Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

IN THE PAPERS

'Life for British Muslims since 7/7'

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

Hollande and Merkel play good cop, bad cop on Greece

Read more

ACCESS ASIA

Burma: Fisherman returns home after 22 years as a slave

Read more

BUSINESS DAILY

Will Greece's banks be able to re-open on Thursday?

Read more

MEDIAWATCH

#Varoufexit: Greece's finance minister bows out

Read more

THE DEBATE

What now? Uncertainty for Greece and for Europe (part 1)

Read more

THE DEBATE

What now? Uncertainty for Greece and for Europe (part 2)

Read more

DOWN TO EARTH

Environmental migrants: The neglected refugees

Read more

REVISITED

One year after Gaza war, residents still struggling to survive

Read more

Opinion:
Luke BROWN

Luke BROWN
French Politics Reporter

François Hollande: he who dares, wins?

Le 23-01-2012

"My adversary has no name, no party, no face. And yet he is in charge. My adversary is the world of finance."

If François Hollande wanted a phrase to define his first major rally in this election campaign, he's found it.

Killing two birds with one stone, he brushed aside Nicolas Sarkozy, omitting to mention the President's name, and singled out what he reckons is the source of many ills in France.

All in all, Sunday's rally at Le Bourget, just north of Paris, is likely to be considered a success by the Socialist Party. There was lots of noise, cheering, flag-waving, queues outside as more people than expected turned up - a vital rule of politics: make it look like you're popular. Singer Yannick Noah gave it some welly as a warm-up act and there were smiles all round from the party barons, the « éléphants ».

François Hollande's spin doctor, Manuel Valls (officially « communications director » but known to have control over pretty much everything the candidate does in public) was apoplectic as Hollande made his entrance. This was an event that was choreographed down to the last detail; who sits next to who, (and who doesn't sit next to who); when activists sing and when they wave their flags. And then came Hollande, pausing as he made his way through the crowd, shaking interminable hands; shaking off, for a moment, Valls' demands to be on time.

It was a good speech, too; one that is worth being remembered (although whether it'll be remembered as a breakthrough ... won't be known until May!). François Hollande has been much mocked for being either a) wooden or b) jovial. He was neither on Sunday: his voice croaked as he bellowed out his message; sweat broke out on his brow as he flailed his arms to underline his point.

He made a clear step leftwards with the promise to 'Get The Financial Sector'. That's important, both to reassure the party, and to ensure he stands out from his rivals that are closest in the polls (that means François Bayrou). "I offer a clear choice, between Right and Left". There's little room for dithering there. 

The closest we got to a reference to Sarkozy was oblique, and disparaging: « improvising measures at the end of your mandate isn't the way to do things ». Shunning his main rival marks this speech out from his inauguration as candidate last autumn, where every second sentence seemed to wag a finger at the President and his rule.

Instead, this speech was about "je", a lot, and "nous", a fair amount. His goal is to outline that he is ready for the task. And that the Socialist Party, too, is ready to rule.

He and the party have « drawn the lessons » from the catastrophe of April 2002 (when the Front National beat the Socialist's Lionel Jospin into third place); he wants to reignite the « joy » of May 1981, when François Mittérand became modern France's first (and, so far, only) Socialist president.

But really, what good does the rally do in the campaign?

You can argue that it's zero-sum: if it goes well, you mobilise the base; badly, and it can alienate the undecided. 2007 saw Sarkozy's colossal effort at Bercy help him triumph over Ségolene Royal. Her speech – clutching her fist and hailing, almost in a trance-like state, that what she wanted was "for every child that is born and lives in France the same that I want for my own children" - was judged too emotional by many.

And, probably more importantly, what about the masses of disenchanted voters? They're unlikely to give two hoots about this rally, as Nathalie, an activist from Sévres pointed out. When she goes canvassing, door-to-door, the election and the candidates are far from people's minds. "It's not a campaign like the others in the past. In these hard times, people don't know who to vote for. Their real concern is to find out which one of the candidates will get them out of the crisis".

With promises to dismantle the wealthy financial elite, François Hollande is playing it safe with his own party. Vowing to make France a better place to grow up may not be new, but it does strike a chord. Both allow him to point the finger at – but not name – the man he judges responsible, the man he hopes to replace, Nicolas Sarkozy.

LATEST CONTRIBUTIONS OF Luke BROWN

COMMENT(S)