Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

THE INTERVIEW

Simon Serfaty, US foreign policy specialist

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

'It's a War, Stupid!'

Read more

BUSINESS DAILY

French PM calls on ECB to go further to help economy

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

'I love the Socialists'

Read more

WEB NEWS

Ukraine: Web users call for international assistance

Read more

WEB NEWS

France: Fighting political corruption with transparency

Read more

MEDIAWATCH

No strategy and a beige suit

Read more

AFRICA NEWS

South Africa: Four men found guilty of shooting Rwandan exile

Read more

THE WORLD THIS WEEK

The World This Week - August 29th, 2014

Read more

  • Ukrainian forces retreat from Luhansk airport after clashes

    Read more

  • Iraqi forces free Armeli in biggest victory over IS militants since June

    Read more

  • Anti-government protesters storm Pakistan's state TV

    Read more

  • Putin calls for talks on 'statehood' for east Ukraine

    Read more

  • Teddy Riner, France’s unstoppable judo champion

    Read more

  • Rescue efforts under way after French apartment block blast

    Read more

  • PSG trounce Saint-Etienne 5-0 with Ibrahimovic hat trick

    Read more

  • Poland marks 75 years since German invasion of WWII

    Read more

  • Israel appropriates large tracts of West Bank land

    Read more

  • Tension rises in Hong Kong as Beijing rejects open elections

    Read more

  • French police stop 'teenage jihadist' from flying to Syria

    Read more

  • Kidnapped Yazidi women 'sold to Islamists' in Syria

    Read more

  • Confusion reigns after Lesotho 'coup'

    Read more

  • French PM vows to safeguard 35-hour work week

    Read more

  • Inside Novoazovsk – the pro-Russians' latest conquest

    Read more

France

Anti-veil law risks being shot down by constitutional council

Text by Gaëlle LE ROUX

Latest update : 2010-07-08

France’s UMP party leader at the National Assembly has declared that the party's proposed anti-veil law would be sent to the Constitutional Council to confirm its constitutional validity, a rather risky move for the party.

A proposed law against the wearing of the full Islamic veil in French public spaces is to be sent to France’s Constitutional Council after being voted on by the Parliament.That was the surprise announcement by Jean-Francois Cope, head of the ruling UMP party in parliament, during a debate on the text by the French National Assembly on Wednesday.

The ‘Sages’ (wise ones), as the Constitutional Council of France is popularly known, are charged with examining the compatibility of laws with the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the constitution. But there’s a strong chance that they will reject a general ban on the Muslim veil, making it a risky bet for the majority party.

Back in March, the State Council, an advisory government body headed by the prime minister, expressed serious reserves on a “general and absolute ban on the wearing of the full veil as such or any method of concealing the face in all public spaces," saying that the act "would be exposed to serious risks with regards to the Constitution...".

Gilles Devers, a lawyer in Lyon and co-author of the book Law and Islam, agrees: "This law touches on fundamental freedoms, it will not withstand the scrutiny of the Constitutional Council," he said.

'A woman in a burqa could bring the republic to its knees'

The Constitutional Council is likely to follow the line taken by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) which, back in February, said that "religious attire in public space cannot be banned except if [people] were accompanied by excessive proselytism, felt as real pressure on passers-by".

"The Constitutional Council cannot really take a decision contrary to the ECHR," said Devers.

So the government's landmark law, which has already generated a great deal of controversy, could be declared unconstitutional.

But according to Devers, not trying to obtain a council endorsement before promulgating the law would be disastrous for the majority UMP party since a radical change of rules in March that now means any individual citizen can challenge a law’s constitutional validity.

If the anti-veil law were to be adopted without the council's approval, "the first woman in a burqa cited for it could, through her lawyer and following a few legal procedures, go before the Constitutional Council and have the law annulled within six or eight months," said Devers.

“It would be an irony of history", he added, if "the first person to bring down a republic forgetful of fundamental rights would be a woman in a burqa…”. 

Date created : 2010-07-08

  • FRANCE

    Security tight as French parliament debates burqa ban

    Read more

  • FRANCE

    Sarkozy calls burqa ban bill a 'moral' choice

    Read more

  • FRANCE

    Kouchner expects international backlash over burqa ban

    Read more

COMMENT(S)