Stocks tumble as Italy defies EU with public spending hike
Issued on: Modified:
Italy's new government proposed a 2019 budget with a deficit three times bigger than the previous administration's target, setting up a clash with the European Commission and sparking a sell-off of state bonds.
Italy has the heaviest debt burden among big European Union economies, at 131 percent of gross domestic product. It is under pressure from the EU to rein in spending amid fears it could sow the seeds of a debt crisis in the euro zone.
Late on Thursday night, the four-month-old government proposed a budget that would target a deficit of 2.4 percent of GDP for the next three years. The spending would fund more welfare spending, tax cuts and a boost to public infrastructure investment.
It marked a victory for the ruling parties over Economy Minister Giovanni Tria, an unaffiliated technocrat whom investors had considered a comparative fiscal conservative.
Tria had wanted a deficit as low as 1.6 percent of GDP next year, hoping to meet EU demands that Italy progressively reduce the fiscal gap to rein in its debt.
The euro slumped on the news overnight, then recovered. Italian bonds were set for their worst day in over three months and banking shares swooned, though fears of a selloff were avoided.
"They seem to be on a collision course with Brussels," said ING rates strategist Martin van Vliet.
A deficit of 2.4 percent of GDP remains under the 3.0 percent ceiling prescribed by EU rules, but Italy had promised Brussels it would cut the deficit to reduce its huge debt.
Nothing would be gained from a clash with Italy, European Economics Commissioner Pierre Moscovici said, but he added, "We don't have any interest either that Italy does not respect the rules and does not reduce its debt, which remains explosive."
Italian Deputy Prime Minister Luigi Di Maio retorted that the new budget would spur economic growth, boost revenues and allow the debt to fall as a percentage of output.
The European Commission said on Friday it would assess the budget plan, along with those of other euro zone members, in the weeks after their formal presentation by Oct. 15.
Rome will "press ahead" even if Brussels rejects the budget, said Italy's other deputy prime minister, Matteo Salvini.
Di Maio leads the anti-establishment 5-Star Movement and Salvini the right-wing League. The two parties took power in June, promising to slash taxes and ramp up spending on welfare.
Alberto Bagnai, a prominent League lawmaker close to Salvini, advised the EU against a battle with Rome while it dealt with Britain's exit from the bloc.
"If it wants to open a second front in Italy, then be my guest," he said in a radio interview.
The budget also risks running afoul of ratings agencies, which were waiting for Italy's fiscal plans before reconsidering their ratings on Italy's sovereign debt. Moody's, which has a negative outlook on Italy's Baa2 rating, said it would pass judgment by the end of October.
Salvini and Di Maio had pushed Tria to increase the deficit sharply to fund their campaign promises. Tria had been holding out for something below 2.0 percent. The previous administration had targeted a deficit of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2019 and a balanced budget in 2020.
Last year's deficit came in at 2.4 percent of GDP and this year's was set at 1.6 percent, although it's unclear whether the 2018 goal will be maintained.
Tria has not commented, but Di Maio and other government officials said he had no intention of resigning. Salvini said on Friday Tria's position had "never been in doubt."
Di Maio said the 2019 budget, which must be presented by Oct. 20, will set aside 10 billion euros ($11.6 billion) for 5-Star's flagship "citizens' income" of up to 780 euros per month for 6.5 million poor Italians.
He said it will also include 15 billion euros of public investment. Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte promised "the biggest programme of public investments ever carried out in Italy."
Salvini said the budget would also allow people to retire earlier, opening about 400,000 jobs for the young, and cut tax rates for a million self-employed workers.