AFP - Switzerland approved Sunday a ban on new minarets from being built, with the referendum initiated by far-right politicians picking up strong support.
To the dismay of the Muslim minority here, some 57.5 percent of voters who cast ballots and 22 out of 26 cantons voted to ban the towers or turrets attached on mosques from where Muslims are called to prayer.
Far-right politicians across Europe celebrated the results, while the Swiss government sought to assure the Muslim minority that a ban on minarets was "not a rejection of the Muslim community, religion or culture."
The Swiss People's Party (SVP) -- Switzerland's biggest party -- had forced a referendum after collecting a mandatory 100,000 signatures from eligible voters within 18 months.
They said that the minarets -- of which Switzerland has just four -- were not architectural features with religious characteristics, but symbolised a "political-religious claim to power, which challenges fundamental rights."
Having won a double majority on turnout of 53 percent, the initiative will now be inscribed in the country's constitution.
"The Federal Council (government) respects this decision. Consequently the construction of new minarets in Switzerland is no longer permitted," said the government, which had firmly opposed the ban, in a statement.
Justice Minister Eveline Widmer-Schlumpf said the result "reflects fears among the population of Islamic fundamentalist tendencies."
"These concerns have to be taken seriously... However, the Federal Council takes the view that a ban on the construction of new minarets is not a feasible means of countering extremist tendencies," she stressed.
Switzerland has had an uneasy relationship with its Muslim population, which makes up some five percent of its population of 7.5 million people. Islam is the second largest religion here after Christianity.
A mosque in Geneva was vandalised three times during the anti-minaret campaign, local media reported Saturday.
Widmer-Schlumpf sought to reassure Muslims, saying: "It is not a rejection of the Muslim community, religion or culture. Of that, the Federal Council gives its assurance."
But for the 400,000-strong Muslim community here, comprised mainly of ex-Yugoslav and Turkish migrants and of whom only 50,000 are estimated to practice their faith, the harm has been done.
"The most painful for us is not the minaret ban, but the symbol sent by this vote. Muslims do not feel accepted as a religious community," said Farhad Afshar, who heads the Coordination of Islamic Organisations in Switzerland.
The Conference of Swiss Bishops also criticised the result, saying that it "heightens the problems of cohabitation between religions and cultures."
Young people carrying candles and cardboard minarets led a mock funerary procession in the federal capital Bern, carrying a banner reading "This is not my Switzerland," the ATS news agency reported.
In Zurich's central Helvetia Platz demonstrators erected around 12 mini-minarets made out of recycled objects, ATS said, with a total of a few hundred people protesting in the two cities.
Amnesty International said the minaret ban is a "violation of religious freedom, incompatible with the conventions signed by Switzerland."
The Swiss Green party said it was contemplating lodging a complaint to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg for violation of religious freedoms as guaranteed by the European Convention on Human Rights.
In Morocco, a parliamentarian from the Justice and Development Islamist Party expressed surprise.
"I think that Muslims in Switzerland, and those who live in the European Union, have a lot of work to do in communication to show their real face of tolerance and cohabitation of Islam," said Saad Eddine Othmani.
French far-right politician Marine Le Pen welcomed the outcome, saying that the "elites should stop denying the aspirations and fears of the European people, who, without opposing religious freedom, reject ostentatious signs that political-religious Muslim groups want to impose."
Meanwhile, SVP Vice-President Yvan Perrin cheered the fact that his party had won the vote "without difficulty."
He told Radio Suisse Romande that Swiss companies should not worry about suffering from a possible backlash from Muslim countries.
"If our companies continue to make good quality products, they have nothing to worry about," he said.






















Comments (20)
The banning of minarets in
The banning of minarets in Switzerland is the right decision, and was a brave thing to do for the Swiss. International relations should be characterised by reciprocity: church for mosque, mosque for church. Christian countries should only allow the building of more mosques with in them if and only if Muslim countries will also allow Christians to build churches with in their Islamic countries.
Paranoid Bigots
Instead of becoming like its Muslims- who generally work hard and have good strong families- the Swiss want to discourage them from coming. They should learn from them and start having good families and be respectful of other religions.
As for Muslim tolerance- I think Muslim countries have been very accepting of Christians despite their coreligionists bombing them, threatening them, destroying their mosques and stealing their oil. However, I think the Muslim world should ask itself how many more spire and churches it wants and how many Expats it can handle. Also, why they should have Christian troops in their country when they hold such anti-Muslim beliefs.
I for one will ban Swiss products!!!
Bravo!
This is a good result and should help give courage to the Political Correctness world of Europe. Most Europeans have watched with silent but real alarm at the growth of mosques right in their own city and town backyards. One is seldom invited to participate; it is an exclusive mosque club for just men. Men who tend to be standoffish. Europe is not Muslim. And Europeans should not feel they have to crater to every Muslim demand, as is now the case. See: Honor killings and women who try to flee their Muslim families/m
minarets
The Swiss people have just told the Muslims that they can't have their cake and eat it too. Good for Switzerland ! Anybody getting that "unwanted feeling" yet ?
EU Anti-democratic
Well done Switzerland - we aren't allowed to vote on our EU masters
Swiss go cuckoo
Its amazing that all these people are congratulating a far right party's victory. I just hope all the rich Muslims and Jews ( as synagogues may be targeted next - its the far right after all ) withdraw their funds. Lets not forget the Swiss have banked Nazi monies for years.
Re: Minaret ban 29/11/2009 15.45
Hi Guys. I'm swiss and would like to explain it a bit. The "Yes" for a ban has a lot to do with the actions of Gadaffi against Switzerland. But I have to say, that the "yes" means nothing else than these towers can't be build anymore. It doesn't mean that muslims ain't no more the chance to live there religion. A lot of swiss people think also that in the 21th century it's down and out to obtrude (don't know if this is the right word) religious icons. We got many schools and universitys with catholic crosses over doors and on the walls. And the time is here to stop this shit. Everyone should have the same chance to make his own religious thoughts.
Minaret ban
If the Swiss Muslims are so concerned with religious rights let them do something to help the Christians and Jews in Muslims lands. Oh right, they don't allow other religions.
Let the swiss Muslims stop
Let the swiss Muslims stop complaining and do something about the treatment of Christains and Jews in the Muslim world if they are concerned about religious rights.
Minarets in Switzerland
This is a demonstration of REAL democracy in action and is to be welcomed as such. It may not be palatable to some or even to many but this is democracy. However, democracy doesn't mean that any nation, even Switzerland, can use any vote to demolish minority views. Those in a minority still need to be accepted and regarded with respect even though some of the things they may wish to see implemented cannot be enacted. We should have a more referendum based society in the UK now that the EU has so reduced the control that can be enacted by Parliament.
Those who are suggesting that
Those who are suggesting that minarets are welcome only after Saudi allows construction of churches should remember that Saudi is not only Muslim country in the world. I live one of the Muslim majority country and where Christians are tiny minority (1-2%) still we have X-mas holiday (holiday during Eid is unthinkable in Europe) and there is no restriction on construction of churches. If I take heed on Swiss vote should I campaign for revoking X-mas holiday and ban on construction of churches in my country? Of course not, I am not a stupid.
Ban on Human Rights
Ban on religious activity is a sign of being christian-ism within Europe and showing of fear for Islam among the Swiss people. As we know that Europe is a symbol of protecting Human rights so why they are resisting people to do their religious practices and ceasing freedom of religion? where is Human rights group?
Congratulations Switzerland.
The spread of Islam in Europe will bring us no good.
Marvellous!
Hats off to the Swiss, the're actually putting their foot down before it's too late. Hopefully this will set an example to other countries.
A question of rights
In response to a European court ordering Greece to remove religious icons from public spaces, a Greek bishop recently said that it's not just the rights of the minority that must be protected; the majority has rights too. He's correct. It is entirely reasonable for a people to decide the future they want for their country. Swiss citizens - not recent immigrants to Switzerland - should determine Swiss values. Europe obviously has to tread carefully so as not to return to the era of fascist abuses. But that doesn't mean that Europe should let itself be undermined by newcomers. I don't see Muslim countries bending over backward to accommodate Western culture.
Minarets
I strongly believe in the old saying: When in Rome, do as the romans do!!! Well done Switzerland! I just wish more nations would follow your example and let the people of each nation decide on what is acceptable in their own country!
minarets
It is their Country, let them do what they want. We have enough of being told what to do to please other people
Moslems should stop trade with Switzerland
If you are letting Moslem immigrants in, then you should also provide them religious freedom. I hope all Moslem countries should stop all kinds of trade with Switzerland.
wow. how unreasonable...
Try and build a church in Saudi Arabia or Iran...or just hand someone a Bible in Israel...
Minaret ban.
It would be reasonable to suspect that the vote to ban minarets is a result of the heavy handed action of Hannibal Gaddafi and the Lybian administration which led to the effective kidnapping of Swiss nationals in Lybia and a groveling apology from the Swiss president.
Post new comment