- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Breaking News
Share :
Subscribe :
Subscribe :
Share :
Subscribe :
Subscribe :
Latest update: 17/01/2010
- France - Haiti earthquake
France's foreign ministry denies objecting to the US handling aid flights
The French Foreign Ministry said that France made "no protest" against the US handling of aid flights into Haiti, contradicting a statement made earlier by Junior Minister for Cooperation Alain Joyandet.
By News Wires (text)
AFP - The French government protested Saturday the US handling of aid flights into Haiti, after a French hospital aircraft was prevented from landing, Secretary of State for Cooperation Alain Joyandet said.
"I have made an official protest to the Americans through the US embassy," Joyandet told reporters at the US-operated airport in Port-au-Prince, the main port of entry into the impoverished Caribbean nation devastated by a massive earthquake.
A French hospital aircraft was turned back from the international airport on Friday, after a major logjam of dozens of planes carrying rescuers and supplies for survivors.
The Haitian government has tasked the United States with operating the airport, whose control tower was destroyed in Tuesday's 7.0-magnitude quake.



























Comments (13)
criminals for haiti
amerika war criminals...
France
Let the french people help,goverments only get on the way.
Long live the USA and Haiti
Alyssa
If the Haitian government has asked the U.S. to do this, then the situation is solved. The U.S. government is simply carrying out a favour to Haiti after Haiti asked for it. It isn't easy to deal with hundreds of planes arriving with aid, to one airport, that has a destroyed control tower with damage facilities. Let's not get carried away with this non-sense when people are DYING. The plane will arrive at another period of time.
Dear France
Isn't it embarrassing to be those who give little if any, claim to be humanitarians, while criticizing the US at every turn for being the opposite? On one hand you claim the US is selfish, yet we give other countries billions upon billions at every turn. Americans send their text message donations by the millions while you sit and call us selfish? We foolishly give credit to all of you for sending your little shipment, or plane, stating, "All of our allies are pulling together to help those in Haiti." You all sit and criticize the US in turn. You are hateful and jealous I think.
Alain Joyandet
Did Alain Joyandet escape from a lunatic asylum during the Earthquake? I'm not sure there this is a "Minister for Co-Operation" - especially one that is not co-operating.
.
Gratitude
Here in America we can dial a number on our cell phones, then write the word "Haiti" and a donation of $10.00 is automatically sent to the Red Cross. So far I understand that more than 10 million dollars has been raised. That was as of yesterday. And the economy here isn't great, but still, we're giving to ease human suffering. I also heard the French government donated TWO MILLION DOLLARS. Wow ! Apparently Monsieur Joyandet's concept of gratitude goes hand in hand with the French definition of generosity.
Mark Nolan
Saratoga, New York, USA
French Frustration
France: Nag, nag, moan, moan, whine, whine!
Using even this disaster to get yourself noticed is disgusting.
france
We're damned if we do, and we're damned if we don't. Perhaps we should't have helped at all.
Frances denouncement of the USA
I listened with anger at the news today of the French criticism of the U.S. It is not just the government that is involved in the aid to Haiti, but the American people. Who by the way have given millions of dollars to the relief effort that is not government money. What a slap in the face to these generous people. The U.S. can never do anything right, but we are helping in a big way and I am sick of France and the uncalled for attacks on a people who are generous to a fault.
RICHARD
I have made an enquiry regarding this matter, and have received a response in summary that more aid flights are arriving than can possibly land, but that coordination is getting better with time. This is an embarassment for us and I hope that it will not be repeated. There is immediate need for medical care and people are dying right now for the lack of it. It is laudible that many countries which have the capability to provide aid are attempting to do so. We stepped in to provide air traffic control because none existed and we had the capability. We are not trying to 'take over', just help mitigate the disasterous consequences of this calamity like everyone else. France and the U.S. work together on a variety of issues that effect us both all over the globe, and it would not be in our interest to jeopardize that work.
So what is it?
Either the French government has protested, or it has not. Either way, it has demonstrated incompetence.
France
The US will give more and do more than any other country. The rest of the world will criticize us again. The comments in the British papers I read already criticize us for sending soldiers. Look at the Tsunami. Americans gave 10x per person more than France. Haiti was a French colony and my guess is they will only give a token amount.
pathetic mess
how pathethic ...engaging in turf wars while people are dying
Post new comment