Latest update: 22/04/2010 

- France - Freedom of Speech - justice - photography


Outrage sparked by French flag bottom-wiping photo

Outrage sparked by French flag bottom-wiping photo

A photograph of a French flag being used instead of toilet paper is stirring passions in the south-east city of Nice, with France’s Justice Minister calling for “criminal prosecution”.

By FRANCE 24 (text)
 

A photograph of a man wiping his rear with the French flag has prompted France’s Minister of Justice Michele Alliot-Marie to demand the "criminal prosecution” of its authors.

The photograph won a special prize in a photo contest organised in Nice by FNAC, the French book and music store giant. The photograph, entered in the “politically incorrect” category, was then published on March 19 by the free newspaper Metro.

A spokesperson for Alliot-Marie said the minister was confident that those who desecrated the French flag could be punished under French law. "If the current law proves to be unsatisfactory on this point, then it should be changed," the spokesperson added.

Eric de Montgolfier, the state prosecutor in Nice, told news agency AFP that he had been made aware of the photograph by Eric Ciotti, president of the Alpes-Maritime regional council.

In a letter, Ciotti asked Minister Alliot-Marie to “please consider initiating proceedings against the perpetrators of these acts.”

“I want whoever committed this outrage to be penalized, and possibly those who published [the photo] too” Ciotti wrote.

FNAC’s regional director issued an apology Wednesday “to all those who have been shocked by the picture”, and said the photo would immediately be removed from the list of winners.

The Metro newspaper said it had only “reported on a local event”. “The question is what are the limits of art, provocation and freedom of expression," said Frederick Vézard, the daily’s editorial director.

Comments (10)

Desecration of the French national flag

All those concerned, the perpetrators of this act and the newspaper which gave them publicity, should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law and, on being found guilty, sentenced to a substantial period of imprisonment. Further, if any concerned in this matter are not French nationals by birth, they should be deprived of French citizenship and sent back to their country of origin.

Terrible

A flag is he symbolic embodiment of a nations people, not necessarily the policies of it's government. This should warrant prison time IMO, as it is nothing but a slap in the face to all those proud to be French!

French Flag

I hear the British Navy want to give the guy who did it a medal

freedom of speech does not

freedom of speech does not mean that a person should be ble to upset or play with people's sentiments, with freedom of speech you should express yourself without causing any hurt to any one regarding anything,relegion, national identity or infact anything, now people use freedom of speech to criticise and humiliate what they don't like and create big issues and upsets where they can.

unbelivable

This is utterly unacceptable, what has really gotten into people,am sure those who gave this picture a winner status are also lowlifes who really have no respect for themselves not to talk of the sovereignty of statehood,really sad what animals pass off as human.

The category was politically

The category was politically incorrect, so I'm sure it was the "most". Now it will be removed as a winner after everyone has seen it and been offended. I'm not French, but I felt outrage when I read this. How was it allowed to be entered? It's just gross and stupid.

Too much freedom

Try to do the same thing in any country around the world and you will understand the real price of lack of respect. I guess there is too much freedom in France and people feel that they can do whatever they want and not be punished. New law are necessary because nowaday more people do stupid things just because it is not illegal.... dooooo...what about doing smart things, work hard and respect others. Surely way to hard for some.

french flag

this is outrageours.

No wonder there are so many

No wonder there are so many injustices in the country... the Justice Minister is insane. She wants to change the law to fit the crime? She's been reading too much Orwell and Kafka. I know it is in bad taste to use the flag in such a way, but if it's not illegal then what does the Justice Minister have to do with it?

Despicable!

Using any country's flag (even if you are not in that country) as toilet paper is worse than burning the flag. I am sure that this is considered a federal offense (or at least the equivalent of such) in any country.

Post new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

Related Content
Close