- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 31/10/2012
- France - Google - Internet
France 'hits Google with €1 billion claim' in content row
French tax authorities have filed a €1 billion claim against Google to pressure the search engine to pay a portion of its advertising revenue for access to French media websites, a Paris-based newspaper reported on Wednesday.
By News Wires (text)
French tax authorities have made a billion-euro ($1.3 billion) claim against Google to pressure it in a dispute over compensation to media websites, a French newspaper reported, a claim denied by the US Internet giant's local arm.
The weekly Canard Enchaine said in its edition to hit news-stands on Wednesday that the tax claim concerns the transfer prices set between Google's Irish holding company and the French unit for four tax years, without disclosing its sources.
French tax authorities told AFP they do not comment on specific cases due to taxpayer privacy. Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
A Google France spokesman told AFP that the company had received no such notification.
"We continue to cooperate with the French authorities as we have done till now," the spokesman said in an email, stressing that "Google conforms with the fiscal laws of all the countries in which we operate, and with European rules."
The weekly said the tax claim was brought up during Monday's meeting between President Francois Hollande and Google chief Eric Schmidt, and that it was a bargaining chip in the dispute with French media.
Hollande said the French government would adopt a law if necessary to settle a dispute with French media websites, which want the search engine to hand over a percentage of the advertising revenue it earns from directing users to their content.
"If the negotiations between Google and the media publishers don't result in a deal by the end of the year, Google already knows what awaits it from a tax point of view: one billion," said the weekly.
"Otherwise, there will no doubt be room to negotiate."
In March, a source told AFP that French authorities had made a tax claim against Google.
The weekly L'Express reported the tax authorities were looking into whether Google had correctly paid company and sales tax between 2008 and 2010.
Google uses a number of measures to reduce the amount of tax it pays in France by funnelling most revenue through a Bermuda-registered holding and then reporting it in Ireland.
According to estimates Google generated between 1.25 billion and 1.4 billion euros in revenue in France last year, primarily due to Internet advertising. It paid only a little more than 5 million euros in tax, primarily due to the corporate tax.
(AFP)
Read more
Business news, technology, media and finance reports




























React to the article
(11) Reactions
This is just ridiculous, I
This is just ridiculous, I can’t wait till google quits indexing the sites to these dinosaur media. They should be happy that google brings people to their site... who would read them otherwise? The level of entitlement here, phh...Yeah this is just scary stupid.
This is just stupid... I
This is just stupid... I laugh when google quits indexing you dinosaur media. You all should be happy that google is bringing people to your site. phh... seriously the level of entitlement is just scary stupid.
Watch Google leave France
Watch Google leave France entirely after this, and then good luck to France trying to collect the judgement.
Sacre Bleu!
Sacre Bleu!
To the French, Blow it out
To the French,
Blow it out your Search Engine.
Frogs, Give it up, You are Greece, you just don't know it!
cut them off google. let
cut them off google. let france figure out its own way to drive users to their stupid websites for content that no one wants
So, they stop sending people
So, they stop sending people to French media sites. How does that help anyone? Why would I want to punish someone who is sending me business for free? No one is ever going to accuse Hollande of being particularly bright but this is dumb even for a socialist.
Hollande seems to think the road to prosperity lays in chasing as many people and businesses out of France as possible. Good luck with that.
It's obvious the new
It's obvious the new socialist government in France is looking to any source of revenue possible to shake down. Google won't give in to their demands to share the revenue from advertising so this tactic is taken. My bet is that Google will shut off France from any search capabilities of any websites in that country.
Gosh socialism is great isn't it?
From the article: "French
From the article: "French media websites, ... want the search engine to hand over a percentage of the advertising revenue it earns from directing users to their content." Translation: You make money driving business to our websites, so give us some of that money. Google owes you nothing. Once you publish to the internet, it's public domain. Don't like it? Create an alternative service. Nothing forces you to publish to the internet, only economic incentives motivate you to do so. Don't like being motivated by economic incentives? Lay down and die; there is no other way to live on earth.
From the article: "French
From the article: "French media websites, which want the search engine to hand over a percentage of the advertising revenue it earns from directing users to their content." Translation: You bring business to our sites, so you owe us money. Why should they pay you for driving your businesses? If you don't like the job that they're doing directing business to your sites, come up with an alternative. If you don't like the fact that the internet is searchable... take your business off the internet, but do not try to tell everyone else the terms you'll accept for the privelage of seeing your already posted content.