France begins consultation on steps to improve confidence in police

Riot police pictured at a rally in Paris on January 16, 2021.
Riot police pictured at a rally in Paris on January 16, 2021. © Gonzalo Fuentes, Reuters

The French government began a public consultation on Monday aimed at devising ways to increase public confidence in the police following repeated scandals involving allegations of racism and police brutality.


The initiative was proposed by President Emmanuel Macron in December in order to diffuse criticism of French security forces which are regularly accused of discrimination and using excessive force.

In November, video of Paris police beating and abusing a black music producer inside his studio shocked the country, drawing a rare rebuke from Macron's government.

The incident came days after the brutal clearing of a migrant camp in the centre of the capital and months after hundreds of thousands took part in huge protests against police racism and brutality.

>> As George Floyd outrage spreads, France confronts its own demons

During months of anti-government demonstrations by "Yellow vest" protesters in 2018-2019, around 20 people lost an eye and dozens were seriously injured by police rubber bullets and stun grenades.

"We need to act urgently," Macron wrote on December 8 when announcing the consultation to "consolidate" the link between the police and the French population, which is expected to last until May.

"I want to advance quickly and concretely to improve the working conditions for the noble and essential job of keeping the peace," he added. "France hangs together through its police and gendarmes."

Balancing act

Pitching the idea as both a listening exercise and a way of improving working conditions for officers is a sign of the delicate balancing act faced by the head of state.

Despite wide-ranging demands for better community relations, Macron is aware that officers are on the front lines of often violent streets protests, as well as anti-terror operations.

He angered police unions when he acknowledged in December that identity checks carried out by security forces targeted ethnic minorities disproportionately – a common complaint from residents in high-immigration areas, which has been corroborated by numerous studies.


"When you have a skin colour that is not white, you are stopped much more. You are identified as a problem factor. And that cannot be justified," he told the Brut video website.

>> Racism, sex abuse and impunity: French police’s toxic legacy in the suburbs

Yves Lefebvre, a trade union leader, wrote to him afterwards to complain, saying that the fault lay in "decades of urbanisation policies that have piled up immigrant populations in the same areas".

The consultations will see police union leaders, former officers and local mayors invited to give their opinions in a process overseen by hardline Interior Minister Gérald Darminin.

Darmanin is also set to tour the country to meet local officers, but it remains unclear how much civil society groups and academics will be asked to contribute.

Controversial security law

The conclusions are set to inform a new draft security law which will be brought before parliament before France holds a presidential election in the first half of 2022.

A previous draft sparked protests in November and December over a clause that would have criminalised publishing images identifying on-duty officers.

Long-standing proposals for improving confidence in French security forces include more local policing focused on problem-solving, rather than simply repression, and a truly independent police complaints process.

>> ‘A lack of public trust’: France mulls reform of country’s police watchdog

Critics have dismissed the latest consultations as a PR exercise.

Interior Minister Darmanin made his views on police brutality clear in July last year in the wake of the killing in the United States of George Floyd, a black man who choked to death while being arrested.

"When I hear the words police violence, personally it makes me choke," Darmanin told a parliamentary hearing.

France saw its biggest anti-racism protests in decades in the wake of the George Floyd killing in the US.
France saw its biggest anti-racism protests in decades in the wake of the George Floyd killing in the US. © Gonzalo Fuentes, Reuters

The start of the public consultation comes just days after six non-governmental organisations launched a class-action lawsuit to press the French government into tackling systemic discrimination by police carrying out identity checks.

The organisations, including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, served Prime Minister Jean Castex and Darmanin with formal legal notice of demands for concrete steps to ensure that police stop targeting Black people and people of Arab descent in their ID checks.

The lead lawyer in the case, Antoine Lyon-Caen, said that the legal action is not targeting individual police officers but "the system itself that generates, by its rules, habits, culture, a discriminatory practice".

(FRANCE 24 with AFP)


Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning

Take international news everywhere with you! Download the France 24 app