Voting has ended in Italy's general election, with wildly conflicting projections pointing to a far closer race than initially thought, after a lacklustre campaign overshadowed by a spate of corruption scandals involving all the major parties.
Italy's general election descended into chaos on Monday amid conflicting reports pointing first to a victory for the centre-left alliance of Pier Luigi Bersani and then for Silvio Berlusconi's centre-right bloc.
As voting ended at 3pm on Monday, exit polls for the key Senate race gave the centre-left coalition led by Pier Luigi Bersani between 36% and 38% of the vote, followed by Silvio Berlusconi's centre-right bloc (30%-32%) and the anti-establishment movement of firebrand comedian Beppe Grillo (17%-19%).
But less than an hour later, early results pointed to yet another spectacular comeback by the “Cavaliere”.
FRANCE 24 REPORTS
Projections based on around half of all votes cast for the Senate put Berlusconi's coalition in the lead with 31%, followed by the centre-left on 30%. Beppe Grillo's 5-Star Movement was credited with 24% of votes cast, making it the single largest party in the Senate.
All projections gave the centrist coalition of Mario Monti lagging well behind (8%), suggesting the outgoing prime minister's bloc may not meet a 10% threshold to enter parliament.
If confirmed, the results are likely to lead to fresh elections in the coming months, with no one in a position to form a majority in both houses of parliament.
“There is no other option but to vote again,” said Enrico Letta, vice-president of Bersani's Democratic Party (PD).
In Pictures: Italians vote in the snow
Voters cast their ballots Sunday morning at the primary school in Mercallo, a small village in the key region of Lombardy. © Terry Bland
“The people are well organised here: the snow had been cleared from the roads by 8am!,” said Monica Merlo, 54, who works as a secretary for a local company. © Terry Bland
Lisa Ferrari, Mercallo's 30-year-old florist, said she was considering abstaining. “But,” she added, “my mum convinced me to go and vote because the situation is too risky.” © Terry Bland
“No one votes for Berlusconi any more,” said Gabriele Agostini, 55. “If he wins, I'm going to live in Switzerland or France.” © Terry Bland
Agostini said he cast a “protest vote” for comedian Beppe Grillo's party in the lower house of parliament, where he expects Pier Luigi Bersani's centre-left coalition to win. “But I voted for Bersani in the senate race because we need a stable majority.” © Terry Bland
Final results for the Senate are expected later in the afternoon. Election officials will then begin counting votes cast for the lower house of parliament.
A complex electoral system, dubbed “porcellum” (or pigsty), means all eyes will be on a handful of hotly contested Senate races, including in Lombardy, Sicily and the Campania region around Naples.
The inconclusive poll follows a lacklustre campaign overshadowed by a spate of corruption scandals involving all the major parties.
The reports fuelled anger among voters burdened by unpopular austerity measures and surging unemployment.
Even by the self-deprecating standards of Italy, the frustration and despair sensed at polling stations appeared to have reached unprecedented levels.
Italy's complex 'pigsty' electoral law
Italy's current electoral law is so complex and cumbersome it has been dubbed "porcellum", or pigsty, by the person who wrote it. The Chamber of Deputies, the lower house, has 630 seats, while the Senate has 315 (plus four senators appointed for life). All elected seats are up for grabs on February 24-5. Seats in both chambers are allocated on a proportional basis, with a variety of thresholds designed to encourage parties to form coalitions. Whichever coalition comes first in the national vote is awarded a "majority prize" in the Chamber of Deputies, guaranteeing it has at least 340 of the 630 seats. "Majority prizes" also apply in the Senate, but on a regional basis, making it more difficult for any one coalition to secure a majority of seats in both chambers.
“We are in economic, cultural and moral decline, so it is no surprise our politics go the same way,” said one voter outside Florence's Liceo Machiavelli.
At the next polling station, Sabina Borgone, 41, said politicians had learned nothing during the year-long technocratic government of Mario Monti. “This is a good country for a holiday by the sea,” she said, “but nothing more.”
While there was a general sense among voters that the country was knee deep in trouble, few thought any of the candidates had a solution to Italy's problems.
The widespread loss of faith in politics has boosted Beppe Grillo's anti-establishment movement.
The popular comedian has campaigned throughout the country in a camper van, drawing huge crowds at rallies from Palermo to Trieste. He has urged Italian voters to send all politicians “a casa” (home).
Grillo kept people waiting until midday on Monday before casting his vote in his hometown of Genova. Wearing large sunglasses, he joked that he “couldn't make [his] mind up” about who to vote.
The prospect of more political instability in the eurozone's third-largest economy has caused alarm abroad, where many fear an anti-austerity verdict from voters could spook the markets and revive Europe's debt crisis.
“If no one has a clear majority then we'll be heading back to the polls in six months,” said a UN official who had flown back to Rome for the vote, but declined to be named. “In the meantime, what are we going to tell our European partners? What will Grillo tell them?”
Italy's general elections
- 'Toto' Riina, feared godfather from Corleone, dies behind bars at 87
- Italy's World Cup 'Apocalypse'
- Video: Is Italy seeing a resurgence of fascism?
- Italy fail to reach World Cup after being held to 0-0 draw by Sweden
- French winegrowers face poorest harvest since 1945
- Italy's Veneto and Lombardy overwhelmingly back greater autonomy in referendums
While no single coalition is likely to secure a majority of seats in the Senate, the winner of the popular vote for the lower house of parliament is guaranteed at least 340 of the 630 seats up for grabs.
Claudio Battilocchi, 52, a member of the centre-left Democratic Party (PD) in Rome, said too little had been done to renew the country's political parties at a time of widespread voter disaffection.
These Grillo voters in Rome, who did not wish to be named, said Italian politics needed something radically new.
Voting at the polling station of Italian President Giorgio Napolitano on Rome's via Panisperna.
All eyes are on the Viminale, Italy's Interior Ministry, as polling institutes offer wildly differing projections.
Antonella Chini, 79, says candidate and comedian Beppe Grillo embodies a form of defeatism that is typical of many Italians.
A voter casts her ballot at Florence's Liceo Galileo, a high school in Florence.
Italy's complex electoral law, known as the "porcellum" (or pigsty), makes it very difficult for any one coalition to secure a majority of seats in both houses of parliament.
A polling station is ready to welcome voters in Florence's Liceo Machiavelli. But where are they?
Voters are required to leave mobile phones at the desk to ensure they don't take pictures of their ballots; this measure was introduced in an effort to fight "voto di scambio", or vote exchanging, whereby candidates buy people's votes.
Date created : 2013-02-25