turks have a ethnic relationship with the peoples of East Turkestan. the Chinese hardly have a enlightened approach. Look at Tibet? Its good that someone speaks out.
Distorting the facts is what China does the best
As if China does not have a reputation for distorting the facts! As in Tiananmen Square massacre... Your words reek of Islamophobia and crude nationalism. Get rid of one-sided, unjust opinions and start believing in fundamental human rights. The name Xinjiang itself is another sign of China's way of distorting the facts, an invented name to avoid using East Turkestan... Truth will prevail.
What about Armenian genocide then!?
hmmm i think the turks should have a look at themselves first.....
Stop
I can not understand why Turkey has termed the violence as genocide. Firstly, it is obvious that people who believe in ISLAM killed Han Chinese, because of the 180 deaths, 137 are Han Chinese. As every foreign reporter allowed to cover the event freely in Xinjiang has witnessed, China has never conducted organized killing of those Uighurs. And it is the case in every country that those involved in such overwhelming events be detained firstly. As I know, China has sent thousands of soldiers to isolate the neighbourhoods of Uighur and Han Chinese, and from the footnotes of BBC, you can find heavy deployments of troops around mosquoes so that Han Chinese won't hurt them. Absolutely, I can not understand why Turkey has made such unreasonable comments.
Stop distorting the facts!
Are Muslim countries completely blind to the truth of the Xinjiang massacre? There are news reports, photos and videos all over the web, pointing to the fact it was sword-wielding UYGHUR MOBSTERS who massacred Han Chinese civilians. 136 of the 184 dead are Hans. They were beheaded, little babies have their heads smashed, others were burned to death. Is the Muslim reaction supposed to be salt rubbed into Chinese wounds?
They didn't succeed in turning Kashmir or Chechnya or Palestine into Islamic states, so now, they cast a lustful eye at Xinjiang. Xinjiang was, is, and will always be China's.
As for Turkey wanting to boycott Chinese goods? Please go right ahead! It will hurt Turkey much more than it will hurt China.