Latest update: 17/07/2012 

- Barack Obama - France - Republicans (USA) - US elections 2012 - US politics


'Being a Republican in the US or in France is exactly the same'

'Being a Republican in the US or in France is exactly the same'

France, with its socialised healthcare and high tax rate, may not seem like an ideal place for a US conservative to call home. Still, Republicans Abroad has a branch in Paris. France24.com caught up with one of its members (pictured left, at centre).

By Jon FROSCH / Julien PEYRON (text)
 

Ellen Wasylina, a middle-aged professor and international relations specialist from California, is a loyal, lifelong Republican. She supported the war in Iraq, believes in strictly limited government, and hopes Barack Obama will be roundly defeated in November’s US presidential election.

She also lives in France, land of socialised medicine, steep tax rates, and often fierce opposition to recent US military interventions.

Rather than check her political views at customs, Wasylina - who resides just outside Paris and teaches in three French business schools - is an active member of the French branch of Republicans Abroad, a worldwide network of conservative US expats who organise initiatives to promote the party’s policies in their adopted homeland.

Republicans Abroad France fact box

Republicans Abroad is a worldwide network of conservative US expats. 

In France, their branch :

- Has roughly 70 members

- Was established nearly 40 years ago

- Was granted “association” status by French government in early 90s

- Holds meetings, debates, voter registration drives for US expats, and outreach events for press, French nationals, and Americans living in France

- Is not allowed to endorse or raise money for any particular candidate
 

France24.com talked to Wasylina about the pleasures and what she describes as the pleasing contradictions of being an American Republican in France.

France24.com: What brought you to France?

Ellen Wasylina: I came to do an MBA in 1986. I liked it, stayed, met a Frenchman, started a family, etc. It was my dream to live in France. I’d been studying French since I was 10.

F24: What kind of Republican do you consider yourself?

EW: I’m a centrist, mainstream Republican, across the board. I’m not a person of extremes. That’s just my personality.

F24: Is it difficult being a US Republican in France?

EW: No. I’ve been a Republican all my life, and being a Republican in the States or in France is exactly the same to me. My values haven’t changed because I’m living abroad. I’ve encountered no judgemental reactions, no surprise from French people. Yes, I enjoy a debate with French people. My French students engage me in debate. The most recent experience was at CELSA, where I taught an intercultural seminar through the prism of the US presidential primaries and elections. It was a very vigorous, lively debate.

F24: What are your favourite and least favourite things about living in France?

EW: My favourite things are the wine, the cheese, and as a woman, the fabulous women’s fashion. Also, the quality of life, and the quality of the food in general. It’s a very interesting experience to live in the comparatively different political environment and system of France. It’s extremely informative and interesting. I wouldn’t have it any other way. My least favourite thing is probably the strikes. But it doesn’t really affect me.

F24: Do you feel well-integrated here?

EW: After 25 years, one tends to integrate. It was very easy for me to adapt. I’m of European descent: my father was Ukrainian, and my mother is from Saxony in eastern Germany. My first trip to France was at the age of 12.

F24: How do you feel about France’s largely socialised healthcare system? What about Obama’s healthcare reform?

Syndicate contentTHE DEBATES

EW: French healthcare is very good, but it comes at a price via the fiscal tax imposition rate. Do we want the same tax imposition rates in America as we have in France? Obamacare must be repealed. It’s against the 10th amendment for the federal government to oblige American citizens to get health insurance. With Obamacare, there is too much federal government involved in healthcare, and as some of our Republican candidates have been saying, let’s give these issues back to the states.

F24: How do you feel about the tax code here?

EW: I do feel the French could reduce their tax rates. They could also reduce their social charges to encourage entrepreneurs to take on new challenges. The charges are just so high that when you want to hire someone here, you’re paying double his salary just to hire him.

F24: How do you feel about France’s gun control policy in comparison to America’s?

EW: Guns are a big problem in that too many accidents happen. I think there’s something to be done to prohibit free circulation of guns in America. It’s a constitutional right, but I think there’s something to be done.

F24: How do you feel about the often negative image of France among US Republicans?

EW: I would say that it’s great that Mitt Romney learned French and has a certain cultural interest in France. I invite all Americans to come to France and get to know France and the French like I now have.

F24: Why do you think the French are still supportive of Obama?

EW: I think the programmes of his administration are very similar to the programmes that exist in France.

F24: Now that you’ve lived in a country with a real Socialist party, what do you think of US Republicans who say Obama is a Socialist?

EW: I would say that the policies of his government are moving toward the left and making government much more powerful and central to political, economic and social decision-making in America.

F24: Are you following the French elections? Which candidate appeals to you?

EW: I’m as fascinated this time as I am every election, so I follow very closely. To get France out of a crisis, I do believe the policies should not involve more government spending or taxing French citizens at a 75-percent rate. You can’t compare American and French politics. But I would identify myself more closely to the UMP [centre-right] party overall. And certainly I like the very bold reforms that have been undertaken under President Sarkozy.

Read more
React to the article
Comment this article typing your message in the above text zone. Please note that this is limited to 1500 characters or less.
(8) Reactions

French republicans

She a woman she should have babies and stay in the kitchen.more useful to society.

Former Republican to Republicans Abroad

You are all idiots! Stay abroad & don't come back to the US.
How can you say people die from gun accidents? Murder isn't an accident. The French have the right idea of combining capitalism with social programs to ensure social justice. Republicans have no social conscience. They love their money more than their fellow countrymen. Shame on them!

Naturally

They both hate black people, brown people, women, and the poor. Of course they are the same.

Insane Asylum

Yep, exactly the same - guests at an Asylum for the Insane.

I agree with jt

I agree with jt's comments wholeheartedly. Furthermore, I find Ms. Wasylina's comments to be very idiotic. She lives in France yet is a hypocrite. She praises their healthcare system yet wants to deny the same system for her fellow Americans. Healthcare is a right. It's unfortunate that it has become a pawn in America where big business rules. I mean the only reason these right winger's wish to force individuals to pay for their healthcare is because of the personal interests they have in the healthcare industry.

Apart from the other stupid things that Ms. Wasylina mentions, I find it quite amusing that she finds Mitt Romney has a 'cultural interest' in France and that it's great he speaks French. Really? That is wishful thinking really. Also it surprises me not that she would look up to such a dishonest type.

The Republicans Abroad are lucky that Europe has not deported the lot of them for being critical of their laws in their countries. It's ridiculous to move to a foreign country then try and get the laws changed in their favor.

She should be ashamed.

This woman lives in France and enjoys the benefits of it's healthcare system but wants to deny the same to the people in her home country.

How come ALL political

How come ALL political candidates except Ron Paul want to keep the federal reserve?
...Because ALL political candidates except Ron Paul allow International bankers who own the federal reserve to treat Americans like cattle....that's why! And these CORRUPT ASSKISSING POLITICIANS sell Americans out, just so they can "lubricate-their-egos" and become "Big-Shot-President".
What crime is committed when ALL political candidates except for Ron Paul allow "foreign-entities" to "commercialize" the federal reserve AND VIOLATE CONSTITUTIONAL LAW?
Answer : treason!
How does military and constitutional law respond to treason?
Write answer here ________________

A Republican in France...jt

In America or in France the statement "Obamacare must be repealed. It’s against the 10th amendment for the federal government to oblige American citizens to get health insurance." is simply false.

A very politicized right-wing Supreme Court may find (5-4) with this woman's presumption, but that finding would be inconsistent with decades of Supreme Court decisions on interstate commerce. Her's is an expression of the same reactionary spirit that has a minority of Americans up in arms about a system that offers a responsible approach to universal health care.

It is incomprehensible to me, that anyone would fight to keep their health insurance in the hands of a predatory, under-regulated and utterly inefficient (30% overhead in US vs. 8% in France) health insurance system.

Except for government run universal health insurance, the only way to have a logical system without individual responsibility for buying health care is for people, who have refused to pay, to be denied care when they are ill — that is inhuman. Thus, this is the typical conservative principle of faux rugged individualism from citizens who are neither rugged nor individualistic, but merely conventional and illogical, which has led America into paths that are dysfunctional.

I too am an American who lives in France. "Liberté, égalité, fraternité" is the motto for the France that I love, not the “Travail, famille, patrie” of the reactionary and the Republican.

Close