Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

MEDIAWATCH

Royal decree on low-cut tops

Read more

DEBATE

Ukraine, The Escalation: No Stopping Putin? (part 2)

Read more

DEBATE

Ukraine, The Escalation: No Stopping Putin?

Read more

FOCUS

Bangladesh: Textile workers' lives still at risk?

Read more

TALKING EUROPE

José Bové, Candidate for the EU Commission presidency, Group of the Greens

Read more

WEB NEWS

NYPD's online campaign backfires

Read more

ENCORE!

Celebrating the Bard's birthday in Britain

Read more

THE INTERVIEW

Yuki Tatsumi, Senior Associate of the East Asia Program, Stimson Center

Read more

INSIDE THE AMERICAS

USA: Executions halted over drugs secrecy

Read more

  • Ferry disaster, nuclear test fears cloud Obama’s South Korea trip

    Read more

  • US warns Russia against making ‘expensive mistake’ in Ukraine

    Read more

  • Israel halts Middle East peace talks over Hamas deal

    Read more

  • French policemen accused of raping Canadian woman

    Read more

  • Internet should stay free of government intervention, conference says

    Read more

  • A radio station defends peace and tolerance in CAR

    Read more

  • Echoes of 2pac and Biggie? French rap feud turns violent

    Read more

  • Fresh clashes in Rio over dancer's death

    Read more

  • US would defend Japan in islands dispute, Obama says

    Read more

  • Platini: PSG in danger over Financial Fair Play rules

    Read more

  • Afghan guard kills US doctors in Kabul hospital attack

    Read more

  • Ségolène Royal denies banning cleavage at French ministry

    Read more

  • Video: Mayor in east Ukraine ready ‘to turn Slaviansk into battlefield’

    Read more

  • New far-right mayor moves to quash Paris region mosque

    Read more

  • Millions of Syrians desperately need aid, says UN

    Read more

  • Muslims in CAR pray for an escape route

    Read more

  • Madrid beat Bayern 1-0 in first leg of Champions League semis

    Read more

  • Britain's ex-PM Blair warns against spread of radical Islam

    Read more

  • Turkish PM offers condolences to descendants of Armenians killed in 1915

    Read more

France

Migrant spat puts strain on EU open borders

©

Text by Mehdi Chebil

Latest update : 2011-04-19

Thousands of North African migrants in Italian refugee centres remain in legal limbo as a diplomatic row escalates between the French and Italian governments over the key principle of free movement within the European Union.

The fate of thousands of stranded Tunisian migrants bearing temporary residence permits remained unclear on Tuesday as activists vowed to challenge the French authorities' refusal to let them cross the border from Italy. Their campaign came amid an increasingly bitter diplomatic spat that deepened when France temporarily suspended a rail link to prevent a train carrying Tunisians and pro-migrant protesters from entering French territory.

Several migration experts contacted by France24.com said that the Italian-delivered permits would not be sufficient to reach France, where many Tunisian migrants have family or friends. But they warned that the move’s legality was “confusing”, forcing Paris to tread a fine line between intensifying border checks and respecting the European principle of free movement enshrined in the Schengen treaty.

Ethnic profiling

As French police continue to monitor trains, roads and foot trails coming from the Italian Riviera town of Ventimiglia, their border controls will come under increased scrutiny from pro-migrant activists checking whether they comply with European and French laws against ethnic profiling.

Brigitte Espuche, a legal expert from the French rights group Anafé, told France24.com that overt targeting of North African migrants could spark a discrimination lawsuit and jeopardise the French policy of restricting cross-border movements.

“Police forces are aware that it would be completely illegal. When reports emerged on February 21 that an internal note calling for the control of Tunisian nationals was put up in the Cannes police station, it was pulled down the next day”, says Brigitte Espuche.

Sufficient funds

Migration experts are also questioning whether French plans to control all migrants with permits in order to deport those who can’t produce evidence of “sufficient funds” is actually enforceable once migrants are already in the Schengen zone. Monitoring of migrants’ financial means is legal under European law, but it is usually performed outside the borders of the Schengen zone.

“We have received first-hand reports from people who boarded trains in Ventimiglia; they told us that police randomly ask to see some passengers’ money. Sometimes a migrant will show 50 euros and it will be fine, but sometimes it won’t. It’s the sort of rule that is impossible to enforce”, said Claire Rodier, the vice-president of Migreurop, an umbrella organisation for pro-migrant advocacy groups.

An internal administrative note from French Interior Minister Claude Gueant put the amount of sufficient funds at 62 euros per day (31 if hosted for free) but remains silent over how police can assess the migrant’s prospective length of stay. In other words, a Tunisian migrant equipped with an Italian residency permit could legally cross into France with 124 euros in his pocket if he claims that he doesn’t intend to stay more than two days.

Slap in the face

The current border crisis has been brewing since Italy decided to grant six-month residency permits to more than 20,000 migrants, mostly Tunisians, who fled political and economic upheaval back home by boarding boats to the tiny southern Italian island of Lampedusa. French authorities reacted by reinforcing police patrols along their south-eastern border, angrily rejecting Rome’s claim that such permits allow migrants to travel freely around Europe.

Tensions came to a head on April 17 when France blocked cross-border trains coming from Ventimiglia for several hours, leaving hundreds of travellers stranded. The drastic decision sparked a public outcry in Italy, with La Repubblica newspaper calling it a “slap in the face” for Rome.

Legal challenge

Few Italian commentators bought the French explanation that the train shutdown was motivated by reasons of “public order” – the ultimate legal argument to temporarily suspend the Schengen treaty. Instead, migration jurists insist that Paris’s hardening stance is the result of a political strategy rather than a legal decision.

Claire Rodier told France24.com that her organisation was currently compiling individual testimonies from both Tunisian migrants with permits and EU citizens affected by the April 17 train blockade to challenge French policy.

“We are going to file a complaint to French administrative courts within one month… We will appeal against the authorities’ denial of access to France’s territory and take the case up to the European court of justice if necessary”.


 

Date created : 2011-04-19

  • IMMIGRATION

    EU says France had right to block migrant trains

    Read more

  • IMMIGRATION

    France blocks Italian train carrying Tunisian migrants

    Read more

  • DIPLOMACY

    EU blame-game over Tunisian migrants turns sour

    Read more

Comments

COMMENT(S)