Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

AFRICA NEWS

Nigeria attack: Bomb blast in college in Kano

Read more

MEDIAWATCH

Scotland's relationship status: "It's complicated"

Read more

DEBATE

Hollande Press Conference: French President Tackles Record Unpopularity

Read more

FOCUS

Cleaning up Thailand's shady surrogacy industry

Read more

ENCORE!

The Biennale des Antiquaires: Where Miro meets million-dollar jewellery and antiques

Read more

THE OBSERVERS

Attacks on migrants in Tangiers and unwelcome stares from men in Cairo

Read more

AFRICA NEWS

Ebola virus: US to send 3,000 troops to West Africa

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

France looks on as Scotland votes

Read more

FACE-OFF

Manuel Valls: A weakened Prime minister?

Read more

Opinion:
Melissa BELL

Melissa BELL
International Affairs Editor

How Greece exposed the cold, hard truth about European democracy

Le 04-11-2011

Rarely has the result of a confidence vote mattered less. Whether or not the government of George Papandreou wins the vote, it is almost certain to be replaced by a government of national unity. And that’s because it is a vote of confidence that is being held long after all confidence has gone. Whether he wins or loses tonight, George Papandreou is almost certain to go.

What did it for him in the end was not the rioting on the streets of Athens or bullying from Frankfurt but the impossibility of reconciling the pressures from both. For months he’s been stuck between a rock and hard place, between the austerity being urged from above and the resistance of the people below.

On Thursday he cracked.

His call for a referendum smacked of desperation, a sort of abdication of responsibility in the face of impossible and irreconcilable, upward and downward pressures. The problem being that the choice that must have appeared to him as the only way out, also happened to be the worst one possible.

It was also one that Germany and France were never going to accept. After weeks of round the clock negotiations, of grumbling at home, of putting their political capital on the line and all the while trying to patch up their differences; Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy watched on in horror as the Greek prime minister suggested giving it all up with the referendum proposal. And they both made their opinions felt quickly and forcefully. It was the euro that would be saved and not Greece, since Greece seemed unwilling to save itself.

The last few days have shown not only the cracks that have come to emerge in the eurozone, but the inadequacy of the very foundations on which it was built. They’ve also shown that the nature of Europe has changed profoundly. Those changes will now have to be digested and, no doubt, reconsidered because the problem is no longer just about currency, but about democracy.

In the end, the referendum proposal will likely cost Papandreou his job. But it has also shown Europe that power now lies beyond the grasp of national governments. It now lies with what has become the de facto government of the EU - the Franco-German couple, the leaders of just two European countries.

The ultimate irony of course being that it was by choosing to hand power to the people that Papandreou has shown just how far from them it has actually drifted.

COMMENT(S)