Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

AFRICA NEWS

Rwandan singer amongst terror plot suspects

Read more

DEBATE

What's Putin's Plan? Kiev Accuses Russia of Terrorism

Read more

FOCUS

Campaigning against Bouteflika's re-election... in France

Read more

WEB NEWS

Chile: Online mobilization to help Valparaiso fire victims

Read more

ENCORE!

Art, sex, money, memory and manga

Read more

MIDDLE EAST MATTERS

Spat over Iran's UN ambassador hampers thawing relations with US

Read more

FOCUS

China trade deal: Is Taiwan's identity under threat?

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

'Call it a caretaker government'

Read more

DEBATE

Nigeria's Battles

Read more

  • Frantic search for South Korea ferry passengers continues

    Read more

  • Kiev powerless as pro-Russia activists seize armoured vehicles

    Read more

  • Real Madrid beat old foes Barcelona to lift Copa del Rey

    Read more

  • Algeria heads to the polls: ‘this election has nothing to do with us’

    Read more

  • Belgian head of wildlife reserve shot in eastern Congo

    Read more

  • US rolls out red carpet for French critic of capitalism

    Read more

  • France's new PM targets welfare in drive to cut spending

    Read more

  • N. Korea not amused by London hair salon's Kim Jong-un ad

    Read more

  • Campaigning against Bouteflika's re-election... in France

    Read more

  • Brazil club Mineiro cancel Anelka signing after no-show

    Read more

  • Syria 'torture' photos silence UN Security Council members

    Read more

  • Paris laboratory loses deadly SARS virus samples

    Read more

  • More than 100 schoolgirls kidnapped in northeast Nigeria

    Read more

  • New York police disband unit targeting Muslims

    Read more

  • 'Miracle girl' healthy after seven-organ transplant in Paris

    Read more

  • Paris police memo calling for Roma eviction ‘rectified’

    Read more

  • Burgundy digs into France's bureaucratic 'mille-feuille'

    Read more

  • French court drops ‘hate speech’ case against Bob Dylan

    Read more

  • Algeria rights crackdown slammed ahead of election

    Read more

  • Iraq closes notorious Abu Ghraib jail over security fears

    Read more

  • In ‘Tom at the Farm’, Xavier Dolan blends Hitchcock and homoeroticism

    Read more

France

McDonald’s hits back at French MP’s damning report

© AFP

Text by Joseph BAMAT , Perrine MOUTERDE

Latest update : 2012-11-01

A lawmaker from France’s ruling Socialist Party has accused McDonald’s of ignoring a tax-reducing pact and pocketing millions. But the hamburger giant has rebuked the MP, saying it is being unfairly singled out.

In 1999, French sheep farmer and activist José Bové won national and international attention for taking the fight to US-based hamburger giant McDonald’s. That year, Bové and his farmer’s union comrades dismantled a McDonald's under construction in the small town of Millau, in southern France, to protest US-imposed tariffs on Roquefort cheese.

That action made Bové a hero of the worldwide anti-globalisation movement that views international corporations like McDonald’s as the enemy of small, locally-owned and run businesses.

But more than a decade later, McDonald’s has a new nemesis in France, even if the escalating row is far less ideological in scope.

Socialist Party MP Thomas Thévenoud is the author of a report that criticizes the measure that lowered restaurant VAT in France and points a damning finger at fast-food giant McDonald's.

Thomas Thévenoud, an MP with the ruling Socialist Party, has blasted McDonald's for allegedly ignoring a pact between restaurants and the French government, and pocketing millions of euros in additional profits since 2009.

Three years ago, the conservative government of ex-president Nicolas Sarkozy struck an agreement with restaurant owners that lowered their value added tax (VAT) from 19.6% to 5.5 % and was meant to boost their business.

In exchange, the eateries – which include high-end restaurants to small bistros to fast-food joints – pledged to lower the price of some items on their menus and invest a significant part of new profits in hiring additional cooks and wait staff.

Nevertheless, Sarkozy reset the restaurant VAT at 7% in January 2012, five months before President François Hollande thwarted his re-election bid in May.

Thévenoud has now penned a damning report to France’s National Assembly on the tax-lowering measure – one that claims restaurants largely failed to hounour their part of the bargain, recommends the agreement be scrapped completely and points a supersized finger at McDonald’s France.

McDonald’s bites back

The Socialist lawmaker, who says he based his report on figures provided to him by McDonald’s, says the fast-food company counted an additional 190 million euros in profits because of the tax cut. He faults the company for re-investing only 136 million of that total in the form of higher workers’ salaries and improvements to work conditions.

An offended McDonald's took out full-page advertisements in the October 30 issue of the country’s most circulated newspapers, including Le Monde daily. It wrote that it has completely respected the VAT pact and that Thévenoud’s numbers don’t add up.

The only number the two agreed on is 190 million in extra profits over the past three years. McDonald’s then subtracts 171 million euros, not 136 million, for its efforts to boost salaries, hire new workers, keep or lower the cost of some food items, and invest in improved and environmentally friendly kitchens.

It boasts having added 3,000 employees to its workforce per year since 2009, and lowered by 5% the price of the Big Mac menu, its flagship product.

The hamburger giant then subtracts another 52 million euros it claims to have lost with the recent VAT rise from 5.5% to 7%. McDonald’s says the bottom line is red, and that its re-investment and slightly higher tax since January actually puts it back by 33 million euros.

A fair critique?

Reacting to McDonald’s full-page rebuttals, Le Monde journalist Samuel Laurent said that it was “hard to believe” the company’s claim that it had lost more than 50 million euros because of the recent tax hike of 2.2%.

In an article that shows little empathy for McDonald’s arguments, Laurent also says it is wrong for the company to take credit for adding 3,000 jobs per year since the VAT was lowered. Pointing to a company report from 2009 – published before the tax cut went into effect and available on McDonald’s own website – he said the company expected to add 3,000 jobs per year anyway, based on normal growth forecasts.

According to economist Henri Sterdyniak, a researcher at the state-funded French Economic Observatory (OFCE), McDonald’s was intentionally misleading people with its figures.

“Unquestionably,McDonald's has earned more with the VAT reduction and lost money with the VAT rise. The problem is that the company is counting all its investments as expenses. At any given time, a company makes investments, hires staff, buys new equipment,” Sterdyniak said.

“There is absolutely no way to distinguish what investments would have been made anyway and which are a result of the three-year VAT reduction,” he added. “Restaurants as a whole made over 5 billion in profits because of the VAT reduction, so McDonald’s claims it has lost money are completely stupid.”

However, the economist agreed that the American fast-food restaurant was being unfairly picked on by the lawmaker Thévenoud.

“All the restaurants benefited from the measure,” Sterdyniak said. “It seems more shocking to me when it concerns luxury hotels and restaurants than McDonald’s.”

Thévenoud also seemed unimpressed with McDonald’s counter-attack. “I would like to find out how much it cost them to take out those full-page adds,” he told the Sipa news agency.

Date created : 2012-11-01

  • BUSINESS

    France’s blighted north lures thousands of Chinese firms

    Read more

  • FRANCE

    French children to learn gay issues at primary school

    Read more

  • INTERNET

    France 'hits Google with €1 billion claim' in content row

    Read more

Comments

COMMENT(S)