Coming up

Don't miss




The World This Week - 01 August 2014 (part 2)

Read more


Coverage of Gaza in the Israeli media

Read more


1914-1918: The Depths of Hell

Read more


The World This Week - 01 August 2014

Read more


Exclusive: Israel's US ambassador speaks to FRANCE 24

Read more

#THE 51%

World War One: The war that changed women’s lives

Read more


Ségolène Royal goes for green

Read more


A look back at some of the Observers' best stories

Read more


Argentina Defaults: Kirchner Cries Foul Over 'Vulture Funds' (part 2)

Read more

  • Israeli soldier feared captured, ceasefire 'over'

    Read more

  • Exclusive: Israel's US ambassador speaks to FRANCE 24

    Read more

  • Police 'chokehold' caused NYC death, coroner rules

    Read more

  • Air France ground workers to strike on August 2

    Read more

  • Rogue general denies Islamist seizure of Benghazi

    Read more

  • Ugandan court strikes down anti-gay legislation

    Read more

  • 1914-1918: The Depths of Hell

    Read more

  • Regional summit to tackle deadly Ebola outbreak

    Read more

  • French hospital to open wine bar for terminally ill patients

    Read more

  • Video: Tipping is dying out in French café culture

    Read more

  • €2.5 million in cocaine ‘disappears’ from Paris police HQ

    Read more

  • Appeal court keeps French rogue trader Kerviel in jail

    Read more

  • Interactive: France’s new plan to counter jihadism in Africa

    Read more

  • Ukrainian army suffers losses in separatist attack

    Read more

  • Argentinian markets plummet following default

    Read more

  • French Jews speak of growing fear in Paris amid Gaza conflict

    Read more


Suicide after loss of an iPhone prototype

Text by Yi SONG , Apoorva PRASAD

Latest update : 2009-08-03

Two weeks after the death of one of its young employees, a little-known Taiwanese electronics manufacturer that makes Apple’s best-selling iPhones is struggling to deal with its aftermath. (Foxconn factory photo from China Labour Watch).

Sun Dan-Yong, 25, died in an apparent suicide on July 16 after jumping out of his 12th-floor apartment in Shenzhen, in southeastern China, in a tragedy that raises questions on technology outsourcing, Chinese labour laws and possibly even counterfeiting.

Sun Dan-Yong worked for Foxconn, a Taiwan-based manufacturer contracted by some of the world’s biggest technology companies, including Apple.

He had been entrusted with sending 16 top-secret, new iPhone prototypes to Apple’s offices in the United States. But at some point, one went missing.

That’s when Sun’s life went downhill.

According to his employer, Foxconn, Sun “was not able to cope with the stress” of the loss of one of the prototypes under his care. But Chinese media reports say that, before his death, Sun was interrogated and beaten up by Foxconn security.


Foxconn has not officially denied or confirmed the reports, but the company said in a press release that it had subsequently suspended one of its supervisors.

The company also compensated Sun’s family. According to the New York Times, they received 44,000 dollars, and his girlfriend got an Apple Macbook.

Foxconn refuses to comment further on the matter while an ongoing investigation is conducted by the police and labour departments of Shenzhen.

Apple’s official response in the meantime is that it is “saddened”, and is waiting for the investigation’s results.

Sun worked at Foxconn’s factory in nearby Dongguan, which had just built 16 prototypes of a new-generation iPhone, as yet unseen by the public.

The iPhone is one of Apple’s biggest commercial successes, with about 21 million units sold to date.

Apple is able to be that successful because it keeps new models of iPhones tightly guarded secrets, resulting in massive public demand for them.

When the iPhone went missing, the China Daily and subsequent Internet chatter said that he was interrogated and beaten. Other reports say that when he couldn’t find the phone, he was questioned but not mistreated. His apartment was searched by Foxconn guards. Sometime later, he was dead.

Labour troubles

Foxconn is contracted by Apple, Nintendo, Sony and others for the manufacture of their newest and most desirable consumer electronic goods. But in a perhaps bizarre contradiction to such high-profile contracts, Foxconn has been known for mistreating its workers, according to labour groups.

Dee Lee, director of Handshake Labour, a labour union based in nearby Guangzhou, told FRANCE 24: “Before this incident, Foxconn had already been put under the media spotlight five times, due to labour problems in the company. Foxconn is like a synonym for companies with bad labour policies.”

New York-based China Labour Watch published a report in August 2008 detailing Foxconn’s treatment of its workers, who it says work long hours in terrible conditions.

Li Qiang, director of China Labour Watch, told FRANCE 24 that Foxconn “has employed a very militaristic style of management at its factories. Foxconn’s management is very rough with its workers. This is something we’ve seen systematically at its factories.”

In 2008, a new Chinese labour law was supposed to improve the condition of factory workers. But Foxconn “has not totally implemented all the labour contract law”, says Li, adding that “Sun Dan-Yong would have to work late into the night and often overtime.”

China Labour Watch contacted Apple upon the publication of its report, but the company did not respond.

So far, Apple’s official response has only been a brief statement that concluded: “We require that our suppliers treat all workers with dignity and respect.”

Date created : 2009-07-30