Russia slams European rights court’s ‘unlawful’ order to free Navalny

Alexei Navalny at a court hearing in Moscow.
Alexei Navalny at a court hearing in Moscow. © Handout Moscow's Babushkinsky district court press service,AFP

Russia's justice minister on Wednesday dismissed as "unlawful" a European Court of Human Rights ruling that demanded the release of Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny, accusing the court of meddling in the Russian judicial system. 


The Strasbourg-based court (ECHR) said it had ruled on Tuesday to "indicate to the Government of Russia" that it should with immediate effect free Navalny, whose arrest and jailing have sparked anti-Kremlin protests in Russia.

It said that the ruling was taken with "regard to the nature and extent of risk to the applicant's life".

Navalny, 44, appealed to the European Court of Human Rights for his release on January 20, just days after his arrest at a Moscow airport, saying his life was in danger if he remained in custody.

Russia is a member of the Council of Europe, a rights body of which the ECHR is a part. Member states are obliged to enforce ECHR decisions and in the past Russia has done so, including in cases involving Navalny.

But shortly after the court made its decision public, Russia's justice ministry said its demands were "unreasonable and unlawful" and there were no legal grounds to release Navalny. 

Justice Minister Konstantin Chuychenko told the Interfax news agency that the ECHR demands represented "clear and gross interference" in the activities of Russia's justice system.

According to constitutional changes introduced in Russia last year, decisions enforced by international treaties may not be executed if they contradict Russia's basic law. 

Back in court on Saturday

Navalny is being held in a Moscow detention centre after a court ruled earlier this month to convert a suspended sentence for fraud he was handed in 2014 to nearly three years in jail over alleged violations of parole terms. 

The ECHR had in 2017 ruled that the decision in that case was "arbitrary" and ordered Russia to pay compensation to Navalny and his brother Oleg, who served jail time. 

Navalny will be back in court on Saturday to appeal his jailing in that case and in another trial where he is facing charges of defamation for calling a World War II veteran and others who appeared in pro-Kremlin video "traitors".

The prosecution has asked the court to fine Navalny 950,000 rubles ($13,000/ €10,600) in the defamation case.

In his complaint to the ECHR, Navalny argued that the Russian government could not provide "sufficient safeguards" for his life and health while he is in custody. 

Navalny fell violently ill on a flight over Siberia last August and was airlifted to Berlin for treatment. Western scientists later concluded that he was poisoned with a Soviet-era nerve toxin, Novichok.

While Navalny, whose investigations into the lavish lifestyles of Russia's elite have infuriated many in power, says Putin ordered the attack, the Kremlin has repeatedly denied any involvement.

Decision 'binding' say Navalny's allies

Navalny's allies on Wednesday insisted that Russia must continue to follow the ECHR's decisions. 

"This must happen, it simply cannot be otherwise given that the European Convention (on Human Rights) is part of Russian legislation," his lawyer Olga Mikhailova told AFP. 

"Russia has always complied with such decisions and will carry it out now," Ivan Zhdanov, a key Navalny aide and lawyer by training, wrote on Telegram. 

The head of Navalny's regional network, Leonid Volkov, said the decision is "binding" for Russia under its obligations as a member of the Council of Europe. 

He said that non-compliance could lead to Russia's exclusion from the council and to "numerous and far-reaching consequences", such as the rupture of a number of international agreements. 

Other Council of Europe members have refused to enforce the court's rulings, including Turkey which has rejected calls by the court to release a Kurdish political leader and a civil society figure accused of involvement in a 2016 coup attempt.

(FRANCE 24 with AFP, AP and REUTERS)

Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning