- Join the France 24 community here
- Log in
Latest update: 18/09/2011
- Mosque - Muslims - Nicolas Sarkozy - Paris
Short on mosques, Paris Muslims pray in fire station
Parisian Muslims escaped a government ban on street prayers Friday when some 5,000 worshippers piled into a makeshift mosque in the north of the capital.
After years of unfurling prayer mats on streets, pavements and in bicycle lanes, Parisian Muslims on Friday were finally able to put their foreheads to the ground somewhere they knew they weren’t stopping traffic. Not quite a mosque yet, their new place of worship is a 2,000-square-metre disused fire station in the north of the capital.
The building’s inauguration Friday afternoon, which saw thousands of Muslims welcomed from across Paris, also marked the first day of a ban on street prayers that had long been promised by France's right-wing government. “Praying in the streets will stop [on Friday],” Interior Minister Claude Gueant told French conservative daily Le Figaro Thursday. “We could go so far as to use force if needed,” he added, although he said he believed it unnecessary.
The Muslim community had scrambled to find a suitable space for the capital’s growing number of worshippers after Gueant, a close ally of President Nicolas Sarkozy, gave them until September 16 to get off the streets. “Prayers in the street are unacceptable, a direct attack on the principle of secularism,” he told AFP last month. Just two days before the deadline and after complex negotiations, local Muslim leaders signed a three-year deal with the authorities for the disused hangar.
While it still resembles little more than a fire station, the new “mosque” was commended by participants Friday, who recounted times when thousands of worshippers were forced to pray under the rain, unable to squeeze into their local mosque. “We used to be squashed in like sardines!”, one woman told FRANCE 24. “At least there’s more room here. And after all, a prayer is a prayer, why not have it in a fire station?”
Only a small minority of worshippers complained about the move, in the form of a tiny protest by a group of Salafi Muslims. “Brothers, wake up!” shouted one. “They’ve put us in here so we don’t pray in the street. But we should be able to pray where we like!”
Most of the surrounding crowd disagreed, however, arguing that it was against Islamic belief to bother your neighbour or block someone from going their way – which is what had been happening for over a decade as thousands of bodies spilled out from mosques onto the roads every Friday afternoon.
No praying in public before the election
French law stipulates that no show of religious allegiance is allowed in public, which is what makes praying in the street a punishable offence. But until recently, the law had only been enforced in state schools, where Jewish skullcaps, Muslim headscarves and Christian crucifixes are banned.
In spring this year, the government introduced a notorious “burqa ban”, banning women (and men, supposedly) from wearing the full Muslim veil. The move was widely viewed as a political one – an attempt by the unpopular Sarkozy administration to appease far-right voters before the presidential election next year. Gueant’s promise to rid the streets of praying Muslims is considered a similar ploy.
One woman visiting the mosque told an AP correspondent that while she was “really happy,” she didn’t believe it was “by chance that this plan is coming just before the presidential election ... this site has been sitting unused here for years.”
Most of the worshippers who turned up on Friday were largely unaware of any political implications, worrying more about practical matters. “It’s not clear where we should put our footwear,” one man told FRANCE 24, clasping his leather moccasins as he peered nervously at a mountain of shoes. Another mused about the building not facing directly towards Mecca, and another, about the cold in the winter.
But Sheikh Salah Hamza, an imam involved in the project, has got grand designs for the hangar. He’s pledged 80,000 euros towards the building, promising to turn it into a “five-star mosque” in the next three years.





































React to the article
(14) Reactions
Tiny minority? Sorry but it
Tiny minority? Sorry but it is on youtube and there are about five hundred still praying in the streets. Openly calling for civil war and to kill the Jews.
Even though I don't have one anymore. People do have their right
You may be entitled to believe that with, one caveat, whatever one believes one has NOT the right to inflict their belief on others.
When a group come together believing in something, they tend to formulate all sorts of rituals and tenets, once where they become a nuisance, as per the Christians of centuries, nowadays based on a ridiculous sort of infantile American bible thumping, along with the Muslims, currently infecting many parts of the globe, we call their grouping, 'religion'. It is that which effectively both annoys and creates problems for the world's populations.
No one, individually, or as a religious group, has the right to affect those who do not wish to believe or engage.
Believe what you will, but keep your beliefs and activities to yourself, and/or the 'club' to which you adhere.
Where democracy has been adopted, almost invariably the state from which that democracy has been formed, of necessity, to prevent fundamentalism taking it over, declares itself to be 'secular'
And so it must remain.
have u not seen the business
have u not seen the business lost in the fashion houses of france italy belgium after the hijab ban this govrtment is nuts
Events like this make me
Events like this make me proud/blessed to live in America where people are granted freedom of Speech and Religion...I mourn for all the religious groups in France who cannot worship God for the sake of "secularism." Just as worshipping in the streets supposedly violates secularism, secularism forces an entity's belief on the religious groups.
I wonder what's holding the right of religion up anymore.
Even though I don't have one anymore. People do have their rights to believe in something though.
Duh
Why, oh why are the muslems in europe always bitching if the country they live in don't appreciate to be turned into a desert slum? I you so dont like european culture, who keeps you here? Go live in your precios mecca.
Praying in the Streets of Paris
A ban on men praying on the streets of Paris finally enforced? Good. Next, let's enforce the ban on men peeing on the streets of Paris.
By the way, 'deprived' is not the correct vocabulary choice. I wonder which news organization is responsible for the web headline. And to Charles G ... Places of worship are financed and built by members of a faith, not given to them by government. It is not the government's role (in European countries or in the USA) to provide places of worship (a private behavior)and in Paris this group simply did not build a community center or place of worship. They have overtaken the public streets for years. They were in violation of public law from day one. Streets were totally blocked. I don't understand why it took so long to address.
-- An American in Paris
Huh, the street prayers were
Huh, the street prayers were limited to TWO streets and to the Goutte d'Or neighborhood, if someone can explain why our so-called journalists try to deceive us and to generalize this to the whole Paris area fell free to do so...
Comment on Mosque "deprivation"
How are the Muslims of Paris deprived of anything since they are not due anything. Tho Free Church in France is the one that is constantly deprived of the ability to rent and buy space by inequitable enforcement of zoning laws. Public prayer in the streets violates French law and failure of the police to enforce French law for years is the real scandal here.
Misleading title
How is ANYONE deprived of a mosque? Saying you can't pray in the streets is not even remotely the same as depriving someone of a mosque. This title is misleading, likely on purpose. And regarding the comment above, why is it the government of France's place to offer ANYONE a place to pray? That's utterly ridiculous.