Latest update: 18/05/2011 

- Dominique Strauss-Kahn - French politics - justice - opinion polls


Strauss-Kahn was set up, French say

Strauss-Kahn was set up, French say

When news broke that Dominique Strauss-Kahn was arrested in New York on criminal sex charges, theories that the IMF chief had been set up began circulating in France.

By Joseph BAMAT / Sébastian SEIBT (text)
 

In the immediate aftermath of Dominique Strauss-Kahn’s dramatic arrest, the majority of French people were inclined to believe that the managing director of the International Monetary Fund was the victim of a conspiracy, an opinion poll revealed on Wednesday.

The survey, conducted by French polling agency CSA after New York City police charged Strauss-Kahn with sexually assaulting and attempting to rape a hotel maid in a luxury hotel, found that 57 percent of people interviewed thought he was set up. Just 32 percent of people thought he was not the victim of a plot and a further 11 percent had no opinion.

The poll, published by the free daily 20 Minutes, was conducted in France on Monday, before New York judge Melissa Jackson denied Strauss-Kahn bail and ordered him to remain in custody, the newspaper said.

The poll echoed the scepticism expressed by many French politicians and analysts in the press. On Monday Michel Wieviorka, a French sociologist and expert on France’s political left said that “everyone’s first reaction” had been one of “utter disbelief.”

Members of Strauss-Kahn’s entourage also contributed to the conspiracy theories circulating in the news. Jean-Christophe Cambadélis, a Socialist Party member and a close aide to Strauss-Kahn, was quick to describe the incident as a plot to scupper the IMF chief's chance of winning next year's presidential election. “He was warned that there would be ‘nuclear war’ as soon as he got near to the presidency,” Cambadélis told journalists on Monday.

Dominique Strauss-Kahn, known in France as DSK for his initials, was widely expected to join the race for next year’s presidential election. According to opinion polls and a growing number of analysts, he was the clear frontrunner of the 2012 vote.

IMF chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn faces sexual assault charges

“Disbelief and conspiracy theories are the result of anguish,” explained Jérome Jamin, a Belgian writer and author of L'imaginaire du complot, a book on the fantasies behind conspiracy theories. “When we are confronted with something as incredible as the arrest of the boss of the IMF, which turns international and national agendas upside down, the reaction is to reject the official explanation.”

According to Jamin, the bigger an apparent anomaly or scandal is, the less likely people are ready to accept ordinary explanations.

“In general, conspiracy theories arise after an event with global consequences, or around a well-known public figure. The September 11 attacks are an example of an event that changes the course of history. The death of Marylin Monroe belongs to the second category. In Dominique Strauss-Kahn’s case, both conditions are present,” said Jamin.

In the days that have followed the CSA survey, a bedraggled Strauss-Kahn has appeared in court alongside his lawyer. Initial shock has given way to the assumption that a long and tedious legal battle lies ahead.

Other elements may already be changing public opinion. The Socialist Party has made it clear it is not putting its plan to hold primaries on hold. The French media, eager to meet the public’s demand for news about the accused, have revisited claims by Hungarian economist Piroska Nagy, who in 2008 said she was pressured into an affair by Strauss-Kahn while working at the IMF.

And in what will be a potential blow to Strauss-Kahn’s credibility before a jury, a young French novelist came forward this week with allegations that Strauss-Kahn tried to rape her in 2002.

 

Read more
React to the article
Comment this article typing your message in the above text zone. Please note that this is limited to 1500 characters or less.
(21) Reactions

Requirements to make an arrest

In the US, "probable cause" is required to make an arrest. It's in the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution. What is probable cause? "a reasonable amount of suspicion, supported by circumstances sufficiently strong to justify a prudent and cautious person's belief that certain facts are probably true."

In other words, there has to be a degree of evidence before the arrest can be made. Not enough to convict--that is what the trial is for--but enough to show there are good reasons to detain the accused.

An out-of-the blue accusation of a crime wouldn't meet this standard.

Face it, the US system is far from perfect, but it has logic and rules. When the trial starts, we'll see what kind of evidence the state of New York has against DSK.

Dom, We are by your side

I never in my mind have any doubt about your innocence. We in Hong Kong and China wish him well. He is a great man and should be treated with more respect by the US.

Will love to see the day you walk out of the courtroom an innocence man and be a Dragon again. The work you have done will always be in our heart. WE ARE With YOU.

Bush Did it

Yep, that's the ticket...Bush did it. The French are perfect and flawless!

presumed innocence??

How would you and I like it, if out of nowhere, someone called the cops and told a lie, then we are hand-cuffed and arrested in public? It could happen, you know? I think the act of doing that, is shameful and i would say even criminal. EVERYONE should be presumed innocent, but by doing it publicly the person is already halfway condemned - if not totally!

i believe it was a set up

The very act of hand-cuffing, then parading and publicly humiliating the person through every possible way - when such a person should be presumably innocent until after judgement - it is cruel, arrogant, shameful and barbaric!

What are the conspiracies?

I'm just curious, who do the French believe are responsible for setting up DSK? The Americans? Sarkozy? Adversaries within the IMF? Developing countries who want the IMF position to be held by someone other than a European? Obama? Martians?

And, I am really appreciating the debate in the legal systems. Americans, I think, do believe in innocent until proven guilty and were struck by the accusation by French press that photos taken compromised that, but they also hold freedom of the press and of speech very highly and would never allow a law like that in France that prevents the press from photographing the detained in public spaces. My suspicion is that there can be a middle ground.

Perhaps the US could do more to keep defendant's privacy without restricting the media?

you thaught?

Someone who can not spell "thought" should not be calling anyone a moron.

Kahn

I don't understand why the French are in denial about this. Do you believe it's a mark on the French people or government? That would be silly because France is not on trial; it's Strauss-Kahn. Get over it.

dsk's not an incident, but an industry pattern

everyone should watch with interest, the oscar nominated "inside job"- and learn that sexual aggression is a part of the financial industry's MO. job tension and stress are creating a psychic break, enabling these guys to feel they can hook up at will to relieve themselves, ( using our money in the bank, to pay for a hooker and party). we've all had bad bosses, and seen aberrant behaviors. he's not the first nor last to abuse society. a position of authority is no longer in his purvey, and that is good in some ways, and a distinct loss in many others. face it, we live in a two-tiered society, where one tier clearly pays to play, the other pays for it in terrible economic or personal consequence.
justice won't be served here, there will be a deal. true justice would be for all the women he has had business with to come forward in court, and also for society to stop abusing a person just because that person is a woman. so change and/or enforce the law.
i don't see that happening in my life. rich people always pay to get off. that's the way it is. more to the point, women will always be oppressed until they force the law to change- all over the world. it's time for women to unite and play "trojan women". that would be awesome. this nightmare story, not so much. it's filed under: SOS/different day.

conspiracy

It just shows that no one is above the law in the USA. If he is inocent he can prove it in court. If he is guilty then he will face the consequences. It takes a lot of guts to claim rape or attempted rape because the womans life will be under the microscope while the defense tries to blame her in some way for what happened. They will look at every aspect of her life and put it up for public scrutiny. Few people have lives that can stand up to that kind of analysis with out pain. Hopefully the truth will come out in the trial.

Close