- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 20/11/2009
- 2010 FIFA World Cup - football - France - French national team - Ireland
Henry's handball sparks media storm against 'Les Bleus'
Devastation from the Irish, a vicious spanking from the UK and red-faced admissions from the French - three countries' media react to Thierry Henry's handball that cost Ireland its World Cup dream on Wednesday.
"Jour de gloire? Day of infamy more like," wrote the UK’s Daily Telegraph columnist Henry Winter. "France cheated their way on to the last flight to South Africa. Thierry Henry handled not once, but twice in setting up William Gallas’s goal that broke Irish hearts and all rules of sporting justice at the Stade de Fraud on Wednesday night.”
"Thierry Henry is an insincere cheat who has tarnished his reputation for good," wrote The Times football columnist Tony Cascarino.
Cascarino, a former Irish international, said Wednesday's infamous handball from French striker and former Arsenal star Henry would be as permanently imprinted on the collective football conscience as Diego Maradona's "Hand of God" in the 1986 World Cup final against England.
"When we reflect in years to come on the career of one of the finest strikers the game has known," he said, "We will have to put his handball against Ireland right up there with all the great goals he scored."
While The Sun, the UK's biggest selling daily newspaper, dubbed the foul "Le Hand of God”, its British competitor the Daily Mirror, firmly in the play-on-words tradition of British tabloids, stated bluntly in its headline: "French Nickers".
All this vitriol towards a player who was once, as Arsenal's star player from 1999 to 2007, one of the most popular players in English Premiership.
The Irish emotional
But if the British press delivered a vicious media spanking to Henry and the French team, the tone in Ireland was much more emotional.
Beginning his article "under a starless sky, death by a single cut," Irish Independent columnist Vincent Hogan lamented an Irish tragedy in a city where everything seems to outshine the relative lack of sophistication of his homeland, making Henry's handball a smooth and terrible stab in the innocent Irish heart.
"And yet it felt shocking that a country’s dream could perish so fraudulently," he wrote. "Short of tucking the ball up his jersey, Thierry Henry couldn’t have been more openly tactile in possession before flicking to William Gallas for the kill shot."
Irish sports blogger Gareth Maher was less emotive, saying the cruelty of the blow was compounded by the basic fact that the Irish team had outclassed the French.
"France march on to South Africa, while Ireland are left wondering what might have been," he opined. "It is a cruel way for the qualifying campaign to finish up, especially after out-playing their more fancied opponents, but sadly that is how it ends."
'Un miracle'
The French press, in a rare moment of unanimous honesty, said Les Bleus had performed badly and admitted that the victory was pyrrhic. Even Henry was quick to admit his guilt, but said it had been the referee's responsibility to spot his foul, and not his to own up.
France's biggest-selling national newspaper, sports title "L'Equipe", also splashed the line "Main de Dieu" (Hand of God) on its front page.
It was "a miracle the French team had survived as long as it did in the game, with its child-like passes and the very average performances from its players," the newspaper said. "No game has been so eagerly anticipated and as monumentally ballsed-up as this one in a very long time."
The French capital's daily Le Parisien also said the result was "a miracle" for a French side that had shown themselves "incredibly apathetic, incapable of cobbling together the barest semblance of football or to pull off two consecutive passes."
The newspaper France Soir said victory for Les Bleus came "as a climax at the end of an unbearable game and thanks to a handball that will be the focus of debate for the days ahead.”
On the net
Social networking has also gone into overdrive, with "Thierry Henry"' featuring as one of the top "trending topics" on micro-blogging site Twitter, while a Facebook group entitled "We Irish hate Thierry Henry" had amassed 25,000 members by 10.30am (GMT+1).
Reactions also poured in to the FRANCE 24 website, some long and some short.
The Irish point of view was summed up succinctly by the comment: "We were robbed of our World Cup! Hand goal to Henry... Very upset... Merde..."
Read more
SPORTS news, stories and scores - Football, tennis, F1…




























React to the article
(59) Reactions
Well the Irish can complain
Well the Irish can complain as much as they like...but what about that penalty that the French team were not allowed? And when you look at shots on goal comparisons, the French team clearly had the advantage...bad calls are made...this is football unfortunately :(
Thierry - No to cheating!!
I used to admired this player very much, but his hand ball againt Ireland is indeed unfortunate. Being a professional player he should have known better. I have regards for him any more and the FFF, as I hold him responsible for the Irish's shattered dream. FIFA should make a rematch of the game as Irelnd demanded. Henry is a cheat...
cheaters
france cheated once again
Thierry Henry
The French team should have immediately admitted their mistake and taken the loss. If the team can't win any other way everyone will now know what kind of team they have. Ireland is clearly the better team and should be acknowledged as such.
Henry has no blame. It was
Henry has no blame. It was emotional and he touched the ball by instincts. it was not intentional. Henry has always been and would always be a good player
The French have been robbed.
The French have been robbed of a chance of a dignified qualification to the world cup. The French Football Federation has robbed the French of an opportunity to qualify fairly.
Cheats
Your team has lost all respect as a team. I hope you have heard about Karma because your country could be in for a long curse.
No Prob In Critical Situation
If I was him I would do thesame because we are all humans and we do things without reasoning when situations are critical.However he is still tobe blame the other way round.
scott
Hand ball
If this happenned with the Irland player,am one hundread percent shore that the French would make a repeat game.
I,m not French or Irish.
This refere should get fired.He should not ref another game on his life.
Yes, lets replay the game and
Yes, lets replay the game and all the other injustices that happen everyweek all around the world. Particularly Joe Jordans infamous hand ball against Wales and what about '66 world cup and the ball not crossing the line for the goal. Eduardo pillaried also Ngot recently. Not aword mentioned about Rooney and Bent going down 2 yards before reaching th keeper. Apart from Shearer justifying Rooney and Bent by saying they might have made contact if they stayed on their feet. C'mon