Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

MEDIAWATCH

No strategy and a beige suit

Read more

THE WORLD THIS WEEK

The World This Week - 29 August 2014 (part 2)

Read more

THE WORLD THIS WEEK

The World This Week - 29 August 2014

Read more

ENCORE!

Alain Choquette: A Hilarious Magician in Paris

Read more

FOCUS

France welcomes Iraqi Christian refugees

Read more

FRANCE IN FOCUS

Emmanuel Macron: A new economy minister with a pro-business agenda

Read more

THE OBSERVERS

More of this year's best Observers stories

Read more

#TECH 24

Changing the world, one video game at a time

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

Socialist Party summer conference kicks off in explosive atmosphere

Read more

  • US aid drops begin in besieged Iraqi town of Amerli

    Read more

  • EU leaders choose Tusk and Mogherini for top jobs, discuss Russia sanctions

    Read more

  • Opposition protesters clash with Pakistani police outside PM's house

    Read more

  • Austerity row overshadows French Socialist’s annual rally

    Read more

  • Egypt sentences Brotherhood leader Badie to life

    Read more

  • Ceasfire allows Gaza families to relax on the beach

    Read more

  • S. Africa condemns 'military coup' in Lesotho

    Read more

  • Kerry calls for 'coalition of nations' to battle IS militants

    Read more

  • Ukrainian plane with seven on board crashes in Algeria

    Read more

  • Exclusive: Fabius warns Russia of more sanctions

    Read more

  • IMF backs Lagarde amid French corruption probe

    Read more

  • Ebola drug ‘ZMapp’ heals all monkeys in study

    Read more

  • British killer escapes from French psychiatric hospital

    Read more

  • Police hunt for British boy with brain tumour taken to France

    Read more

  • Ukraine to relaunch NATO membership bid

    Read more

  • Suriname leader’s son pleads guilty to courting Hezbollah

    Read more

  • Mapping Ukraine: Canada and Russia in ‘tweet for tat’ row

    Read more

Middle east

Israel acknowledges use of white-phosphorus shells

Text by Hasnae MALIH

Latest update : 2009-08-02

In a report published Thursday, the Israeli government has, for the first time, admitted to using “munitions containing white phosphorus” during its December 2008-January 2009 military offensive in Gaza.

Israel has admitted for the first time to “using munitions containing white phosphorus” during its offensive on the Gaza Strip in December 2008 and January 2009. But the Israeli government denied violating international law, claiming that such weapons were not fired into areas populated by civilians.

The admission came in an Israeli government report published Thursday, which confirmed earlier reports by the United Nations and several international human rights organizations. Those reports said that Israeli troops violated international law during the offensive.

A Human Rights Watch report released in March slammed Israel for firing white phosphorus shells over densely populated areas, including repeated attacks on the UN Relief and Works Agency headquarters in Gaza City.
Israel denied the report, saying its troops respected international law during the Gaza war.

The use of white phosphorus weapons to generate a smokescreen and cover troop movements is legally accepted, but the 1980 Geneva Convention forbids its use in densely populated areas.

Eyal Alimi, a Radio Israel journalist who has extensively covered Israeli military affairs, notes that Gaza's population density, one of the highest in the world, makes it difficult to avoid areas populated by civilians during military operations.

"In such conditions, how can we say there was no high concentration of civilians in these areas?" said Alimi.

Urban-warfare dilemma

Following a spate of reports by international rights groups questioning the legality of Israel's Gaza offensive, many analysts believe international laws dealing with asymmetrical urban warfare need to be updated.

"These international laws have been established for wars with an actual battlefield, where there is a clear front line between belligerents. But they'e not adapted for today's conflicts. Modern wars are fought in densely populated urban areas," said Alimi.

Critics of the offensive say that the use of phosphorus weapons in Gaza belies the Israeli military claim that it struggled hard to hit only Hamas targets and avoid civilian non-combatants. But distinguishing legitimate military targets is getting more difficult in urban guerilla warfare, where fighters are among the civilian population.

"The main problem is war tactics in urban areas, where there are no uniforms, no clearly defined bases, no obvious targets. Should we just give up? Or should we kill the targets and risk civilian casualties?" asked Gil Mihaely, the Paris correspondent for the Israeli daily, Yedioth Ahronoth.

Reports of Israel's use of white phosphorus shells started emerging during the Gaza operation, when doctors in the Strip began noticing chemical burns among the injured. The official Israeli response to the reports was that the Israeli military was complying with international law. The use of white phosphorus shells was initially neither confirmed nor denied.

In its 163-page report, the Israeli government denied charges that white phosphorus shells killed Palestinian civilians.

"There appear to have been no documented deaths in Gaza resulting from exposure to white phosphorus itself," says a footnote in the report, which goes on to acknowledge that shell casings with phosphorus residue could have hurt some people and started fires. But "it does not appear that damage from this use can be regarded as excessive," said the report.

International rights groups say most civilians in Gaza were killed by F16 missiles, tank shells, heavy artillery and other "legal" weapons.

According to the Palestinian Centre for Human Rights, more than 1,400 Palestinians, including 926 civilians were killed during the campaign. The civilian casualties included 313 children, according to the PCHR.

A March report by the Israeli Defence Forces, however, put the death toll at 1,166, of which 295 were civilians.

Date created : 2009-08-02

COMMENT(S)