- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 09/06/2010
- immigration - Mexico - USA
Mexican teenager shot dead at US border
Mexico has demanded an investigation into the apparent shooting death of a teenager by a US border patrol agent, an incident bound to stoke cross-border tensions over illegal immigration.
AFP - Mexico on Tuesday strongly condemned the US Border Patrol's "disproportionate" use of force after an agent shot dead a 14-year-old Mexican boy who was throwing rocks on a bridge linking the two nations.
The boy died after a border patrol officer opened fire from the El Paso, Texas, side of the border on a group who "threw stones" while apparently trying to enter the United States illegally from Ciudad Juarez, the Mexican Foreign Ministry said.
"The use of firearms to repel attacks with stones represents a disproportionate use of force," the ministry said in a statement.
President Ernesto Calderon "strongly condemns" the death of the teenager and will ask the United States to investigate "fully the incident and punish those held responsible," the president's office said in a statement.
Lou Patch, a supervisory Border Patrol agent in El Paso, confirmed that at least one agent opened fire during the Monday incident and said an investigation was under way, headed by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Patch told AFP that agents were "performing bike patrol duties" on the bridge when they were "assaulted with rocks by an unknown number of people."
"During the assault at least one agent discharged his firearm," he said.
The agent was placed on administrative leave and "a thorough multi-agency investigation is ongoing," he added.
Mexican officials said that according to witness statements, the US agents on bicycle pursued the youths toward Mexico and that two of them opened fire.
Mexican state police had earlier provided a different version of events, saying the boy had been playing with two other youths on the Puente Negro bridge spanning the Rio Grande.
Ciudad Juarez's attorney general's office also said the youths were playing when they strayed into US territory inadvertently, and ran back toward the Mexican side after being surprised by the US agents.
The victim's parents said their son was killed inside Mexico and that he had no intention of crossing the border.
Jesus Hernandez, the father, told W Radio his son went to the bridge to have lunch with his brother, who works nearby. At one point, "he went to the river bank to look to the other side.
"There were lots of kids and the border patrol cop... started firing off shots and hit my son, my baby twice in the head."
Hernandez said Mexican authorities had yet to contact the family about the incident.
The US State Department said US agents responded to "a group of suspected illegal immigrants from Mexico."
It said in a statement that "the agents were reportedly assaulted with rocks by an unknown number of people. During the assault, an agent discharged his firearm, killing one of the suspects. We regret the loss of life."
The teenager's death comes on the heels of a US investigation into the beating death last week in San Diego, California of Anastasio Hernandez, a 42-year-old Mexican father of five in Border Patrol custody for deportation for crossing the border illegally.
Mexico's foreign ministry said the cases of Mexicans killed or injured in incidents involving use of force by US authorities have risen, "from five in 2008 to 12 in 2009 and 17 so far this year."
The increasing frequency of such incidents "reflects a disturbing increase in the use of excessive force by some authorities in the border area," the ministry said.
An estimated 10.8 million illegal immigrants live in the United States. Roughly half a million people attempt to cross the 3,200-kilometer (2,000-mile) border from Mexico into the United States each year, according to official figures.
US President Barack Obama has ordered the deployment of up to 1,200 more troops on the border with Mexico to battle drug trafficking.




























React to the article
(8) Reactions
Non-lethal weapons
Non-lethal weapons will be able to bring these teenage rioters under control without killing them. I wonder where the parents of these "children" are when they're throwing rocks at the Border Patrol agents. It reminds me of the Palastinian rioters throwing rocks at the Israeli soldiers.
Simple Solution
There are a few problems. But the biggest is the inconsistent enforcement of laws. Virtually 100% of the time illegal aliens are aided, coddled, and practically carried over the border. Don't forget a couple years ago a border guard was sent to US prison for firing back and wounding one of their drug smugglers. As likely as not that will be this poor man's fate too.
What we need is a consistent response to the invasion of our nation by this foreign aggressor. It should be consistent so there is no mistake about what will happen. To this end I suggest the US government seize a 15 mile exclusion zone along the entire border. This is specifically allowed in the US Constitution (look it up)!
Then you put the US Marines in this exclusion zone with one simple order. Kill everything that invades our country. Problem solved in less than 24 hours. Likely as not, not a single shot would ever be fired.
And the cost of all this? It would probably turn a healthy profit from US citizens getting jobs and paying taxes now that such jobs would be available again.
Moral: Don't throw rocks at
Moral: Don't throw rocks at officers and don't try to hop the boarder. Play somewhere else.
Remorse
I'm sorry to the family of this child for what my country calls due process. I feel shame in my heart for the condition of my "land of oppertunity, freedom and justice." Americans have become tugs on the border with our neighbors to the south. The agent shot into Mexico and killed a child, needs to be tried by Mexican law. We as a country can't protect bad agents. Lethal force is not warranted, ever, agents children...even throwing rocks. Mr. President, change our immigration laws to be people laws not hate laws. Embrace the less fortunate, they are our brothers and sisters. Extend your hand. Declare Arizona's new law Discrimination and illigal by international standards. We can only lead by example.
The news earlier stated these
The news earlier stated these teens were throwing rocks, tormenting the officials like running bacjk and fourth to see if theyd get caught crossing the border etc.. I feel theres alot more to this story than being told. The USA would NEVER deliberately shoot anyone unless there was just cuase. Especially a teenager. I feel this is all set up, as people in usa are against the new border law from arizonia and also in mesico. Mexico has NO say in our laws, here in the USA> sure their against it, their people comeinto this country illegally, take the jobs, money schooling etc.. and send it back to mexico. Alot of the illegals are committing more crimes and well I agree with the new laws of arizonia. My thoughts and prayers are with the shot teens family but I still feel theres alot to this story that is NOT being told!!
Throwing "stones"
Tell you what. Let's do a little experiment. Let's take Mexican president Ernesto Calderon and stand him about 30 to 40 feet away from me. And then I'll start throwing nice smooth rocks about 4 or 5 inches in diameter right at his head, as hard as I can throw. Oh yes, if I hit him in the head just right and fracture his skull or even kill him, I get to go free, okay? That was the situation on border bridge involving that border patrol agent and that poor little lamb that he fired at the day before yesterday. "Disproportionate force?" Tell you what, if President Calderon wants to make himself available to enact my little experiment, all he has to do is name the time and the place. I'll bring my own rocks.
Mexican shot
So was the child on the US side or was he in the Mexico side? Appears no one wants to say where he was. Incrimmingating to say the least if he was in Mexico. Are we allowed to shoot across international borders? At kids? Hmmmm interesting.....
Mexican teenager shot dead at US border
I am saddened by the incident that has happened, in Texas. We have turned into a society that acts before thinking. And where public officials believe they are above the law.
However, there is a correction Arizona did not pass a immigration law. It is a law that simple states that all immigrants in Arizona must now carry their alien registration documents and it means that police can question anyone they think may be in the United States illegally. It will also address people that knowingly hire illegal immigrants or who transport them.
It is illegal for someone to be in the United States. Arizona just placed the same Federal Law into the state books. As well Arizona is not the only state with a similar law in the books. EVEN boycotting California, has a law in place California penal code 834a,b,c. Which allows law enforcement officers to stop anyone they merely suspect of being there illegally and it can be based on race. Not so with the Arizona law.