Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

MEDIAWATCH

Macron's airforce uniform draws Tom Cruise comparisons

Read more

THE DEBATE

Polish democracy under threat: EU warns Warsaw over judicial independence

Read more

PEOPLE & PROFIT

Game of Thrones and TV's golden age

Read more

ENCORE!

The best of the summer's exhibitions in Paris

Read more

INSIDE THE AMERICAS

Game of Thrones returns: Mega fans bask in themed pop-up bar

Read more

FOCUS

Unwanted children: 3,800 babies abandoned in South Africa every year

Read more

THE INTERVIEW

'Looking for Lenin': The search for fallen Soviet statues in Ukraine

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

From footballer to inmate: Will OJ Simpson be released?

Read more

BUSINESS DAILY

Time to taper? ECB governing council meets in Frankfurt

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

An overview of the stories making the French and international newspaper headlines. From Monday to Friday live at 7.20 am and 9.20 am Paris time.

Latest update : 2010-03-03

Chile “saved by Pinochet and Milton Friedman”

Right-leaning columnist for the Wall Street Journal, Bret Stevens, attributes Chile’s low death toll in the recent quake to reforms made by Augusto Pinochet and inspired by free-market economist Milton Friedman. Stevens arguments are picked apart by Jason Linkins in the Huffington Post. WEDNESDAY, 3rd MARCH, 2010

 

In this morning’s Wall Street Journal, Bret Stevens attributes the low rate of death after the Chilean quake to Augusto Pinochet and Milton Friedman.Friedman is considered as one of the most important economists of the 20th Century and an arch-proponent of neo-liberalism and free trade economics.According to Stevens, Pinochet transformed Chile’s economy to a free-trade one having consulted with the famous economist.
 
“Friedman’s spirit was surely hovering protectively over Chile in the early hours of Saturday. Thanks to him the country has endured a tragedy that elsewhere would have been an apocalypse.”
 
Stevens predictably employs the same tired comparisons with Haiti that have been trotted out all week:
 
“It’s not by chance that Chileans were living in houses of brick and Haitians in houses of straw when the wolf arrived to blow them down.”
 
Writing in the Huffington Post, Jason Linkinspoints out some inconvenients truths that upset Bret Stevens logic.
 
Linkins references academics who point out that Chile’s economic success is founded on two industries – copper and agriculture.
 
Copper was never privatized (which doesn’t adhere to Friedman’s economics); it remained state-controlled under Pinochet and provided massive export revenues.
 
As for agriculture, it was reformed under the socialist government of Salvador Allende (overthrown by Pinochet) who broke up Chile’s feudal estates and distributed the land to a new class of farmers whose exports have also driven the economy.
 
The article also points out that the much-praised building codes that prevented buildings from collapsing during the quake were brought in 1972 – before Pinochet.
 
Perhaps most importantly, Linkins cites one statistic conveniently ignored by Bret Stevens: some 2,300 persons were killed by Pinochet’s regime. The death toll from the quake currently stands at around 800. Viewed in this light, Pinochet’s legacy of “saving Chilean lives” doesn’t really stand up to scrutiny.
 
Other stories in today’s international papers:
 
Times Online: Silvio Berlusconi’s party out of poll count in ‘comedy of errors’
 
La Stampa:  “Liste, stop anche alla Polverini” (Polverini blocked from electoral lists)
 
The Independent: “Is there anything the Winklevoss twins can’t do?”
 
The Daily Mail: “Murder most fowl: Three hens and cockerel named Dude peck fox to death after it breaks into coop”

 

By James CREEDON

COMMENT(S)

Archives

2017-07-20 OJ Simpson

From footballer to inmate: Will OJ Simpson be released?

IN THE WORLD PAPERS - Thursday, July 20: In the United States, OJ Simpson faces a parole board and could be freed as early as October. Also, Donald Trump decides to end a CIA...

Read more

2017-07-20 Emmanuel Macron

Macron and the military: Has power gone to his head?

IN THE FRENCH PAPERS - Thursday, July 20: We look at reactions to the very public spat between French President Emmanuel Macron and Pierre de Villiers, the head of the military,...

Read more

2017-07-19 Donald Trump

Shopping centre security robot 'commits suicide' out of boredom

IN THE FRENCH PAPERS - Wednesday, July 19: We look at reactions after the White House reveals that Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin met "informally" over dinner at the G20 summit....

Read more

2017-07-19 France

Not so local: Are French city centres overrun by mass commerce?

IN THE FRENCH PAPERS - Wednesday, July 19: We look at the one-year anniversary of the passing of Adama Traoré, a young Frenchman whose death in police custody set off suburban...

Read more

2017-07-18 healthcare reform

'Bill Withers': Is Trumpcare finally dead?

IN THE WORLD PAPERS - Thursday, July 18: We look at reactions after Donald Trump's efforts to repeal and replace Obamacare face defeat in the Senate. Also, the fatal shooting of...

Read more