Latest update: 11/09/2012 

- Belgium - France - tax evasion - taxes


France's wealthiest man sues newspaper for calling him 'rich idiot'

France's richest man, Bernard Arnault, is suing newspaper Libération for public insult after its front-page headline on Monday ordered him to "Get Lost you Rich Idiot". The leftwing daily was objecting to his decision to seek Belgian nationality.

By Oliver FARRY (video)
 

France’s richest man, billionaire Bernard Arnault, has come under fire from all quarters for his controversial decision to apply for Belgian nationality.

The decision by the 63-year-old head of the Louis Vuitton, Moët and Hennessy (LVMH) luxury goods empire to seek Belgian citizenship, has been seen by some as a first step to his future financial exile from France. It is an accusation Arnault has strongly denied.

'Parasite'

Nevertheless, his decision has provoked a furious reaction in the press and among politicians.

Libération’s front-page headline on Monday screamed “Get Lost, you Rich Idiot”, in homage to the infamous outburst by former president Nicolas Sarkozy, a friend of Arnault’s, who memorably told a farmer to “get lost, you poor idiot”.

“Even if he denies he will go into exile for financial motives, Bernard Arnault’s request for Belgian nationality appears to be the symbol of selfishness by the most wealthy,” Libération added on their front page.

Arnault's lawyer announced that he was suing Libération for public insult over the headline, calling it vulgar and violent.

Arnault has refused to accept the slur and immediately ordered his lawyers to open legal proceedings against the paper for 'public insult'.

"Bernard Arnault has no other choice, given the extreme vulgarity and brutality," a statement from the billionaire's lawyers read.

Jean-Luc Mélenchon, outspoken leader of the Left Front coalition of far-left political parties, was even more stinging in his attack on Arnault, saying "people like him were parasites”.

 

On the other end of the political spectrum, Mélenchon’s nemesis, the far-right National Front leader Marine le Pen, also waded into the row saying Arnault was guilty of “scandalous behaviour”.

Message to Hollande

Arnault’s move comes as President François Hollande announced a raft of tax hikes aimed at balancing the books. Hollande has insisted the current financial crisis puts an onus on the most wealthy to help drag the beleagured economy out of debt.

The president’s controversial 75 percent income tax rate for earnings over one million euros is due to be finalised later this month and will be included in the 2013 budget.

Hollande took the opportunity to remind Arnault of his duty during a televised interview on Sunday evening.

“Bernard Arnault should realise what it means to ask for another nationality… Being French is not just about receiving, it is about giving to your country,” the president said.

Arnauld insisted on Sunday that his application is not motivated by money, nor should it be seen as a political statement.

"I am and will remain a tax resident in France and in this regard I will, like all French people, fulfil my fiscal obligations," the world's fourth-richest man told AFP.

"Our country must count on everyone to do their bit to face a deep economic crisis amid strict budgetary contraints," he said.

However, he may have trouble convincing his doubters, especially given his history of walking out on France when the political landscape is not to his liking.

After the Socialist Party’s François Mitterrand triumphed in the presidential election of 1981, Arnault, whose fortune is estimated at 41 billion dollars, upped sticks and spent three years in the United States.

Heading for tax haven Monaco?

Despite Arnault's efforts to allay fears, France’s media has been full of speculation over the motives behind his decision to seek a Belgian passport.

Brussells-based tax lawyer Thierry Afschrift told French daily Le Parisien he was sceptical about Arnault’s motives.

“If the French government pursues an idea put forward by Nicolas Sarkozy to tax the revenues of French exiles around the world, then it would become an advantage to have dual nationality,” Afschrift said.

The financial landscape for billionaires appears much more amenable in Belgium with its lower tax rates, and unlike France, its neighbour does not have fortune tax. This may prove too tempting for Arnault, according to Afschrift.

Others tax experts have speculated whether the move is simply the first step towards him setting up in the tax haven of Monaco.

French citizens living in Monaco are bound by law to pay their taxes in France. But if Arnault simply renounces his French citizenship in favour of Belgian nationality, he will no longer be bound by such legislation.

France 24 with wires

Read more
React to the article
Comment this article typing your message in the above text zone. Please note that this is limited to 1500 characters or less.
(25) Reactions

Get A Job!

Socialist Scum. I hope Mr.Arnault, and the few remaining successful French citizens take their talents and tax dollars elsewhere, Belgium or otherwise (I would not advise him to come to America until Obama is out of office). French people are lazy, spoiled and don't deserve to parasitically suck off those who actually work for a living. France is going to be an even worse implosion than Greece after the unhinged Socialists are finished enacting their moronic policies that have proven to fail repeatedly throughout history. All Leftists are perpetual, bitter adolescents incapable of learning from history or striving to succeed on their own. They are prosperity destroyers. Their sloth, greed, envy and entitlement mindset is disgusting. With any luck, the U.S. will be unloading ours in November.

Franco - Belgian escape routes

With their track record of manipulating the rest of EU for their benefit, I'm surprised the French governing apparatchiks couldn't "head this one off at the pass". I guess its the old story of best allies arguing over a windfall. What odds against harmonised tax rates becoming a regular feature at EU summits fromnow on?

Franco - Belgian escape routes

With their track record of manipulating the rest of EU for their benefit, I'm surprised the French governing apparatchiks couldn't "head this one off at the pass". I guess its the old story of best allies arguing over a windfall. What odds against harmonised tax rates becoming a regular feature at EU summits fromnow on?

Don't slaughter a hen that lays golden eggs!

(a Russian proverb).
Russian communists once promised that there would be no rich and no poor. They fulfilled half of the promise - there were no rich people in the Sovyet Union. Unfortunately, 70 years in power wasn't enough to make good on the second half.

We stopped investing in France because of taxes

We, I guess, are not the only wealthy foreigners who have decided not to move to France despite buying a house there. It makes no sense to make a business investment when I am facing all the risk but government is collecting most of the fruits.

Instead of attacking personal

Instead of attacking personal tax directly, branding it as crisis tax - something that will be remove once the economy is doing well- will be easier for them to swallow.

After a years of paying

After a years of paying €billions in French Taxes, far more in one year than most French will pay in a lifetime, you want to accuse him of not paying his fair share?

Fair share or a giant dose of envy from a society that prefers forced equality. Congratulations on the road to economic suicide, an amazing display of the arrogance of ignorance, the French seem doomed to become China's slaves, then you can truly be equal.

Logical not emotional

Bernard Arnault is packing a fiscal parachute. If he decides to leap out of the French plane, with a Belgian passport, he will have all the necessary elements to properly leave the French tax system.If France decides to tax based on citizenship (like the US) then he has another passport in place so he will not be stateless. He can also give up his French passport, so that he will only have a Belgian one and thereby properly have left the French tax regime under the France-Belgian tax treaty. With the French tax system in a high likelihood of hitting him hard, this is just smart self-protection. As for French politicians, as Samuel Johnson famously said, "Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel". As for those people who say "good riddance", I would point out to you that a progressive tax system like that of France, the US and the UK has the natural result that the top 1% of tax payers contribute over 30% of the personal tax revenue collected. Therefore, losing a super-contributor like Mr. Arnault would have a huge negative asymmetric impact on tax revenues. Before you call him names (which is not going to inspire him to stay), you may want to think about how you are going to replace the 10s of millions in annual tax revenue he provides.

The rich don't need the 99% anymore

Bernard Arnault isn't unique. The 1% don't need the rest of us anymore. The declare citizenship where they pay the least in taxes. They invest all ove the world and make their money moving money around. They don't need the rest of us as either workers or consumers nearly as much as they used to, if they need us at all anymore. We're just the household servants and security guards now. What's bizarre is that after pulling stunts like this, they expect to be loved, like enriching themselves was somehow a favor to the rest of us. Yes, get lost, renounce your citizenship and live wherever, but no, you don't get to take your money tax free. It's time for the rich to start paying their share. Don't give me that "we pay most of the taxes" nonsense when you take most of the money.

wealth redistribution

This article begs the question; if you are a very successful individual, do you really want to be French?

Close