Don't miss




How corruption has damaged Armenia's environment

Read more


'Changing FARC peace deal would be a huge historical error for Colombia'

Read more


EU ombudsman: 'Just raising an issue can be sufficient to change things'

Read more


Trouble in the eurozone: New Italian government puts pressure on establishment

Read more


Celebrations after Mexico's win against Germany prompts 'fan-made' earthquake

Read more


France's Basque country, where singing is sacred

Read more


Charitable donations: 'By 2024, we believe giving will be the norm'

Read more


Ex-Carrefour boss urged to give up €13 million retirement package

Read more


Egypt, Morocco lose first World Cup matches after conceding last-minute goals

Read more

Middle east

Syria 'torture' photos silence UN Security Council members

© Photo: AFP

Text by FRANCE 24

Latest update : 2014-04-16

Members of the United Nations Security Council have viewed gruesome pictures of prisoners allegedly tortured by Syrian government forces.

The images, reportedly taken by a former Syrian military police photographer, appear to show evidence of abuse, including beatings, strangulation, electrocution and starvation.

The informal council meeting was organised by France to give the 15 member states a chance to see some of the 55,000 photographs.

"The council fell into silence after we displayed the images," Araud said. "Members were truly moved."

US Ambassador to the UN Samantha Power expressed a sense of horror after attending the informal council meeting.

Graphic and ghastly photographs

"The gruesome images of corpses indicate that the Assad regime has carried out systematic, widespread and industrial killing," she said, referring to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.

"The perpetrators of these monstrous crimes must be held accountable, and the international community must unite in the face of such horrors," she said.

Assad's ally Russia sent a representative to the meeting, though one council diplomat present said he was a legal counselor and not Ambassador Vitaly Churkin. Most missions sent ambassadors to the meeting, the diplomat said.

Syracuse University law professor David Crane, who was chief prosecutor at the Sierra Leone war crimes tribunal that indicted former President Charles Taylor of Liberia, compared the treatment of the victims to what was done to inmates of Nazi concentration camps such as Auschwitz.

Military photographer codenamed "Caesar"

Stuart Hamilton, a forensic pathologist, said the former Syrian military photographer, identified by the code name "Caesar," smuggled the photos out of Syria between 2011 and mid-2013. Some 5,500 photos of 1,300 people were examined by the team of investigators.

"I'm content that they have not been digitally altered," Hamilton said. He displayed photos of corpses with distinctive patterned bruises on their necks that he eventually identified to have come from strangulation with an auto timing belt.

The images Caesar took were passed to the Syrian National Movement, which is supported by the Gulf state of Qatar. Lawyers acting for Qatar from the London-based Carter-Ruck commissioned the examination of the evidence.

Qatar, like Saudi Arabia, is strongly opposed to Assad and is supporting rebel groups in the conflict.

War crimes on "a scale not seen since Rwanda"

While Caesar's photos would appear to offer evidence of war crimes by the Syrian government, Araud and Crane said that crimes had also been committed by opposition forces, though their actions were not documented by Caesar.

"All sides are committing international crimes," Crane said. "We're well beyond a good-guy, bad-guy scenario here. We just have human beings killing human beings at a scale that has not been seen since Rwanda."

Araud said the Russian delegate who attended asked a number of questions which Crane described as excellent, similar to what would likely be asked during a legal proceeding.

Crane added that Caesar's evidence was of very high quality.

"The photographs, the witness himself, are credible and sustainable in a court of law at the international or domestic level," he said.

French hopeful despite Russian veto

The French ambassador was asked why he was preparing to urge the Security Council to refer the case of Syria to the ICC when Moscow has made clear it would veto any attempt to do so.

Russia, supported by China, has vetoed three resolutions that would have condemned Assad's government, threatened sanctions and called for accountability for any war crimes.

"When you're a diplomat, you need to be hopeful," he said, adding that he was not going to demand a quick vote on the issue. "We are going to try to convince our Russian friends and the other members of the Security Council that it's a fair solution to a real problem."

"But I say to my 14 colleagues ... after the decision you make (on ICC referral), you will have to look yourselves in the mirror, look at yourselves and you will have to tell yourselves 'What did I do when it was the time?'," Araud said.

UN investigators have said the government has been responsible for most of the war crimes, though the opposition has committed them as well on a smaller scale. Western officials say Islamist extremists are responsible for war crimes committed on the side of the rebels.

Smuggled out images on memory card in shoe

Caesar was a senior sergeant in Syria's Army who spent 13 years working as a forensic photographer, Crane said.

Between September 2011 and August 2013, he worked at a military hospital, taking photos of bodies from three detention centers in the Damascus area. He smuggled copies of those photos out of the hospital on memory sticks hidden in his shoe.

"Caesar became a spy," said Crane. "The extraction of Caesar out of Syria is a Hollywood movie someday. It's a fascinating cover plan they put together (to get Caesar out of Syria)."

"They killed him and they told his family they killed him and they had a funeral while he's being extracted. Then the family was exfiltrated out and reunited with Caesar," he said. "Caesar's a hero."




Date created : 2014-04-16


    Syrian army retakes Christian town near border with Lebanon

    Read more


    War in Syria has turned in regime’s favour, Assad says

    Read more


    Syria rebels, government blame each other for new gas attack

    Read more