Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

FOCUS

Cleaning up Thailand's shady surrogacy industry

Read more

ENCORE!

The Biennale des Antiquaires: Where Miro meets million-dollar jewellery and antiques

Read more

THE OBSERVERS

Attacks on migrants in Tangiers and unwelcome stares from men in Cairo

Read more

AFRICA NEWS

Ebola virus: US to send 3,000 troops to West Africa

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

France looks on as Scotland votes

Read more

FACE-OFF

Manuel Valls: A weakened Prime minister?

Read more

BUSINESS DAILY

Jack Ma, the man behind Alibaba's record stock market debut

Read more

DEBATE

If Scotland Says 'Aye': Polls Say Indpendence Referendum Too Close to Call

Read more

DEBATE

If Scotland Says 'Aye': Polls Say Independence Referendum Too Close to Call (part 2)

Read more

Europe

Twenty years later, Timisoara affair exposes media credulity

Text by Marc DAOU

Latest update : 2009-12-22

As Romania celebrates the 20th anniversary of the toppling of Communist dictator Nicolae Ceausescu, misreporting of events in Timisoara by French media is also not likely to be forgotten.

In France, violent events leading up to Ceausescu’s execution captivated viewers but would go down in history for its hasty and misreported media coverage.

As explains French media historian Christian Delporte, the media rushed to cover Romania’s violent uprising, which they deemed much more fitting of a revolution than the relatively peaceful fall of the Berlin Wall.

Chasing the news

It all began in Romania’s second largest city, Timisoara, near the border with Hungary. On Dec. 17, 1989, a bloody crackdown on a protest against the eviction of dissident ethnic-Hungarian priest Laszlo Tokes left dozens dead, prompting further mass unrest across the country.

French private and public news networks, in fierce competition, broadcasted raw footage streaming in from the Romanian television.

Western media mainly depended on Romanian networks for information, explains Delporte.  “French journalists often found themselves watching live reports at the same time as viewers, losing their journalist’s role of choosing what to broadcast,” he says.

On Dec. 22, grim footage of 19 corpses - allegedly victims of the police crackdown in Timisoara - flashed on small screens across France. Yugoslavian and Hungarian news agencies were quoting a death toll of 4,630, a figure picked up by the usually reputable French news agency AFP.

Errors of judgement

Most French media didn’t bother to investigate the figures or check facts. One month later, it turned out that the corpses were of people who died before the protest even took place. The official death toll of the Romanian revolution in Timisoara eventually came down to 93. Twenty years on, the Timisoara hoax remains an example of journalists failing to check the accuracy of the news they broadcast.

“Media should be immune to a large-scale manipulation such as Timisoara. However, fierce competition and imitation in the media industry can always lead to mistakes,” says Delporte.

 

Date created : 2009-12-20

COMMENT(S)