- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 22/06/2012
- Burma - human rights
‘Burma’s Rohingya minority are the Roma of Asia’
More than 80 people have been killed and thousands displaced in a wave of violence between Muslims and Buddhists in west Burma. Among those targeted in the clashes is the Muslim Rohingya minority, called “Asia’s Roma” by researcher David Camroux.
By Charlotte Oberti (text)
Western Burma has been rocked by violence since the start of June, when the rape and murder of a 27-year-old Buddhist woman, allegedly by local Muslims, triggered a series of reprisals between communities.
The attacks have left more than 80 people dead and have displaced thousands, prompting the government to declare a state of emergency in Rakhine, a state formerly known as Arakan.
According to David Camroux, a researcher at the Paris-based Sciences Po-Ceri (Centre for international studies and research), the wave of communitarian violence was a disaster waiting to happen in a country torn between different ethnic groups.
A deeply divided society
Named after a Buddhist ethnic group that makes up the majority of the population, Rakhine state also counts a sizeable Muslim minority, which includes the Rohingya, a particularly persecuted group.
The 800,000-strong Rohingya are pariahs: they are stateless, and pejoratively called “Bengalis” by the Burmese, who consider them to be refugees from neighbouring Bangladesh.
But those who have tried to flee by boat to Bangladesh, where they are equally despised, have been turned back.
“The Rohingya are the Roma of Asia, nobody respects their human rights,” David Camroux told FRANCE 24.
In a country where 89% of the population embraces Buddhism and only 4% Islam, anti-Muslim sentiment is rampant.
“British colonisation left its mark on Burma. Britain’s strategy was to divide and conquer, pitting the various ethnic groups against each other. After independence [in 1948] the Burmese became more nationalist, and nowadays xenophobia is common,” said David Camroux.
The Rohingya, who were stripped of their Burmese citizenship in 1982 by military dictator Ne Win, are not represented in parliament, whereas other ethnic minorities such as the Karen, the Shan and the Kachin are.
“They have no political leader and they live in poverty,” said David Camroux.
Forgotten by the international community
Since securing independence in 1948, Burma has struggled to create a feeling of national unity from a patchwork society. The Burmese government, which has renamed the country Myanmar, officially recognises 135 distinct ethnic groups – but the Rohingya are among them.
Opposition figure Aung San Suu Kyi called for national reconciliation in her Nobel Peace Prize speech in Oslo last Saturday.
On her first trip to Europe in two decades, she also told Burmese exiles “we have to avoid saying and doing things that will make the problem worse, we have to calm it down,” referring to the sectarian clashes.
“But she stopped short of adopting a clear stance [on the Rohingya issue],” said David Camroux. “The Rohingya have been forgotten by the international community.”
Meanwhile, the situation on the ground remains unclear, especially as much of northern Rakhine state is a no-go area for journalists and independent observers, making it difficult to verify conflicting versions of events.
While local authorities say calm has returned to the area, a statement on Thursday by the Myanmar Ethnic Rohingya Human Rights Organizations Malaysia (Merhrom) said the situation was becoming “worse day by day”.



























React to the article
(13) Reactions
REQUESTING FOER HUMAN GROUND,NOT RELIAGENT BASIS
PLEASE SAVE MUSLIM MAN AND WOMEN AND CHILD BECAUSE DISTROIED MOSQUE OR TEMPLE OR PAGODA CAN BUILD AGAIN AND AGAIN BUT ONE TIME HUMAN DIE NO ONE CAN GIVE LIFE . WHERE ARE MUSLIM WORLD SUCH AS PARKISTAN , INDONISIA ,MALAYSIA BURUNIE SAUDI ARIBIA ,UAE. IS THIS ISLARM. IGNORING HUMAN RIGHT. FEAR ALAH, WHEN HE CATCH NO ONE CAN SAVE TO ANY ONE.
english
burmaess solders is all so carminal
Shame on you(To Bermese people from Bangladesh)
Shame on you for talking like that!!! You are perfectly normal to look at them being killed daily? Help your Muslim brother & sisters... Why not take them in? Give them rights to jobs & education. How do you expect the Buddist to help if your own kind will not help you... Shame on all us Muslims!!! Shame on Syria for killing their own people, shame on Lebanon and all the others... Read the Kuran please!!!
To the Burmese people from Bangladesh
Rohingya people are called as Bengali? Bengali people speak in Bengali language, but Rohingya people speak in Different language. How come they are Bengali?
If they are living there for some generation, this is the standard of modern world to give cityzenship. Rohingya people are burmese, we (Bangladesh) will never allow them to get into our country.
Let Rohingya people survive and claim right by themselves. Dont relate them with us.
And, Burmaese people and their nation should be kept isolated more from this modern world they need more education.
Illegal Immigrants!!!
They don't even speak our national language - Burmese. How could they claim they are Burmese???? Obviously, they speak Bangali. They are bangali!!! These people illegally came into our country!
Just wondering
Just wondering how many of those terrorists in Rakhine(who call themselves the 'Rohningyas')can actually speak or write the 'Rohningya language', something that had popped so suddenly out of nowhere.
Dare not to allow comments on your wrong biased article
Why don't you dare to allow my comments on your article . If you have confidence to declare about your article , please allow the other's view on you also . Otherwise , you are not more than paid biased personnel of Human Right Watch .
Rohingya is not a Myanmar ethnic group
So-called Rohingya are just illelegal immigrants. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has already mentioned that statement in one of her lectures.
Thanking to David Scott Mathieson,
This latter to David Scott Mathieson, According to his speech,
I think all the minority ethic group will hope for good future. but I got a news today, Some of Rohinga people kidnap from their village, How did this no one have any idea. Their name as bellow, Dr. Nurul Haque, Dr. NAzim uddin, Professor Younus, MD. Fazal, Jahid hassan. What will do the human right in this issue? There is no one to help them only Human right.
we have a news, Now not only the rakahin but also the military do wrong with ruhinga.
Collective massacres against Muslims
Collective massacres against Muslims the Muslim living before this Buddhists in west Burma