Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

BUSINESS DAILY

Argentina set for deeper recession after default

Read more

THE INTERVIEW

Dr Matshidiso Moeti, Former WHO Deputy Regional Director for Africa

Read more

MEDIAWATCH

Towards a 'Third Intifada'?

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

Germany and Russia discuss secret Ukraine deal

Read more

DEBATE

Iraq's Christians: Nowhere to Run? (part 2)

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

France commemorates a hero of the left

Read more

DEBATE

Iraq's Christians: Nowhere to Run?

Read more

WEB NEWS

Fake Twitter accounts spread chinese propaganda

Read more

FOCUS

What solutions for California's overcrowded prisons?

Read more

  • Israel calls up 16,000 more reservist as Gaza death toll soars

    Read more

  • Scores feared dead in India landslide

    Read more

  • Kiev declares 24-hour ceasefire to aid MH17 probe

    Read more

  • Video: Inside Hamas ‘terror’ tunnels in Gaza

    Read more

  • Sierra Leone quarantines Ebola outbreak epicentres

    Read more

  • Russia ordered to pay further EUR1.9bn to Yukos shareholders

    Read more

  • Iraq's Christians: Nowhere to Run?

    Read more

  • Russia defiant as US, EU unveil 'phase three' sanctions

    Read more

  • US House votes to sue Obama for over-reaching his powers

    Read more

  • Argentina fails to reach deal with creditors

    Read more

  • Women should not laugh in public, Turkey's deputy PM says

    Read more

  • Suspect in Jewish Museum attack charged with 'terrorist' murder

    Read more

  • US rebounds to 4% growth in second quarter

    Read more

  • Rats on the rampage at Louvre museum gardens

    Read more

Americas

Scientists offer conflicting BP oil spill cleanup figures

Text by Julien PEYRON

Latest update : 2010-08-25

What has happened to the millions of barrels of crude oil that escaped into the Gulf of Mexico throughout the summer? Recent reports suggest that even the scientists are struggling to answer the question.

Figures on the amount of oil still in the Gulf of Mexico have baffled the public since the BP well was capped. The numbers vary so wildly that Gulf coast residents are not sure if they should be alarmed or feel reassured.

Some 784 million litres of crude oil escaped into the ocean since April, and now scientists seem at odds over how much, or how little, of it is still there.

Figures presented in an August 4th report by the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) suggests that three-quarters of the spill has been eliminated.

But experts at the University of Georgia rained on those sunny estimates on August 16th, publishing their own study that says 79 percent of the oil remains in the water.

On the margins of error

But for some experts, the huge gap in the reports is not impossible to reconcile, or perhaps proof of the researchers’ incompetence. “You have to consider the margins of error in both studies,” says Christophe Rousseau of the French-based Centre for Research and Testing on Accidental Water Pollution (Cedre). “Considering the significant margins [of error], the two studies are not as contradictory as they might seem.”

“The figures are not incorrect, but they are estimates,” continues Rousseau. “The researchers at NOAA and the University of Georgia, who are both capable scientists and even renowned in this field, should have stressed the fact they are working with estimates.”

According to Rousseau, the two groups were not working with the same amounts of leaked oil; another explanation for the discrepancy. The University of Georgia study, Rousseau claims, did not account for oil recovered at the ocean bottom, some 17 percent of the total leaked oil.



Lessons from Erika

The debates surrounding the cleanup efforts in the Gulf of Mexico oil spill are reminiscent of those in France after the 1999 Erika oil tanker disaster.

But there are important differences between the two events, Rousseau says. The oil slick on the Brittany coast was heavy, refined oil that spilled close to shore. The images of the environmental disaster were beamed into people’s homes and shocked a nation.

“But the closer the leakage is to the coast, the easier it is to recover the oil,” says Rousseau. “In the case of BP, the light crude is very difficult to recover. The leak occurred off the coast and at great depths, so the percentage of oil that will remain in the ocean will be much higher.”

Like other oil spills, the associated images will stick in the public’s memory far longer than figures or statistics. To combat this, US President Barack Obama did not hesitate to invite the media to join him for a dip in Florida waters.

Unfortunately for the US administration, the New Orleans daily the Times-Picayune recently reported that thousands of dead fish have been found at the mouth of the Mississippi river. Authorities have announced they will investigate a possible link with the oil spill.

Date created : 2010-08-25

  • BP OIL SPILL

    Obama takes a dip to encourage Gulf Coast tourism

    Read more

  • BP OIL SPILL

    Oil spill battle 'just about over', says Obama

    Read more

  • BP OIL SPILL

    BP finishes pumping cement into oil well in bid to seal leak

    Read more

COMMENT(S)