- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Breaking News
Latest update: 08/11/2012
- adoption - France - Gay marriage - homosexuality
French government backs draft gay marriage law
French President François Hollande's cabinet on Wednesday approved a proposed law authorising gay marriage and adoption for same-sex couples on Wednesday.
By News Wires (text)
France's Socialist government Wednesday approved a draft law to authorise gay marriage and adoption despite fierce opposition from the Roman Catholic Church and the right-wing opposition.
President Francois Hollande, who made the issue a key part of his electoral platform, told a cabinet meeting the move was "not only a step forward for some but for all of society," government spokeswoman Najat Vallaud-Belkacem said.
The proposed legislation "resolutely takes into account the greater interest of the child," he said, Vallaud-Belkacem added.
"This is an important step towards the equality of rights," said Minister of Family Affairs Dominique Bertinnoti.
Bertinnoti rejected criticism that the move would "destroy" the family, saying: "On the contrary it is a legal protection."
It now has to be voted through parliament before becoming law: Hollande has promised that it will be on the statute books by mid-2013.
Some in the government also want the final law to include state funding for artificial insemination for gay couples.
"This is a great advance and very important for the legal protection of gay families," said Stephanie, a 41-year-old member of an association of gay and lesbian parents.
The draft law, a liberal cornerstone of the election manifesto that brought Hollande to power in May has come under fire in a country that is officially secular but predominantly Catholic.
Muslim, Protestant and Jewish organisations have also expressed opposition to the project.
Paris Cardinal Andre Vingt-Trois, who has led opposition to the project, told a mass in the southern pilgrimage town of Lourdes last weekend that children needed both a father and a mother to build their identities.
"When we defend the right of children to build their personality with reference to the man and the woman who gave them life, we are not defending a particular position," he said.
A number of European nations allow gay marriage and adoption, but in France only married couples and not civil union partners can adopt.
Belgium, Britain, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Iceland, The Netherlands, Norway, Spain and Sweden currently allow gay adoption.
Polls suggest that up to two-thirds of French voters back homosexuals' right to marry, but there is less support on allowing them to adopt.
Marine Le Pen, leader of the far-right National Front, has called for a popular vote on gay marriage and adoption.
Jean-Francois Cope, one of two candidates to succeed former president Nicolas Sarkozy as the head of the conservative UMP party, has urged the government to postpone the draft bill saying it was "incredibly badly prepared.
"It is not just about homosexual marriage, it is about a complete reorganisation, deconstruction of the right of the family, with questions surrounding lineage, the removal of the reference to father and mother in the text," Cope said.
Some conservative and far-right politicians have also called for mass protests to try and force the government to back down. Hundreds of French mayors or deputy mayors have signed a petition opposing the government's plans.
Pope Benedict XVI last month urged French bishops to oppose the bill and defend marriage as the "foundation of social life".
The draft legislation will include a provision for married gay couples to adopt children but the right will not be immediately extended to unmarried homosexuals, Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault said last month.
That question and the issue of gay couples' access to medically assisted conception will be addressed in secondary legislation at a later date.
(AFP)




























React to the article
(9) Reactions
I am often amused that
I am often amused that Mundanes aka straight people are up in arms about gays marrying and or adopting, yet they are not in the least threatened by interracial marriage and children.
test msg
test msg
The church basiccally triess
The church basiccally triess to take a high moral ground -
But which morality?
The vatican morality is best described by the following first two links and the act of its leader = a couple horrendous examples
http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/erbe/2009/02/05/pope-should-excommunicate-holocaust-denying-bishop-williamson?msg=1 - comments
http://www.irishcentral.com/news/Pope-Benedict-accused-of-masterminding-Catholic-Church-sex-abuse-cover-up-91038229.html#ixzz1lf7M...
First of all, scientifically
First of all, scientifically there is no difference in the health of families wherein the parents are of the same-sex. Their children do just as well (or just as poorly) as the children of heterosexuals in marriage. Secondly, there is a fierce debate as to whether the Talmud or the Christian Scriptures even condemn homosexuality.
I, for one, pertain to the belief that the Christian Scripture were twisted in 390 by anti-Arian theologians in an effort to exert their authority against "eunuchs".
The family-unit is only endangered by those who would seek to render ultimate harm to children and their parents. Namely, by the religious-right.
First of all, scientifically
First of all, scientifically there is no difference in the health of families wherein the parents are of the same-sex. Their children do just as well (or just as poorly) as the children of heterosexuals in marriage. Secondly, there is a fierce debate as to whether the Talmud or the Christian Scriptures even condemn homosexuality.
I, for one, pertain to the belief that the Christian Scripture were twisted in 390 by anti-Arian theologians in an effort to exert their authority against "eunuchs".
The family-unit is only endangered by those who would seek to render ultimate harm to children and their parents. Namely, by the religious-right.
First of all, scientifically
First of all, scientifically there is no difference in the health of families wherein the parents are of the same-sex. Their children do just as well (or just as poorly) as the children of heterosexuals in marriage. Secondly, there is a fierce debate as to whether the Talmud or the Christian Scriptures even condemn homosexuality.
I, for one, pertain to the belief that the Christian Scripture were twisted in 390 by anti-Arian theologians in an effort to exert their authority against "eunuchs".
The family-unit is only endangered by those who would seek to render ultimate harm to children and their parents. Namely, by the religious-right.
just watched ur discussion
just watched ur discussion regarding this topic(am straight male,catholic,considered "socially conservative").grew up in "home" with mother/father that was more a war zone than loving environment.SO horrible,i left to live with my aunt as teen.i believe a child has right and NEEDS TO grow up in protected/loving environment.this is FAR more important than whether ur parents are hetero OR gay/lesbian.I would be interested in knowing if there are studies on % children of gay couples,who THEMSELVES are gay vs % children of hetero couples).if # is low/minimal,it wud undermine ur conservative guest's arguments.if # IS bit higher, WHO THE HELL cares???if child is taught to love/care @ other human beings--THAT is the type of person I want to be my friend...GAY OR NOT! thanks,george
i just watched your
i just watched your discussion on tv regarding this topic (i am a straight male...as well catholic and tend to be considered "socially conservative").
i grew up in a "home" with a "mother and father" that was more like a war zone than a loving environment. SO horrible, that i left to live with my aunt in my early teens
i believe a child has a right to and NEEDS TO grow up in a protected and loving environment, and that this is FAR more important than whether your parents are hetero OR gay/lesbian.
I would be interested in knowing if there are any studies on percentage of children of gay couples, who grow up and are THEMSELVES gay (same about % children (adopted OR natural)to hetero couples). if the number is low/minimal, it would undermine your conservative guest's arguments.
if this number DOES tend to be a bit higher, WHO THE HELL cares??? if he is taught to love and care about other human beings...THAT is the type of person I want to be my friend...GAY OR NOT!
thanks,
george
What would happen if the
What would happen if the church stopped performing marriages? What would happen if they said to parishioners not to adopt? Would the government care? Would People be upset?. The church if it's upset needs to decide fight or flee....how many people would be upset with the government if the church said that is no longer performing weddings until the law changes......would the church fight or again turn the other cheek. Are the people of the nations becoming Moral or immoral......if the church is to teach it must first lead...they should state that they will no longer perform marriages until the law changes.....will there be fireworks or a damp squid.....the church should take the moral high ground....fight back....but if you don't you may lose your parishioners.