Latest update: 09/01/2010 

- Australia - India - racism


Indian man in stable condition after being set alight by attackers

A man of Indian descent is in stable condition on Saturday after four men set the 29-year-old alight early on Saturday in a suburb of the Australian city of Melbourne, police said.

By News Wires (text)
 

AFP - A man of Indian descent was recovering in hospital on Saturday after a group of men set him on fire in the Australian city of Melbourne, police said, the latest in a string of similar attacks.

Police stressed there was no evidence of a racial motive after four men poured an unidentified fluid on the 29-year-old and set him alight in a suburb of the city, leaving him with 15 percent burns.

It follows the stabbing murder of another Indian in the city last weekend, which prompted a New Delhi newspaper to run a cartoon likening Australian police to the Ku Klux Klan, and in turn an angry reaction by Australian officials.

In the latest incident, the victim was parking his car in a side street after dinner with friends when he was attacked in the early hours of Saturday. His condition was described as stable.

"I believe there's no reason at this stage to consider this in any way racially motivated," detective sergeant Neil Smyth told reporters.

"The circumstances of parking a car randomly on a side street and just some people approaching him are a bit strange and it's highly unlikely, therefore, to be a targeted attack on any individual."

Police have only a vague description of the attackers "which is really just unspecific, just four males", Smyth said. "It is an unusual event."

Deputy Prime Minister Julia Gillard said the government "condemns all acts of violence in the strongest possible way.... This matter remains under investigation by the Victorian police."

In New Delhi, the Indian government said it was in touch with Australian authorities but urged the media "to exercise utmost restraint" while reporting the incident.

"The Indian high commissioner in Canberra and consul general in Melbourne are following up this matter vigorously with the Australian authorities," foreign ministry spokesman Vishnu Prakash said.

"Under the circumstances, the media is advised to exercise utmost restraint in reporting on these sensitive issues, as it could aggravate the situation and could have a bearing on our bilateral relations with Australia."

The murder on January 2 of Nitin Garg brought sharp condemnation from the Indian government and allegations of Australian racism in the Indian media.

India's Mail Today defended its cartoon, which showed an Australian police officer in a Ku Klux Klan hood, insisting the Melbourne force was a "racist organisation".

"We perceive the Melbourne police to be a racist organisation simply because it seems it is not acting fast enough, or seriously enough, on the attacks on Indian students," editor Bharat Bhushan said.

A series of attacks on Indian nationals and students in Australia sparked street protests and a diplomatic row in the middle of last year.

Comments (2)

Lets get this straight

-"it's highly unlikely to be a targeted attack on any individual." - detective sergeant Neil Smyth
--How about a targeted attack on a race of people? Its not necessary that they were targeting this man in particular, but maybe targeting his colour?

-In June, police said that 1,447 people of Indian origin were victims of crime against the person in Victoria between June 2008 and July 2009
-- Thats 4 attacks against Indians EACH DAY in Victoria State ALONE, Does no one else see a problem here?

-When Indian children are being stabbed to death and burned alive in a majority white country well known for racism right up until 1973, don't be so snappy when the parents exercise their right to freedom of expression and release a simple cartoon in a tabloid to vent their frustration.

In my opinion, if you dont

In my opinion, if you dont know the motivation behind a crime, you cannot say it is racially motivated OR that it ISNT racially motivated. To claim you dont know the motivation means that you cannot at the same time rule out one form of motivation. If you have no clues, then you should not close any doors. I am caucasian, but I find the choice to state definitively that there is NO racial motivation while at the same time admitting you dont know why this man was chosen, to be very peculiar and showing at least some form of bias. very very sad.

Face the facts

These attacks are obviously targeted - is the police there really so dense as to suggest they are not? Perhaps they would do better to try and maintain the peace than to work the press.

Post new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

Related Content
Close