April 19 marks the fifth anniversary of the pontificate of Benedict XVI. Since the beginning, he has made a habit of making bold statements and then frantically back-pedalling.
Europe is Christian
Benedict XVI made waves with his very first public appearance as pope - perhaps an indication of things to come - when on April 27, 2005 he questioned why the European Constitution didn't mention the “inalienable Christian roots of its culture and civilisation.”
Two years later, however, the Vatican softened its position, culminating in the Vatican endorsing Turkey’s accession to the European Union.
The Regensburg speech
On September 12, 2006, Benedict XVI delivered an address on the subject of faith at the University of Regensburg in Germany. By way of condemning violence in the name of religion, the pope quoted Byzantine Christian emperor Manuel Il Palaiologos, who denounced ‘Mohammed’s mandate to use the sword to spread his faith.’ This speech was almost universally condemned by Muslims.
Quenn Rania of Jordan welcomes the pope
Several months later, the pope tried to backpedal on his remarks, saying he “regretted” the misunderstanding created by his speech.
Three years later, the pope went to Jordan – his first visit to Muslim soil. He prayed at the Al-Hussein mosque, the largest in the nation. Benedict XVI is only the second pope to enter a mosque -- the first one having been John Paul II, his predecessor.
In July 2007, Benedict XVI relented on his career-long insistence that all masses be held in Latin. He also consented to allow the Traditionalist Catholic movement to adhere to the Tridentine Mass – an older version of the mass that Benedict had previously dismissed as non canonical.
The Williamson controversy and run-ins with the Jewish community
On January 24, 2009, Benedict XVI overruled the excommunication of four bishops from the Society of St. Pius X (which opposes Vatican II reforms) - including Holocaust-denying Bishop Richard Williamson. The decision created controversies in both the Catholic and Jewish communities. The Jewish community asked the pope to clarify his position. The Catholic community was divided on the matter. In an unusual move for a head of state, German Chancellor Angela Merkel demanded that the pope clarify his position.
The Vatican declared it was unaware of Williamson’ extreme views when it made the decision to overrule his excommunication. The pope requested that Williamson publicly retract his statements. However, the pope ultimately deemed the bishop’s contrition to be “insufficient.”
Beatification of Spanish Civil War martyrs
Taking up a cause championed by his papal predecessor, Benedict XVI beatified “498 martyrs of the Spanish Civil War” who died in the name of Catholicism. However, he undid some of that goodwill by hailing Franco loyalists – a very touchy issue in a nation still recovering from the legacy of fascism.
“Condoms aggravate the AIDS problem"
This statement reverberated around the world in March 2009 on the pope’s first trip to Africa. His statement went farther even than John Paul II, who opposed the use of condoms as a solution to the AIDS epidemic.
The beatification of Pius XII
In the beginning of February 2010, an enormous paedophilia scandal rocked the Dublin diocese. The church was accused of having covered up sexual abuse against children, spanning the period of 1975 to 2004. It was just the beginning of a long string of similar scandals in Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, and the US. As a damage control measure, Benedict XVI apologised to the Catholics of Ireland. But no sooner had he done so that he was accused of covering up for a paedophile cardinal. So great was the outrage that many called for the pope’s resignation – casting a cloud over Easter.
Date created : 2010-04-18