Don't miss




From Foe to Friend? Iraq: The makeover of Muqtada al-Sadr

Read more


France's newest political parties go to school

Read more


Hugh Coltman serves up a New Orleans-inspired musical gumbo

Read more


'Macron sees high earners as key to getting the French economy moving again'

Read more


'Shut Up and Drive': Saudi's paradoxical stance after female activists arrested

Read more


$2.3bn for two million songs: Sony buys majority stake in EMI

Read more


Burundi approves new constitution allowing president to extend time in power

Read more


Populist takeover: Italy approves unprecedented coalition

Read more


Young Nicaraguans lead protests against President Ortega

Read more


Zuma announces inquiry into police mine shootings

Text by FRANCE 24

Latest update : 2012-08-18

South Africa’s President Jacob Zuma has announced an official investigation into the shooting deaths of 34 striking mine workers at the hands of police, who defended their actions, saying they opened fire in self-defense.

Faced with a populace clamouring for answers over the shooting deaths of 34 striking mine workers by the police, South African President Jacob Zuma announced an official investigation into the most brutal crowd control incident in South African history since the apartheid era.

Zuma cut short a visit to neighbouring Mozambique a day after police forces killed 34 striking workers and wounded 78 others during protests at a platinum mine in Marikana, in north-eastern South Africa.

Upon his return, the president went directly to the scene of the shooting, where a visibly distraught Zuma called the incident “tragic” and “shocking”.

"It is clear there is something serious behind these happenings and that's why I have taken a decision to establish the commission (of inquiry) because we must get to the truth," Zuma said.

South Africa’s police chief Riah Phiyega has claimed that her officers acted in self-defence against armed miners.

At a press conference Friday, Phiyega said police used tear gas, water cannons, stun grenades and rubber bullets, all of which failed to disperse the miners, many of them armed with machetes, guns or sticks.

Phiyega’s insistence, however, has failed to stem a torrent of criticism against her force in the wake of Thursday’s bloodshed.

The South African Institute of Race Relations (SAIRR) joined newspapers and commentators in recalling the infamous 1960 Sharpeville massacre, when police, then answerable to an apartheid government, opened fire on black protesters and killed 69 of them.

'Police force riddled with corruption and bribery allegations’

On Friday, SAIRR called for an “immediate suspension of all police officers involved in the shooting, pending charges of murder or culpable homicide”.

“What happened was completely unacceptable,” a statement from the institute read. “There is evidence of police officers continuing to shoot after a number of bodies can be seen dropping and others turning to run. The police were not properly equipped to control a crowd. Rifles are a no-no in such a situation.”

The build up to Thursday’s tragedy meant tensions were high among police ranks.

Even before the first bullet was fired Thursday, 10 people had already been killed in a conflict between rival trade unions. The labour dispute began on August 1 when workers staged a walk-out demanding better pay from Lonmin, the London-based company that runs the mine.

Among those victims were two police officers, hacked to death by striking miners, who had armed themselves with machetes, spears and firearms.

"The criticism of the police is coming from civil society and the African National Congress Youth League"

But even if provoked by the killing of their two colleagues, “no disciplined and properly trained policeman would shoot into a crowd,” SAIRR argued.

The institute’s research manager Lucy Holborn told FRANCE 24 the deaths at Marikana were due to the failed strategy of a poorly-trained, ill-disciplined police force that has been riddled with allegations of corruption and bribery.

“The ability of the police to maintain law and order is being brought into question,” said Holborn, who believes the force’s inability to bring perpetrators to justice meant they had failed to stamp out the violence that still plagues the country.

Others, equally outraged by Thursday’s events, went even further in their criticism. Helen Zille, leader of the opposition Democratic Alliance, called the shootings a “massacre”.

For Jeff Mphahlele, secretary general of the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, the Marikana killings were simply an act of retribution.

“The police had planned everything. It was planned right from the top. They killed innocent people,” he told Radio France Internationale (RFI).

'No ordinary crowd situation'

Not everyone in crime-ridden South Africa has lined up to place the blame for the miners deaths at the door of the police, who only fired live rounds after tear gas and rubber bullets had failed to disperse the crowd.

Reports that miners were sharpening their weapons and licking the blades of machetes whilst chanting war songs meant the police would have been acting under extreme pressure and provocation, said Johan Burger, a senior researcher at South Africa’s Institute for Security Studies.

“This was no ordinary crowd management situation,” Burger told FRANCE 24. “The police were dealing with a crowd, who were angry and heavily armed. Some even had the firearms from the policemen they had murdered just days before.

“You can imagine what was going through their minds after they had seen the mutilated bodies of colleagues who had been hacked to death. It would have had a huge psychological impact on them,” Burger said.

“When they came under attack, they had the right to defend themselves. It is totally different to Sharpeville, where most of the protesters were unarmed.”

Police left to deal with people’s anger

For Burger, Thursday’s events were predictable in a country where violent protests have become a regular occurrence in recent years.

According to the South African Police Service, there were 622 crowd management incidents in 2004/05 where the police used force to intervene. By 2011/12 that number had shot up by 75 percent, to 1,091 cases.

For many, these protests and the ensuing violence represent the growing resentment of people living in a country crippled by poverty and vast inequality, and where unemployment stands at 25 percent.

There has been widespread resentment and disillusionment at the failure of the ruling ANC party to bring about change 18 years after the end of apartheid. There is also anger at the levels of corruption described as ‘endemic’ by the country’s Public Protector, Thuli Madonsela.

When peoples’ frustration bubbles over into unrest and violence, it is the country’s police force that naturally ends up on the front line.

“The police always find themselves in a situation like Thursday’s, because they are the visible face of the government or in this case the mining authority,” Burger said. “The authorities left it to the police to sort things out, hoping the problem would just go away.”

South Africa’s successful hosting of the 2010 World Cup had convinced many that the country’s reputation for violence and murder was unjust. But the images of young men lying in pools of blood after a labour dispute had turned ugly proves South Africa still has a long way to go before it rids itself of the curse.


Date created : 2012-08-18


    S. African police claim 'self-defence' in mine shootings

    Read more


    South African police kill dozens of striking miners

    Read more


    Mining company fires 13,000 after strike

    Read more