Stranded migrant rescue ship Open Arms refuses to leave Italian waters

Alessandro Serrano, AFP | The Italian Guardia di Finanza boat sails towards the Spanish migrant rescue NGO ship Open Arms to retrieve 27 unaccompanied minors and take them to the Italian island of Lampedusa on August 17, 2019.

The commanders of a rescue ship with 98 migrants aboard declined to leave Italian waters on Monday, saying that its resources were exhausted and suggesting that Italy's Coast Guard should take the migrants to Spain.


The Open Arms ship, run by a Spanish charity of the same name, has been stranded at sea for 18 days, with the charity saying that the migrants are distressed and in no condition to sail to Spain in such cramped conditions on board.

Italian Transport Minister Danilo Toninelli said late on Monday Italy was ready to take all the migrants to a Spanish port, though it was not immediately clear if the offer was conditional.

"Spain should first, in its turn, take a step forward and immediately remove its flag from the (charity) ship," Toninelli said in a comment on his Facebook page.

Italy bans private rescue ships from bringing migrants ashore, saying it has borne too much responsibility for handling African migration to Europe. Interior Minister Matteo Salvini says the ships have become "taxis" for people smugglers.

'We are in a state of humanitarian emergency,' Open Arms's Laura Lanuza tells France 24

Late on Monday eight migrants that needed urgent assistance and another one accompanying them were evacuated to the Italian port of Lampedusa after being authorized to do so, an Open Arms spokeswoman said.

"We have exhausted physically, morally and technically the few resources that this organisation has in this moment," Open Arms' director and founder, Oscar Camps, told Reuters on Monday.

Camps said the Italian Coast Guard had offered to provide an escort and to carry some of the migrants to end the standoff, which he says is at crisis point. Migrants sleep jammed together on the deck, with two toilets for about 100 people. Some are suicidal and close to mental breakdown, Open Arms said.

Camps said Open Arms wanted the Coast Guard to take all the migrants to Spain.

"(I say) that they not only carry a part but carry them all and that they carry them in a safe and dignified way," he said.

Toninelli said Italy had offered to accompany Open Arms to Spain, provide support, and transfer part of the migrants to one of its vessels for the trip.

"The NGO incredibly refused with an attitude that makes us suspect bad faith on their part," he said.

If a solution is not found, Open Arms has not ruled out the option of defying Italy's ban and attempting to dock. The ship has been sitting for days off Lampedusa, watched by an Italian patrol boat stationed nearby.

Asked if the ship would try and enter the port without permission, Open Arms' head of mission in Lampedusa, Riccardo Gatti, replied: "Yes it is an option".

The standoff has fuelled Salvini's campaign against migrant boats from Africa at a time when he is striving to drag Italy to snap elections. The ruling coalition, in danger of collapse this week, has split over the issue.

Salvini allowed 27 minors to leave the boat on Saturday, saying he was only doing so on the prime minister's instructions, and has cast doubt on Open Arms' statement that the migrants' physical and mental wellbeing is at crisis point.

Spain's left-wing government offered on Monday to allow the ship to land in a Spanish port, and it and five other European Union nations have offered to take the migrants.

The details of the offers from France, Germany, Romania, Portugal, Spain and Luxembourg have yet to be finalised. The European Commission said it was trying to "facilitate a solution which would allow the people on board the boat to disembark".

Coastguard vessel

If the Open Arms attempts to dock in Lampedusa, it could face resistance from a coastguard vessel stationed near the mouth of the port - a scene that played out in June when the captain of another charity ship defied Salvini's ban.

Carola Rackete, captain of a ship run by German charity Sea-Watch, took her ship into Lampedusa, squeezing a patrol boat against the quay as she docked. She was arrested but later freed from house arrest, and she still faces possible charges of aiding illegal immigration and defying official orders.

Under new laws introduced by Salvini, ships that enter Italian waters without authorisation face a fine of up to 1 million euros ($1.11 million). The ships can also be seized.

Spain's acting defence minister, Margarita Robles, said Salvini was putting human lives at risk for "absolutely electoral reasons", adding: "What Salvini is doing regarding the Open Arms is a shame for all humanity."


Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning