Latest update: 16/01/2012 

- accident - Italy - tourism


Cruise ship operator blames captain for fatal accident

The company Costa Cruises on Monday blamed Captain Francesco Schettino (photo) for Friday's accident in which a 4,000-passenger cruise ship ran aground, killing at least six people. They denied the ship's size was a factor in the accident.

By Achren ALLAHVERDIAN / Nicolas Rushworth (video)
News Wires (text)
 

REUTERS - The operator of a cruise ship that ran aground off Italy’s west coast blamed the captain for the accident, saying on Monday his actions had caused the disaster in which at least six people died.

At a news conference in Genoa, the head of Costa Cruises, a unit of Carnival Corp, rejected suggestions that the sheer size of the cruise ship had made it impossible to evacuate the more than 4,000 people onboard safely.

“These ships are ultra-safe. It is an exceptional event, which was unforeseeable,” Chairman and chief executive Pier Luigi Foschi said, fighting back tears as he answered questions.

Captain 'jumps ship' before passengers

The captain of the Costa Concordia left the stricken cruise liner "well before" the last passengers were evacuated, the prosecutor in charge of investigating the disaster said Sunday.

             
Asked on the news channel SkyTG24 whether captain Francesco Schettino, arrested Saturday for multiple homicide, had left the liner "well before all the passengers were evacuated," prosecutor Francesco Verusio replied: "Unfortunately I can confirm that."
             
The prosecutor also indicated that the ship "was not on the right course", adding that the captain was on the bridge and "therefore responsible for operations."
             
He said the possible responsibility of other persons apart from the captain and his number two, Ciro Ambrosio, was also being investigated.
             
Asked whether the crew were not properly prepared, Verusio said "It was rather the system of command which did not function as it should have done."
             
Italian media reports have said the captain was on shore around 11.40 pm (2240 GMT) Friday while the last passengers were not evacuated until 0500 GMT Saturday.
             
Ennio Aquilino, in charge of the rescue operation, told AFP Saturday: "The last person we took off the ship around 6 am (0500 GMT) had a broken leg."

“The company will be close to the captain and will provide him with all the necessary assistance, but we need to acknowledge the facts and we cannot deny human error,” he said.

The 114,500-tonne Costa Concordia vessel capsized on Friday night as passengers were sitting down to dinner and now lies on its side near the port of Giglio off the Tuscan coast.

Captain Francesco Schettino was arrested on Saturday and accused of manslaughter and abandoning the ship before all of the people were evacuated. With rescue operations suspended on Monday morning, 16 people were still unaccounted for.

Foschi said the ship had deviated from the correct route when it hit rocks near the coast, tearing a large hole in the hull, and that the captain had contravened company’s safety procedures.

“The company disavows such behaviour, which caused the accident,” he said.

Prosecutors have accused Schettino, who has worked for Costa Crociere since 2002 and was promoted to captain in 2006, of leaving the ship before the evacuation was complete.

Coastguard officials have said he had refused to return to the vessel when asked to.

Foschi said the company had not had access to internal communication records but had “internal witness accounts” suggesting the captain stayed on board for a long time after the accident. He said the rest of the crew behaved like “heroes”.

Schettino has told Italian television the ship hit rocks that were not marked on maps and were not detected by navigation systems. He said the accident occurred 300 metres from shore.

 

Foschi said 2,300 tonnes of fuel were aboard the vessel but that there was no sign of leakage so far, as concerns grew of an impending environmental disaster if the giant ship breaks apart.

He said removing such a big vessel from its rocky resting place would be “one of the most difficult things in the world.”

The priority would be to seal any holes caused by the accident, and then the ship could possibly be lifted by giant balloons and towed away.

But he said he could not rule out that the ship would have to be cut into pieces in order to be removed from the scene.

Foschi said the accident would likely hurt the cruise industry in the short-term but did not expect a lasting fallout.

“We have one million loyal customers are hoping that the reputation of our company will be repaired.”

 

Read more
React to the article
Comment this article typing your message in the above text zone. Please note that this is limited to 1500 characters or less.
(2) Reactions

Costa Concordia disaster

I find the comments for Costa's heirachy rather strange in that they have decided that the captain is at fault - he may well be - but that is for a court of inquiry to decide and not a management which appears in the press to have provided no evidence to its accusations. How do they know that the route was pre-planned into the navigation system correctly? If it was pre-planned in then the ship will have been on autopilot and it would have been with only a monitoring watch being kept. Can the management be absolutely sure that the ship's GPS was working correctly, was in fact providing true data to the computerised navigation system? I'm afraid the Costa management cannot provide that information until the ship's 'black box' has been examined by independent examiners. Anyone who has worked with any sort of computer system knows that somewhere along the line it will foul up, regardless of the number of checks in the system - its the nature of the beasties. So until more evidence is produced then I suggest that the Costa management watch what they say. As has been reported by all the worlds press and media, this disaster could have been caused by human error, technical error or a combination of both, it is up to an inquiry to produce the results and quickly.

That there are other areas of concern doesn't surprise me as the majority of the crew are not 'sailors', they are 'hotel' staff or entertainers. This sort of manning disparity is not confined to Costa but to every company which runs cruise ships.
The number of 'deck' sailors and engineers is an extremely small number of a cruise ships crew.

Poor bloke, sounds like he

Poor bloke, sounds like he just took a wrong turn. We've all done it.

Close