Macron aide Benalla detained for beating May Day protester

Lionel Bonaventure, AFP | File photo from March 1, 2017, showing French presidential candidate Emmanuel Macron (C), flanked by head of security Alexandre Benalla (R), shaking hands as he visits Paris's international agriculture fair.

France's Emmanuel Macron fired the head of his personal security detail Friday but faced criticism for failing to act sooner, after video was released showing the man posing as a police officer and beating a protester while off duty in May.


Alexandre Benalla, who as Macron's top bodyguard has long been a fixture by his side, was taken into custody for police questioning over the incident, which took place when Benalla appeared at May Day protests in a riot helmet and police tags.

He had initially been suspended for just 15 days and allowed to return to work. Just days ago he was seen in public helping to organise security for celebrations for the return of France's World Cup champion soccer team.

Lawmakers have launched a six-month parliamentary inquiry into the incident itself, the lenient initial punishment, the failure of the authorities to report Benalla promptly to the judiciary, and the broader question of “the circumstances under which people who aren’t members of the security forces have been or may be involved in policing duties”.

FRANCE 24's Chris Moore reports

In the footage, which was released on Wednesday by Le Monde newspaper, Benalla can be seen dragging a woman away from a protest and later beating a male demonstrator. On Friday, French media released a second video which showed Benalla also manhandling the woman.

He had been given permission by the president's office to attend the protests as an observer of the security operation, but had no authorisation to take part in police work.

The president's office brushed off accusations that it had responded only because the nearly three-month-old videos had become public. It said the decision had now been taken to fire Benalla because the bodyguard had improperly obtained a document while trying to make his case over the accusations.

"New facts that could constitute a misdemeanour by Alexandre Benalla were brought to the president's attention," an official at the presidential palace told Reuters. "As a result ... the presidency has decided to start Alexandre Benalla's dismissal procedure."

FRANCE 24's Marc Perelman gives his analysis

Delayed response

Critics of Macron called the president's delayed response a characteristic sign that he is out of touch. It follows controversies over government spending on official crockery, a swimming pool at a presidential retreat and cutting remarks by the president about the costs of welfare.

After hours of debate in the lower house on Thursday, lawmakers agreed to launch a parliamentary inquiry.

"Why did he protect this person? Does he head up a parallel police force? Refusing to answer makes (Macron) complicit in these acts of violence," Eric Ciotti, a senior member of the conservative Republicans party, said on Twitter.

Video grab taken on July 19, 2018, from footage filmed on May 1, 2018, shows a man identified as Élysée Chief Security Officer Alexandre Benalla wearing a police visor as he drags away a demonstrator during May 1 protests in Paris.
Video grab taken on July 19, 2018, from footage filmed on May 1, 2018, shows a man identified as Élysée Chief Security Officer Alexandre Benalla wearing a police visor as he drags away a demonstrator during May 1 protests in Paris. Taha Bouhafs/AFP

Several French media outlets reported that Interior Minister Gérard Collomb, who on Thursday asked for an internal police investigation into the incident, had been aware of the video on May 2, the day after it was filmed.

The parliamentary inquiry will interview Collomb “early next week”, its members announced on Thursday.

Judicial sources said Benalla was now being questioned both over the incident itself and over his acquiring police footage of the incident after Le Monde reported the story. Three police officers were suspended on Friday, including two suspected of passing footage to Benalla, the interior ministry said.

A second man, who worked for Macron's political party and was alongside Benalla during the protests and also seen manhandling a protestor, was also taken into custody on Friday, judicial sources said.

Police also questioned Macron's chief of staff, Patrick Strzoda, who initially handled the matter in May.

After the 15-day suspension, Benalla was brought back into the president's immediate entourage. He appears in many photos alongside Macron during public events and private trips, including a skiing holiday in December.

"This is an extremely bad phase for the president and I am not sure that reacting late will change the situation," Jean-Daniel Levy, a political analyst for Harris pollsters told Reuters. "It reinforces the image of a rather authoritarian person who sometimes shows arrogance."


Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning