Open

Coming up

Don't miss

Replay


LATEST SHOWS

FOCUS

Video: Milan is starting point for Syrian refugees’ European odyssey

Read more

MIDDLE EAST MATTERS

Terrorist ransoms: Should governments pay up for hostages?

Read more

ENCORE!

Kristen Stewart and Juliette Binoche star in 'Clouds of Sils Maria'

Read more

WEB NEWS

India: journalist launches "Rice Bucket Challenge"

Read more

WEB NEWS

Russian aid convoy: Mission accomplished?

Read more

WEB NEWS

Actor Orlando Jones lauches 'Bullet Bucket Challenge'

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

'Macron Economics'

Read more

BUSINESS DAILY

Macron-economics, the former banker turned minister

Read more

IN THE PAPERS

'The capital of sex, drugs, alcohol, trash and trashy tourism'

Read more

  • French unemployment rises 0.8% in July to record high

    Read more

  • UN probe accuses Syrian regime, Islamists of ‘crimes against humanity’

    Read more

  • France’s Hollande puts young ex-banker in top economy post

    Read more

  • Video: Iraq’s Yazidis flee to spiritual capital of Lalish

    Read more

  • Video: Milan is starting point for Syrian refugees’ European odyssey

    Read more

  • Airstrikes and Assad - Obama’s military conundrum in Syria

    Read more

  • IMF’s Lagarde investigated in French corruption case

    Read more

  • American journalist held captive in Syria arrives in US

    Read more

  • In pictures: The ministers in France's new government

    Read more

  • 'Lasting' ceasefire agreed for Gaza, Abbas says

    Read more

  • Far-right ‘Russian Jihad’ fighters cross into Ukraine

    Read more

  • American 'Islamic State fighter' killed in Syria

    Read more

  • Rebels 'shoot down' UN helicopter in South Sudan

    Read more

  • Air France pilots threaten September strike

    Read more

  • WHO seeks stricter regulation for e-cigarettes

    Read more

Europe

World War I death count 'too low by one million'

© AFP / French soldiers at the Battle of Verdun in 1916

Text by Stéphanie TROUILLARD

Latest update : 2014-01-22

The number of soldiers killed in World War I has been vastly underestimated, says French historian Antoine Prost. He tells FRANCE 24 how some nations failed to count all their dead and how governments differed over the burial of lost soldiers.

For years, historians of the Great War have settled for the figure of nine million soldiers killed during the bloody conflict that ushered in the so-called "Age of Extremes".

But that consensus has been challenged by an article published this week in the final volume of the "Complete Cambridge History of the First World War", part of a flurry of new studies to mark one hundred years since the war’s outbreak.

Its author, French historian Antoine Prost, says the number of soldiers killed is closer to ten million.

"Official statistics fail to take into account the soldiers who died as a result of illness or while being detained in prisoner-of-war camps,” Prost told FRANCE 24. “The armies often rushed to give their figures, seeking to play down their losses.”

Statistical omissions

Prost is Professor Emeritus at Pantheon-Sorbonne University in Paris. For his article, entitled “The Dead”, he combed through a century of statistics published by the warring nations.

In the case of France, Prost noticed that the military had only counted those who died while serving in the army, thereby excluding veterans who had returned to civilian life after the war.

“Current records claim around 1,325,000 died at the front or as a result of their injuries, but this does not include those – around 70,000 – who died of war-related illnesses upon returning home,” says Prost.

The French historian says the gap is even larger in Russia: “Soviet statistics omit the prisoners of war who died in German camps. We’re talking about some 200,000 people.”

Russian prisoners of war captured after the Battle of Tannenberg in 1914. © Photos of the Great War

As for Germany, its military leaders stopped counting casualties in late July 1918, more than four months before the armistice that brought an end to the war. “Figures for August, September, October and the start of November were added subsequently, but in a haphazard way,” says Prost.

Bucking the trend, one country actually magnified its losses. “US losses are generally estimated at between 110,000 and 120,000, but I discovered that 35,000 of them had died of the Spanish influenza before even crossing the Atlantic to join the war,” he says. "The Americans were keen to maximise their losses in order to establish themselves as a major military power.”

‘Some corner of a foreign field’

“The Dead” also examines the different armies’ burial practices, highlighting striking differences between the British army’s approach and that of its French ally.

In 1917, the Imperial War Graves Commission, today known as the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, was tasked with building military cemeteries along the frontline – an institutional version of what the English wartime poet Rupert Brooke had described as “some corner of a foreign field that is forever England”.

“All those who fell for the British Empire, whether English, Scottish, Canadian or Australian, are buried on the Continent,” says Prost. “Had the British allowed bodies to be repatriated, only the richest families would have been able to – so they opted for a more democratic principle.”

Members of the Women's Army Auxiliary Corps (WAAC) prepare the tombs of British soldiers at Abbeville, near the Somme, in February 1918. © Imperial War Museums.

France proved less organised. By the time the government set up a national commission to deal with the issue, in November 1918, many families had already travelled to the front to look for their lost ones.

“This was illegal, but if the families had enough money they could bribe undertakers to take the bodies back home,” says Prost.

The government eventually bowed to pressure from the public. More than 240,000 bodies were identified and sent back home, while the rest were buried in military cemeteries.

But, to this day, the French “corner of a [French] field” is a poor match for the 832 British military cemeteries and their 1,000 dedicated gardeners.

“The United Kingdom showed greater respect for its fallen soldiers, in part because the British army was initially a professional one,” says Prost. “Until 1916, the [British] soldiers who fought and died in northern France were volunteers – and, as such, were treated with higher regard than their French counterparts, who had little choice but to fight.”

Notre-Dame-de-Lorette military cemetery near Ablain-Saint-Nazaire, in northern France, where French President François Hollande is due to inaugurate an international memorial with the names of 600,000 soldiers of all nations who died during the Great War. © AFP


 

Date created : 2014-01-22

  • AUSTRALIA

    Remembering Aborigines who fought for Australia in WWI

    Read more

  • FRANCE

    France 'still feeling' the legacy of WWI 100 years on

    Read more

  • FRANCE

    Hollande honours African role in France's WWI fight

    Read more

COMMENT(S)