Notre-Dame Cathedral 'not yet totally saved' six months after devastating fire

Notre Dame Cathedral shown as work continues to stabilise the monument’s structure six months after a fire caused significant damage, in Paris, France, on October 15, 2019.
Notre Dame Cathedral shown as work continues to stabilise the monument’s structure six months after a fire caused significant damage, in Paris, France, on October 15, 2019. Charles Platiau, Reuters

Melted scaffolding atop fire-ravaged Notre Dame Cathedral will be removed “in the coming weeks” to allow restoration work to begin next year, France’s culture minister said Tuesday.


It’s been six months since an April 15 fire gutted the medieval Paris structure, which was under renovation at the time and crisscrossed with scaffolding where its spire once stood.

The twisted metal remained in place after the fire as engineers tried to determine whether removing it would exacerbate structural weaknesses from the blaze.

French Culture Minister Franck Riester said that before rebuilding can begin, several more months of conservation work done in parallel with an evaluation of the cathedral’s soundness need to be completed.

“Our Notre Dame de Paris is not yet totally saved,” Riester told reporters.

Five-year goal

President Emmanuel Macron promised in April that France’s beloved landmark would be restored within five years. Critics say his timeline is overly ambitious.

The culture minister offered few hard deadlines. He told reporters Tuesday that the French government prioritises quality over speed, though he said the five-year timeframe represents the state’s “ambition to mobilise”.

“For us, the top priority is to do a quality restoration that captures the height of what our history represents for our country, for Paris, for the Catholic religion, for Notre Dame,” Riester said.

The government has not settled on a particular path for reconstruction. Riester promised wide consultation and debate. As head of state, Macron has the final word because the French government owns Notre Dame.

“We are determined to do things in a totally transparent manner,” Riester said.

The budget for the project also remains undecided. Some 350,000 donors have given or pledged a total of €922 million ($1.02 billion), according to Riester.

The Notre Dame Foundation has received €104 million ($114 million) to date.

Lead contamination fears

Riester also addressed public criticism that French officials were slow to recognize the potential harmful effects of melted lead from the cathedral’s roof that drifted into the air and onto surfaces below.

He said health officials take regular samples from areas around Notre Dame to check for lead, and that workers on the site take appropriate precautions.

Authorities ran 877 lead tests on people in surrounding neighborhoods at risk of exposure to lead pollution from the fire and only 10 showed dangerously elevated levels, Riester said.

In its update at the six-month mark on the lead contamination situation surrounding the Notre-Dame fire, the Regional Health Agency (ARS) noted that the 877 blood-lead screenings had been conducted on children in the 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th arrondissements after the fire. Young children are particularly vulnerable to health problems from lead exposure.

Twelve of the children showed levels above 50 micrograms per litre of blood, the level denoting lead poisoning in children. Another 78 showed levels below 50 micrograms but above 25, the “level of vigilance” that requires follow-up care.

(FRANCE 24 with AP and AFP)

Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning